Sachin tendulkar vs Ms Dhoni :Who is India`s greatest Odi cricketer of all time ??

[adi B]

sachin is still>>>>dhoni in odi but dhoni is the greatest finisher..close the thread and enjoy like an indian fan

[JaFanatic]

A finisher can't do squat without the openers laying a platform. Both roles complement each other and can't really be compared. In one of Dhoni's best innings - One against Pakistan where he single handedly took us to a 220 odd total after the top order crumbled, resulted in a loss for India.

well said :two_thumbs_up:

[jusarrived]

Dude as I have said before' date=' you will put Vinay Kumar ahead of Sachin. I have seen your posts over the years and your obvious dislike of Sachin is something very obvious[/quote'] My dislike is for annoying tendulkar fans .

[Yoda-esque]

Chalo guys,thread band kar do abhi

[jalebi_bhai]

People have messed up priorities......:headshake:......INDIA WON.......Enjoy the moment.......stop this pointless bickering........

[JaFanatic]

My dislike is for annoying tendulkar fans .

WTF ? no one is taking your retarded logics seriously so stfu.

[flamy]

Can someone honestly tell me that Dhoni would have scored the desert storm in Sharjah? Or that Sachin would have left it till 15 of 6 in the first place if he had opened? Since when is 15 0f 6 the only criteria to judge a batsman?

I'm not talking abt the strike rate. I'm talking about handling the pressure.

[jusarrived]

jusarrived's formula is pretty simple. If the player is a southie' date=' he is better. No contest :cantstop:[/quote'] Stop talking like a retard . This why I said I cant stand tendulkar fans ...

[velu]

Dude as I have said before' date=' y[b']ou will put Vinay Kumar ahead of Sachin. I have seen your posts over the years and your obvious dislike of Sachin is something very obvious

you are repeating the same formula in your replies :phehehe: recently when i was anti-sachin you said i will pick agarkar ahead of sachin :giggle:

[Yoda-esque]

you are repeating the same formula in your replies :phehehe: recently when i was anti-sachin you said i will pick agarkar ahead of sachin :giggle:

:hysterical:

[fineleg]

Has jaf become a jackass? Saying msd > srt? The fools

[ganeshran]

Has jaf become a jackass? Saying msd > srt? The fools

MSD fans would say he is better than Bradman and sobers if they got the chance. Too bad no one has created the thread yet. :giggle:

[flamy]

In pressure situations, I'd trust Dhoni more than Sachin. That's all. WC 2003 comes to mind.

[adi B]

I'm not talking abt the strike rate. I'm talking about handling the pressure.

is that all in an odi game?

[flamy]

is that all in an odi game?

Que?

[adi B]

In pressure situations, I'd trust Dhoni more than Sachin. That's all. WC 2003 comes to mind.

so msd would have opened and clobbered mcgrath,lee,right?:hysterical::hysterical:

[flamy]

And, I think I'm done with this thread. Can't believe I got sucked into this. India just won the SILICON MOBILE CUP!!!

[Sachin=GOD]

MSD fans would say he is better than Bradman and sobers if they got the chance. Too bad no one has created the thread yet. :giggle:

Yoda has already said in that other thread that Dhoni is better than Sir Viv Goddy, Sir Viv toh ho gaye. Ab bas Sobers, Bradman bache hain - create a thread with a poll about this tomorrow :idea:

[Old guy]

so msd would have opened and clobbered mcgrath' date='lee,right?:hysterical::hysterical:[/quote'] +1 i still think gambhir's inning was much more important than msd's in 2011 world cup final

[CSK Fan]

In pressure situations, I'd trust Dhoni more than Sachin. That's all. WC 2003 comes to mind.

What about WC 92, 96, 99, 2007? Where we didn't even qualify for the finals?