India A team's tour of South Africa

[pnimesh1955]

1 hour ago, gattaca said:

Both Rohit and Rahane have flaws. Rahane is useless in spinning conditions and rohit is useless away from Indian shores. I havent Iyer or shaw.

Shaw will never play for India overnight in next 3 years.

[pnimesh1955]

Rohit will continues in Indian team for longer than you thought.

[pnimesh1955]

Rahane is too good in test cricket who scores century in every country outside India, whose highest in SOA 96 but he will break that in 365 days.he is our better Fielder with WORLD RECIRD 8 CATCHES IN SINGLE TEST on his name.India's Yajuvendra Singh and G.Chappel hold previous record.RAHANE can even lead India, he is vice captain of India.

[pnimesh1955]

10 hours ago, sandeep said:

Looks like Nair finally came to the party on a slowish track.   Good for him.   

 

 

Next 10 innings he will scores 28/29/0/5/40/1/6/ not playing /92//0/?

[pnimesh1955]

13 hours ago, SK_IH said:

thanks for details,i hope this guy and that prashant chopra both open for ind A on next A tour

Indian selection policy so rigid, they do not wants to experiments newer blood like Pakistan doing

We have option of Rahul/Rohit/Vijay/dhawan now Mukund will sits out so RAHANE was told you are 3rd opener in SL ODI.

 

Pandey deserves in SL ODI right now but he was not selected

[Kerberos]

7 hours ago, gattaca said:

Both Rohit and Rahane have flaws. Rahane is useless in spinning conditions and rohit is useless away from Indian shores. I havent Iyer or shaw.

A batsman who has done wonders in first class can no way be useless against spin. Rahane does have some issues against spin for now. Even quality batsman have some particular issues at some point of their career.

[gakgupta]

Is this tour done??

[fineleg]

On 8/27/2017 at 9:01 AM, gakgupta said:

Is this tour done??

Looks like its done....right folks??

Which player are winners for India-A from this tour? And, Who didn't make it to next level according to you?

Summary?

Edited August 28, 2017 by fineleg

[express bowling]

2 hours ago, fineleg said:

Which player are winners for India-A from this tour? And, Who didn't make it to next level according to you?

Summary?

 

Looked international material to me  --

 

1-day games --

 

Pandey, Iyer, Pant, Shardul, Siraj, Thampi, Axar

 

4-day games -- 

 

Did not watch but  Samarth, Siraj, Nadeem, Rajpoot   performed .....  Saini, Nair, Iyer, Sudeep were decent

 

[sandeep]

10 hours ago, express bowling said:

 

Looked international material to me  --

 

1-day games --

 

Pandey, Iyer, Pant, Shardul, Siraj, Thampi, Axar

 

4-day games -- 

 

Did not watch but  Samarth, Siraj, Nadeem, Rajpoot   performed .....  Saini, Nair, Iyer, Sudeep were decent

 

Pandey was super clutch and consistent in the ODI leg.  Iyer had his typical performance - flashed a lot of potential, but wasn't consistent enough to really take that next step.   IMO Siraj has shown a lot of promise, purely based on the expectation to performance ratio.   For an inexperienced rookie, he has come along quite quickly.   

[SUMO]

among all the 7 rookie pacers nurtured by bcci at NCA + shardul .... siraj is the one who has the hunger, looks ready and want to excel. 
Thats why his first class, list A and A tours record is better than the rest.

[rkt.india]

10 hours ago, express bowling said:

 

Looked international material to me  --

 

1-day games --

 

Pandey, Iyer, Pant, Shardul, Siraj, Thampi, Axar

 

4-day games -- 

 

Did not watch but  Samarth, Siraj, Nadeem, Rajpoot   performed .....  Saini, Nair, Iyer, Sudeep were decent

 

actually Saini was the best pacer in 4-day games

[express bowling]

5 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

actually Saini was the best pacer in 4-day games

Siraj and Rajpoot had better wickets per match ratio in the 4-day games

 

Siraj        5.0

Rajpoot   4.0

Saini       3.5

[express bowling]

1 hour ago, sandeep said:

  IMO Siraj has shown a lot of promise, purely based on the expectation to performance ratio.   For an inexperienced rookie, he has come along quite quickly.   

 

Just look at the consistency Siraj  has shown where-ever he has played.  Has picked up wickets in every format and every series.

 

On this A tour ..... 5 wickets in 1  four-day game ..... 5 wickets in 3  one-day-games.

 

10 wickets from 6 IPL matches.

 

42 wickets from 10 Ranji games.

 

He has the pace and consistently  attacks the top of off-stump.    This combination spells big potential for developing into a strike bowler as he can get the outside-edges as well as bowleds / LBWs.

 

 

Bowling averages

	Mat	Inns	Balls	Runs	Wkts	BBI	BBM	Ave	Econ	SR	4w	5w	10
First-class	12	23	2223	1075	49	5/52	9/116	21.93	2.90	45.3	4	1	0
List A	11	11	536	439	18	3/24	3/24	24.38	4.91	29.7	0	0	0
T20s	16	16	372	487	26	4/24	4/24	18.73	7.85	14.3	2	0	0

 

http://www.espncricinfo.com/india/content/player/940973.html

 

 

IPL

Bowling	Mat	Balls	Runs	WKTS	BBM	Ave	Econ	SR	4W	5W
Career	6	138	212	10	4/32	21.20	9.21	13.80	1	0
2017	6	138	212	10	4/32	21.20	9.21	13.80	1	0

 

 

http://www.iplt20.com/teams/sunrisers-hyderabad/squad/3840/Mohammed-Siraj/

 

 

Edited August 28, 2017 by express bowling

[sandeep]

1 hour ago, SUMO said:

among all the 7 rookie pacers nurtured by bcci at NCA + shardul .... siraj is the one who has the hunger, looks ready and want to excel. 
Thats why his first class, list A and A tours record is better than the rest.

Could also be due to the fact that he hasn't played more than a season or 2 has he?  

[express bowling]

One aspect Siraj has to work on is sustaining pace in 4-day matches. The last spell of the day should be pacy too.

 

Most of those 7 NCA bound pacers have the same issue.

Edited August 28, 2017 by express bowling

[chewy]

So not single guy from recent India A tour to SA in current Test squad

 

And in current Test squad no-one has played in SA or Australia for over two years

 

I see Pant, Samson and Ishan Kishen were on this A tour, but BCCI select Pappu  

 

some decent perofrmances by the quicks on the A tour, but BCCI and Kohli opt for Ishant Sharma  

 

plenty runs scored by next in line batsmen (with SA conditions under their belt) but BCCI and Kohli go ahead with Rohit Sharma  

 

I see Makram playing in that tour look where he is now!

 

And that’s why India will Never dominate cricket, despite doing a lot of good work in background (U19, Emerging players tournament, A tours) when it comes to the final decision for the first team...there is no rational or logical approach  

[Forever Indian]

1 minute ago, chewy said:

So not single guy from recent India A tour to SA in current Test squad

 

And in current Test squad no-one has played in SA or Australia for over two years

 

I see Pant, Samson and Ishan Kishen were on this A tour, but BCCI select Pappu  

 

some decent perofrmances by the quicks on the A tour, but BCCI and Kohli opt for Ishant Sharma  

 

plenty runs scored by next in line batsmen (with SA conditions under their belt) but BCCI and Kohli go ahead with Rohit Sharma  

 

I see Makram playing in that tour look where he is now!

 

And that’s why India will Never dominate cricket, despite doing a lot of good work in background (U19, Emerging players tournament, A tours) when it comes to the final decision for the first team...there is no rational or logical approach  

If you have a captain who doesn't believe in youngsters and instead opts for so called "Experience" of test discards, this is what will happen.