Can this team beat most ATG test X1?

[maniac]

Players who are good and consistent from 2000 onwards but don’t get the recognition or not talked about much even though they played some clutch knocks or bowled great spells. Names that are only when  brought up, people realize how good they were.

 

To avoid conflicts I am excluding Indian players.

 

Picking players who are underrated or are better than what we think they are/were.

 

 

Justin Langer

Greame Smith

Younis Khan

Jayawerdana (c)

Ross Taylor

Mark Boucher (wk)

Jason Holder

Jason Gillespee

Morne Morkel

Rangana Herat 

Nathan Lyon

 

Reserves based on conditions: Neil Wagner, Danish Kaneria, Andrew Strauss

[zen]

Below is an ATG 11 from 2000 onwards: 

 

Hayden

Sangakkara 

Ponting

Lara

S Waugh

Kallis 

GIlly

Warne 

Steyn 

Murali

Mcgrath 

 

 

Edited November 5, 2021 by zen

[maniac]

1 minute ago, zen said:

Below is an ATGish 11 from 2000s onwards: 

 

Hayden

Sangakkara 

Ponting

Lara

S Waugh

Kallis 

GIlly

Warne 

Steyn 

Murali

Mcgrath 

 

 

can they dominate the team in the OP or not?

 

I think that underrated team I posted can beat most ATG teams on their day, in fact even capable of winning a series in a best of 3, beat of 5 contests.

Edited November 5, 2021 by maniac

[maniac]

Basically ATG lists are meaningless. That’s the point of the thread.

[zen]

Just now, maniac said:

can they dominate the team in the OP or not?

 

I think that underrated team I posted can beat most ATG teams on their day, in fact even capable of winning a series in a best of 3, beat of 5 contests.

Can, Yes; Will, No

[maniac]

1 minute ago, zen said:

Can, Yes; Will, No

why not? Is Ross Taylor or Jaya or G.Smith/Langer   Lesser talents or clutch than most ATG names?

[zen]

Just now, maniac said:

why not? Is Ross Taylor or Jaya or G.Smith/Langer   Lesser talents or clutch than most ATG names?

ATG 11 has phenomenal batting and bowling skills. 

 

 

[Jay]

1 hour ago, maniac said:

Players who are good and consistent from 2000 onwards but don’t get the recognition or not talked about much even though they played some clutch knocks or bowled great spells. Names that are only when  brought up, people realize how good they were.

 

To avoid conflicts I am excluding Indian players.

 

Picking players who are underrated or are better than what we think they are/were.

 

 

Justin Langer

Greame Smith

Younis Khan

Jayawerdana (c)

Ross Taylor

Mark Boucher (wk)

Jason Holder

Jason Gillespee

Morne Morkel

Rangana Herat 

Nathan Lyon

 

Reserves based on conditions: Neil Wagner, Danish Kaneria, Andrew Strauss

lol how will this team beat india in india captained by rahane? even kohli actually. 

how will this team beat aussies of 2000-2006? 

[Vijy]

Most teams with random compilations of players (call it World XI), however talented, would struggle to beat high-level national teams even if individually the World XI is better. this was clearly illustrated in the Super Test organized by the ICC

[rkt.india]

On 11/5/2021 at 7:41 PM, maniac said:

can they dominate the team in the OP or not?

 

I think that underrated team I posted can beat most ATG teams on their day, in fact even capable of winning a series in a best of 3, beat of 5 contests.

No way. Their bowling is too weak in comparison to the ATG team.

[First class]

On 11/5/2021 at 10:02 AM, maniac said:

Players who are good and consistent from 2000 onwards but don’t get the recognition or not talked about much even though they played some clutch knocks or bowled great spells. Names that are only when  brought up, people realize how good they were.

 

To avoid conflicts I am excluding Indian players.

 

Picking players who are underrated or are better than what we think they are/were.

 

 

Justin Langer

Greame Smith

Younis Khan

Jayawerdana (c)

Ross Taylor

Mark Boucher (wk)

Jason Holder

Jason Gillespee

Morne Morkel

Rangana Herat 

Nathan Lyon

 

Reserves based on conditions: Neil Wagner, Danish Kaneria, Andrew Strauss

Only Mark Boucher from this list had the potential to compete any ALG keeper, rest were not ALG , because they were not of that caliber , very good crickters but not ALG.

[express bowling]

I will make  Test 11s from 2015 onwards ....

 

Tests In Asia ....

 

 

 

1. Rohit

2. Pujara

3. Root

4. S.Smith

5. Kohli

6. Pant

7. Jadeja

8. Ashwin

9. Yasir

10. Shami

11. Bumrah

 

 

Tests In England and NZ ....

 

1. Cook

2. Latham

3. Root

4. Williamson

5  S.Smith

6. Stokes

7. Shakib

8. Watling

9. Steyn

10. Bumrah

11. Anderson

 

 

Tests In Australia, South Africa, WI

 

1. Warner

2. Amla

3. S.Smith

4. Kohli

5. ABDV

6. Pant

7.Jadeja

8. Cummins

9. Rabada

10. Bumrah

11. Steyn