India vs India-A in ODIs. Who will win?

[ShebbySB]

India:- Rohit,Dhawan,Kohli(c),Dhoni(Wk),Yuvraj,Kedar,Hardik,Jadeja,Ashwin,Shami,Bumrah.

India-A:- KL Rahul,Pant(Wk),Rayudu,Nair,Pandey,Hooda,Akshar,BK,Kuldeep,Umesh,Nathu.

Mishraji and Mandeep doesn't make the cut for me and Jayant misses out to other spinners.

In a 5 match series India will beat India-A 3-2 in my view.

[sandeep]

Rayudu seals 'A' team's fate.  4-1 to India.  Rohit drops a daddy 100 in one win, ODI Boss Kohli wins 2 on his own without breaking a sweat, and the double Ds - Dhoni and Dhawan bat well enough to win a 4th on the back of good bowling by Bumrah and Ash.   Nathu will spray the ball like he's a young Umesh.  Umesh will bowl better like he's the new Sir Aggy, while Akshar will give up 6s to Dhoni like its Guru Purnima and he forgot to buy roses.

 

For added flame-bait, Pant will fail to deKock the bowling and will bat like a younger Sharjeel 

[ShebbySB]

Just now, sandeep said:

Rayudu seals 'A' team's fate.  4-1 to India.  Rohit drops a daddy 100 in one win, ODI Boss Kohli wins 2 on his own without breaking a sweat, and the double Ds - Dhoni and Dhawan bat well enough to win a 4th on the back of good bowling by Bumrah and Ash.   Nathu will spray the ball like he's a young Umesh.  Umesh will bowl better like he's the new Sir Aggy, while Akshar will give up 6s to Dhoni like its Guru Purnima and he forgot to buy roses.

 

For added flame-bait, Pant will fail to deKock the bowling and will bat like a younger Sharjeel 

[tweaker]

I would go with India A with Rahul,Pant,Hooda,Kuldeep & Nathu as top performer.

 

As seen in today ' match by Kuldeep 's performance, if young talent are given oppurtunity they will surely grab it.

 

I expect Hooda ,Nathu ,Pant to be as impressive as Kuldeep.

[express bowling]

India A --  Rahul, Pant, Nair, Pandey, Hooda, Kishan, Axar, Kuldeep, Bhuvi, Umesh, Nathu

 

Will be a team of fearless rookies on the batting front with nothing to lose.....we may see many good performers

[sourab10forever]

How about this ? Who will win?

 

1 : Rahul,Rohit,Kohli,Dhoni,Yuvi,Manish,H.Pandya, Jadeja , Ashwin, Bumrah , Shami

 

2 : Rahane, Dhawan, Rayadu, Pant,Raina,Kedhar,K.pandya, Akshar Patel, Kuldeep, Bhuvi , Umesh

 

Likely best IND XI currently (given all are fit) vs Their Immidiante replacements (except for Kohli) very similar to the OP but a few changes here and there.

 

I say main team just ahead by 60-40 on paper.

3-2 in a 5 match series.

[Sandeep99]

Simple - the team with Kohli will win.

[kira]

Rayudu seals the fate of India A, easy 5-0 win for India 

[rkt.india]

These two teams could have played 2 ODIs against each other rather than playing against England. It was ridiculous to see 30 year old plus some on their last legs Dhoni, Yuvraj, Dhawan, Nehra, Rayudu playing against England in a warmup game disguised as India A. Serious lack of planning and imagination there by BCCI and selectors. England should have been given to play a third rate Ranji team like Tripura, Chattishgarh, or Orissa.

[Mariyam]

Which ever team is lead by the astute captaincy of captain  M S Dhoni will win.

[CoverDrive]

Kohli is so good he is going to make a huge difference. Dhoni may not be the best in the world any longer but he is good enough to outsmart local lads

[Austin 3:!6]

2-2 Drawn series...with last match washed out.

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

[express bowling]

1 hour ago, rkt.india said:

These two teams could have played 2 ODIs against each other rather than playing against England. It was ridiculous to see 30 year old plus some on their last legs Dhoni, Yuvraj, Dhawan, Nehra, Rayudu playing against England in a warmup game disguised as India A. Serious lack of planning and imagination there by BCCI and selectors. England should have been given to play a third rate Ranji team like Tripura, Chattishgarh, or Orissa.

I was surprised to see us given high quality one day practice to the English team before a crucial ODI series.  This is real poor planning.