who can do a better job than Sachin in SA?

[trundlerNO1]

Many are asking him to step down, can anyone give me any good replacement name that will do better job than Sachin in SA Not just Name, give the reason as well why he will do better than Sachin in SA(alien like condition)

[philcric]

Ravindra Jadeja ? Reason: Because he is Ravindra Jadeja.

[Laaloo]

anyone who averages more than 31

[trundlerNO1]

anyone who averages more than 31

in SA who is that guy?

[vvvslaxman]

in SA who is that guy?

Dinesh karthik averages 60 :cantstop:

[saneindian]

How would you know without giving an opportunity to a youngster?

[adi B]

How would you know without giving an opportunity to a youngster?

this.tbh any youngster will do better than sachin right now

[trundlerNO1]

this.tbh any youngster will do better than sachin right now

how are you so sure? Any reason?

[Junyfan]

Rohit sharma or ajink Rahane.

[jusarrived]

that avg of 31 was sachin at his best . The chances of him even matching that is bleak . So I would rather take a youngster even if he avgs 25

[trundlerNO1]

that avg of 31 was sachin at his best . The chances of him even matching that is bleak . So I would rather take a youngster even if he avgs 25

My personal opinion that there is none better than Sachin right now?, stick with him you need a senior figure to guide youngsters

[adi B]

how are you so sure? Any reason?

i am pretty sure sachin will fail miserably in saf after watching him struggle so badly in last 6 months,so anyone who replaces him wont do worse than him,it`ll be a good learning experience

[adi B]

My personal opinion that there is none better than Sachin right now?, stick with him you need a senior figure to guide youngsters

no offense but thats sh1t thinking..sachin has already blocked a youngsters spot for 2 years,needs to go ASAP,he wont offer much in saf

[trundlerNO1]

no offense but thats sh1t thinking..sachin has already blocked a youngsters spot for 2 years' date='needs to go ASAP,he wont offer much in saf[/quote'] Those players that played with Sachin against Australia have little experience outside Asia let alone SA condition. He is averaging 32 for last two year, I know it really bad for his standard but his experience counts for a lot in those type of condition Can't have all noobs playing in SA, we will get murdered. You need a mentor to guide these youngsters

[trundlerNO1]

i am pretty sure sachin will fail miserably in saf after watching him struggle so badly in last 6 months' date='so anyone who replaces him wont do worse than him,it`ll be a good [b']learning experience

inexpense of preforming less than Sachin would preform in SA, you need your best XI and Sachin I am afraid he is one of them Form is temporary and Class is permanent

[adi B]

if u are adamant to have sachin in ur team then nobody (even with a valid reason) cant change ur mindset..tbh he`ll play in saf knowing the bcci and our fattu selectors

[BeautifulGame]

Those players that played with Sachin against Australia have little experience outside Asia let alone SA condition. He is averaging 32 for last two year, I know it really bad for his standard but his experience counts for a lot in those type of condition Can't have all noobs playing in SA, we will get murdered. You need a mentor to guide these youngsters

How much did it counted during the 8-0 white wash:cantstop:

[jalebi_bhai]

In all honesty, we'd be better off having a youngster with potential play instead of Sachin. Either way, Sachin won't perform to a high standard so even If the youngster fails, it will at least be part of his learning curve. The name i'd propose would have to be Rahane. He seems a very level headed individual and definitely has the talent. It's all a matter of him having the mental strength to cope with international cricket. I'm also not convinced on Murali Vijay. He's done well off late and deserves his chances but his technique is simply too faulty for overseas conditions.

[Clarke]

My personal opinion that there is none better than Sachin right now?, stick with him you need a senior figure to guide youngsters

Can't have all noobs playing in SA' date=' we will get murdered. You need a mentor to guide these youngsters[/quote'] You don't need a ****ing guide on the wicket who btw is struggling to make runs. He can guide in the nets, during practice etc IF he 'enjoys' doing it.

[Crookbond]

Cardboard