Will Rohit keep his test spot vs Kiwis?

[psrb4u]

I don't think that his such a poor performance will make him a place in the squad.

[Sooda]

Gambhir, Rahane, Pujara, Tendulkar, Sehwag, Kohli, MSD, Ashwin, Ojha, Umesh Zaheer Rohit, Dinda, A. Spinner, O. Pener

[diga]

I just hope that he goes away either to South Africa or Australia to play club cricket, if BCCI doesnt allow people to play in English county ckt and improve his shot selection & escape from the constant focus on him. BTW, I have heard of his binge drinking habits? Is that true?

[cowboysfan]

He should play in the tests,he can play.at his own pace in the test matches.

[Number]

These JamODIs are inconsequential. I'd still drop Laxman and play Rohit in the XI.

[Tendulkar_Bhai]

I would do the same as above but VVS will not be dropped. He should be in the team but definately should not play in place of Pujara, who must be given the number 3 spot. Is he on a bad run or at 26 years old should have been playing at his peak by now? I think he should be given a run in tests as he has proved in ODI's he cant play under pressure and is our most talented youngster.

[Ultimate_Game]

These JamODIs are inconsequential. I'd still drop Laxman and play Rohit in the XI.

Spot on :two_thumbs_up: My team for kiwis... Sehwag Gambhir Pujara Tendulkar Kohli Rohit Dhoni Ashwin Zak Umesh Ojha 12th man: Rahane Hopefully the youngsters do well and when Tendulkar hangs up his boots Rahane to replace him.

[Vilander]

Test and ODI's should not be confused. Rohit should get his spot.

[vamos_rafa]

^ Not before Pujara though.

[Ultimate_Game]

^ Not before Pujara though.

True. For me the depth chart for the batsmen is... 1. Pujara 2. Rohit 3. Rahane 4. Tiwary, Raina 5. Mukund, Shikhar Dhawan

[vamos_rafa]

True. For me the depth chart for the batsmen is... 1. Pujara 2. Rohit 3. Rahane 4. Tiwary, Raina 5. Mukund, Shikhar Dhawan

I agree with the top 3, but I am still not convinced with Tiwary. He needs to play a bit more IMO. Of whatever little I have seen of him, I am not convinced by his technique.

[Ultimate_Game]

I agree with the top 3' date=' but I am still not convinced with Tiwary. He needs to play a bit more IMO. Of whatever little I have seen of him, I am not convinced by his technique.[/quote'] That's why he's at 4 in the depth chart I can't see any other player ahead of him. Maybe that Jharkhand opener (is it Ishank Jaggi?) may come out of nowhere and leapfrog the chart but at the moment Tiwary deserves to be at 4 after the usual suspects.

[Cricket Tragic]

No Dhawan please.

[jusarrived]

if the selectors are smart , he wont . Sharma has always been a confused player in ODI's ..but his approach for T20 and Tests is sorted .

[jj_28]

I doubt it Pujara Raina will come first

[Number]

I doubt it Pujara Raina will come first

No way he should be selected. As much as I'm a fan of his attitude, but atm he doesn't deserve it. Even last season in Ranji, he did nothing special to be considered.

[velu]

i would take 42 year sachin over 25 year old Rohit :mad: i would say rohit's commitment towards the game is not even50% of what sachin gives

[Old guy]

i would take 42 year sachin over 25 year old Rohit :mad: i would say rohit's commitment towards the game is not even50% of what sachin gives

:hmmm: but he plays all games :--D

[velu]

:hmmm: but he plays all games :--D

nothing much will change if we play with 10 players instead of rohit.. even sir jaddu will do fancy haircuts to motivate the team .. after Dada era in 2005 , if i can relate 2 minute maggi noodle , then it has to be Rohit :orderorder:

[Old guy]

nothing much will change if we play with 10 players instead of rohit.. even sir jaddu will do fancy haircuts to motivate the team .. after Dada era in 2005 , if i can relate 2 minute maggi noodle , then it has to be Rohit :orderorder:

but heres the problem guy will even play next game and will probably end up debuting in test ahead of pujara .. based on playing well in nets ok if we dont consider odis to be good judge of player then why should nets be ? :sniffle: