Dinesh, Pandey, Iyer, Patel, Thakur should get 3 games each

[Khota]

5 hours ago, express bowling said:

I want to defeat SA in SA  6-0.  Play strongest team.

 

Develop bench strength against WI, SL, Bangladesh, Zim 

This is the moment. They never do it for any series. The grandfather keeps on playing.

[Khota]

4 minutes ago, MultiB48 said:

not dinesh kartik ,i have gone from a teenager to a father the guy hasn't succeeded

He is batting real well. You need to see the body of work and form your own opinion. In 2017 he was the tops. Oh and congratulations on being a father.

Edited February 3, 2018 by Khota

[Ankit_sharma03]

13 minutes ago, Khota said:

This is 2018. Dinesh in 2017 is a much improved player. Are you assuming that players dont improve over a period of time?

didnt dhoni outscore him in 2017 sl series

 

16 minutes ago, Khota said:

The selectors. He did outperform him in CT.  Then you dont give him an opportunity you start messing with his confidence. Lot of this is mental and if the moron coach had any brain he would come out and say that Dinesh gets three games and I can assure you he will outperform the grandfather.

I didnt see MSK prasad ghost holding his bad when he had no idea in dharamshala where the ball was jagging 

 

 

outperformed he didnt even play a single game

 

Warm up aur faltu ke games men karthik bradman ko bhi outperform kr de

 

International men saalon se wahi kahani hai aur wahi rahegi

[Khota]

2 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

didnt dhoni outscore him in 2017 sl series

 

I didnt see MSK prasad ghost holding his bad when he had no idea in dharamshala where the ball was jagging 

 

 

outperformed he didnt even play a single game

 

Warm up aur faltu ke games men karthik bradman ko bhi outperform kr de

 

International men saalon se wahi kahani hai aur wahi rahegi

Dhoni moves up and down the order to suit him. Dinesh does not get a steady opportunity to showcase his talent.

CT warm up games are not faltu. Everyone is trying to do well and Dinesh did great.

He completely outperformed the grandfather in IPL.

Mere bhai Dinesh ko ek theek chance to do. faltu mein bechare ki jaan kha gayen hain sare.

[BeautifulGame]

3 hours ago, Khota said:

What you are spouting is nonsense. Did we take these players for shopping in cape town. They need to be tested and I can assure you with phasing one by one there would be no drop off. Going by  your logic we would still have Ashwin, Jaddu and ishant bowling. Tese players need a clear path forward.

Actually nonsense is you thinking D Karthik performing in IPL makes him a great test player .

 

And no bench strength can be tested at best after winning the series.Not in the middle of the series in a country where we have never won an odi series.

 

And no Kuldeep and Chahal performed enough in IPL to show they were ready to replace Ashwin.

 

 

[velu]

dinesh and pandey shld not come anywhere closer the team

 

and we can rest players when we play in our home

[Khota]

45 minutes ago, BeautifulGame said:

Actually nonsense is you thinking D Karthik performing in IPL makes him a great test player .

 

And no bench strength can be tested at best after winning the series.Not in the middle of the series in a country where we have never won an odi series.

 

And no Kuldeep and Chahal performed enough in IPL to show they were ready to replace Ashwin.

 

 

And Dinesh has done enough in IPL to show that he surpasses Dhoni anytime. So you can pick and chose your logic and your players but it does not extend to other deserving players.

[velu]

13 minutes ago, Khota said:

And Dinesh has done enough in IPL to show that he surpasses Dhoni anytime. So you can pick and chose your logic and your players but it does not extend to other deserving players.

what has Dinesh done in IPL?

 

[Sgattick10]

Only Thakur, Iyer and Pandey should get a chance others dont even deserve to be in the team. 

[Khota]

5 minutes ago, velu said:

what has Dinesh done in IPL?

 

Whatever he did was more than Dhoni.

[velu]

14 minutes ago, Khota said:

Whatever he did was more than Dhoni.

 

then list what Dinesh did and dhoni did for comparison instead of pulling the data out of thin air 

[Khota]

2 minutes ago, velu said:

 

then list what Dinesh did and dhoni did for comparison instead of pulling the data out of thin air 

After I get some work done.

[BeautifulGame]

1 hour ago, Khota said:

And Dinesh has done enough in IPL to show that he surpasses Dhoni anytime. So you can pick and chose your logic and your players but it does not extend to other deserving players.

Do you even know Karthik was picked into the Indian team based in his Vijay Hazare form last season ?

This thread I opened even before he played IPL started last season .But no he hasn't improved neither his technique or mental ability.So he doesn't deserve any more chances and it's a  waste of time.

 

Just because your knowledge of Indian cricket and players is poor doesn't make others logic poor.

 

You actually admitted you wanted Karthick back in the Indian test team ahead of Saha based on IPL without ever watching him Ranji.That sums up your cricketing knowledge and logic in anything.

 

[Khota]

2 hours ago, velu said:

 

then list what Dinesh did and dhoni did for comparison instead of pulling the data out of thin air 

Here are the batting nos for 2017 IPL:

 

SV Samson	14	14	0	386	102	27.57	273	141.39	1	2	2	32	19
(Delhi Daredevils)
KA Pollard	17	16	3	385	70	29.61	276	139.49	0	3	0	26	22
(Mumbai Indians)
AM Rahane	16	16	1	382	60	25.46	323	118.26	0	2	2	35	9
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
RR Pant	14	14	0	366	97	26.14	221	165.61	0	2	3	28	24
(Delhi Daredevils)
KD Karthik	14	13	3	361	65	36.10	259	139.38	0	2	1	30	11
(Gujarat Lions)
SS Iyer	12	12	2	338	96	33.80	243	139.09	0	2	0	36	10
(Delhi Daredevils)
N Rana	13	12	1	333	62*	30.27	264	126.13	0	3	0	24	17
(Mumbai Indians)
RG Sharma	17	16	2	333	67	23.78	273	121.97	0	3	1	31	9
(Mumbai Indians)
MK Tiwary	15	13	3	324	60	32.40	236	137.28	0	2	1	31	11
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
BB McCullum	11	11	0	319	72	29.00	217	147.00	0	2	0	29	18
(Gujarat Lions)
BA Stokes	12	11	1	316	103*	31.60	221	142.98	1	1	0	22	15
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
GJ Maxwell	14	13	3	310	47	31.00	179	173.18	0	0	3	19	26
(Kings XI Punjab)
V Kohli	10	10	0	308	64	30.80	252	122.22	0	4	1	23	11
(Royal Challengers Bangalore)
AJ Finch	13	13	1	299	72	24.91	180	166.11	0	2	1	25	19
(Gujarat Lions)
CA Lynn	7	7	1	295	93*	49.16	163	180.98	0	3	0	25	19
(Kolkata Knight Riders)
MS Dhoni	16	15	4	290	61*	26.36	250	116.00	0	1	0	15	16
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
KK Nair

 

 

As you can see my man took fewer innings than the grandfather to score more runs. Would it be fair to say Dinesh>>> Grandfather in batting. I catch lot of crap but IPL stats are much better than other cricket stats that are meaningless mostly.

 

I can get other nos too but this Dhoni obsession is meaningless.

[Khota]

2 hours ago, BeautifulGame said:

Do you even know Karthik was picked into the Indian team based in his Vijay Hazare form last season ?

This thread I opened even before he played IPL started last season .But no he hasn't improved neither his technique or mental ability.So he doesn't deserve any more chances and it's a  waste of time.

 

Just because your knowledge of Indian cricket and players is poor doesn't make others logic poor.

 

You actually admitted you wanted Karthick back in the Indian test team ahead of Saha based on IPL without ever watching him Ranji.That sums up your cricketing knowledge and logic in anything.

 

For you to assume what I know and what I dont is extremely arrogant on your part. Watching TV more than I do does not make you an expert. All it tells is that you just watched more TV. Kathick was not given a proper run this time around.

 

You may know everything under the sun but you backed three players who I though were going to fail. I just dont want to go there anymore. You have a pre conceived notion abt certain players which is difficult to change. I have no preference for any player. I only like the players who perform.

[velu]

6 minutes ago, Khota said:

Here are the batting nos for 2017 IPL:

 

SV Samson	14	14	0	386	102	27.57	273	141.39	1	2	2	32	19
(Delhi Daredevils)
KA Pollard	17	16	3	385	70	29.61	276	139.49	0	3	0	26	22
(Mumbai Indians)
AM Rahane	16	16	1	382	60	25.46	323	118.26	0	2	2	35	9
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
RR Pant	14	14	0	366	97	26.14	221	165.61	0	2	3	28	24
(Delhi Daredevils)
KD Karthik	14	13	3	361	65	36.10	259	139.38	0	2	1	30	11
(Gujarat Lions)
SS Iyer	12	12	2	338	96	33.80	243	139.09	0	2	0	36	10
(Delhi Daredevils)
N Rana	13	12	1	333	62*	30.27	264	126.13	0	3	0	24	17
(Mumbai Indians)
RG Sharma	17	16	2	333	67	23.78	273	121.97	0	3	1	31	9
(Mumbai Indians)
MK Tiwary	15	13	3	324	60	32.40	236	137.28	0	2	1	31	11
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
BB McCullum	11	11	0	319	72	29.00	217	147.00	0	2	0	29	18
(Gujarat Lions)
BA Stokes	12	11	1	316	103*	31.60	221	142.98	1	1	0	22	15
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
GJ Maxwell	14	13	3	310	47	31.00	179	173.18	0	0	3	19	26
(Kings XI Punjab)
V Kohli	10	10	0	308	64	30.80	252	122.22	0	4	1	23	11
(Royal Challengers Bangalore)
AJ Finch	13	13	1	299	72	24.91	180	166.11	0	2	1	25	19
(Gujarat Lions)
CA Lynn	7	7	1	295	93*	49.16	163	180.98	0	3	0	25	19
(Kolkata Knight Riders)
MS Dhoni	16	15	4	290	61*	26.36	250	116.00	0	1	0	15	16
(Rising Pune Supergiant)
KK Nair

 

 

As you can see my man took fewer innings than the grandfather to score more runs. Would it be fair to say Dinesh>>> Grandfather in batting. I catch lot of crap but IPL stats are much better than other cricket stats that are meaningless mostly.

 

I can get other nos too but this Dhoni obsession is meaningless.

why not for the whole IPL ? 

[Khota]

4 minutes ago, velu said:

why not for the whole IPL ? 

Current form is more important. Actually whole IPL would be good too and that just might show the decline of grandfather.I might do it.

[Laaloo]

8 hours ago, velu said:

dinesh and pandey shld not come anywhere closer the team

 

and we can rest players when we play in our home

Wait you're not a pandey fan? Lol

[BeautifulGame]

5 hours ago, Khota said:

For you to assume what I know and what I dont is extremely arrogant on your part. Watching TV more than I do does not make you an expert. All it tells is that you just watched more TV. Kathick was not given a proper run this time around.

 

You may know everything under the sun but you backed three players who I though were going to fail. I just dont want to go there anymore. You have a pre conceived notion abt certain players which is difficult to change. I have no preference for any player. I only like the players who perform.

What assumption ? It's you who sadmitted you don't watch Ranji trophy ,haven't watched  Karthick in matches and want his selection for test team based on IPL performances.Atleast remember and be consistent in the nonsense you spout.

 

 

[Khota]

23 minutes ago, BeautifulGame said:

What assumption ? It's you who sadmitted you don't watch Ranji trophy ,haven't watched  Karthick in matches and want his selection for test team based on IPL performances.Atleast remember and be consistent in the nonsense you spout.

 

 

I have not watched him in Ranji but I have watched him plenty. You keepon saying he will fail without any facts. Let him get a chance and then speak. IPL performance means a lot because all the conditons are nearly same. Let karthick get a proper chance and he will do better than Dhoni.

I dont even want to discuss the other three failed players you have been supporting.