Jump to content

Team for SA ODI’s selected


nsareen

Recommended Posts

Posted
2 minutes ago, ShoonyaSifar said:

Saini on the A tour picked wickets and rediscovered his rhythm. Why couldn't he have been given a chance?

Is Saini still with the squad or what purpose he was specifically sent for?

Are this lot of selectors on drugs?

Posted
6 minutes ago, Suhaan said:

Vijay Hazare ,SMAT were fairly watchable and looked exciting not too long ago,covid times have been quite tough

Things may take time to get back on track

all I am saying,dont take performances in it too seriously. It can be feeder to IPL selection,but ultimate Test is there

Posted

Even Sky will be 33 in 2023.  He did well in that tour to Srilanka. But is he a long term option?  He is 31 years old. At his age normally players would have played over 20 matches. He has played only 3 that too part of second string side.  He was picked as a stop gap arrangement. He might prove us wrong. But i am not sure whether he even get into playing XI. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Suhaan said:

I think they are seeing a role for him in WC23 and want him to be in loi frame of mind

For me biggest disappointment is Bhuvi,Dhawan again making the team list

If Ashwin is their solution to our bowling woes in ODIs, better to have no expectations in the 2023 WC. 

Posted
10 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

Rishi Dhawan did not do anything to get noticed until this season. When Dhoni plays at 40 without doing anything with bat there is a chance he  may get picked.  Also in the IPL if you are not in the right setup you might fail. Same Ruturaj would have flopped under Kohli's RCB.

 

Dhoni is obviously picked to pull the crowds.

 

Paddikal performed for RCB so you are wrong.If you are good you can do well but you cant hide if you are mediocre.

 

 

Posted
5 minutes ago, Suhaan said:

Is Saini still with the squad or what purpose he was specifically sent for?

Are this lot of selectors on drugs?

He is in SA with the test squad as a reserve player.

Posted
2 minutes ago, Lord said:

 

Dhoni is obviously picked to pull the crowds.

 

Paddikal performed for RCB so you are wrong.If you are good you can do well but you cant hide if you are mediocre.

 

 

 

Ruturaj strike rate in 2020 was 120.  His strike rate in 2021 was 136

Padikkal strike rate in 2020 was 124. His strike rate in 2021 was 125

 

Ruturaj subsequently had a fabulous VH. If someone is good in the IPL he should be able to thrash everyone in the VH as well logically. Padikka 2 matches 4 runs in the vijay hazare.

Posted
9 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Even Sky will be 33 in 2023.  He did well in that tour to Srilanka. But is he a long term option?  He is 31 years old. At his age normally players would have played over 20 matches. He has played only 3 that too part of second string side.  He was picked as a stop gap arrangement. He might prove us wrong. But i am not sure whether he even get into playing XI. 

He made his debut this year, TM didn't play him vs England. Played the 3 ODIs we have played since then. Should be playing every single LOI match going forward

Posted
Just now, ShoonyaSifar said:

He made his debut this year, TM didn't play him vs England. Played the 3 ODIs we have played since then. Should be playing every single LOI match going forward

 

The depends on whether Venkatesh Iyer will be played as 6th bowling option.  Dhawan/KL Rahul/Kohli/Iyer/Pant/Iyer/Sundar then 4 seamers.

Posted
2 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

The depends on whether Venkatesh Iyer will be played as 6th bowling option.  Dhawan/KL Rahul/Kohli/Iyer/Pant/Iyer/Sundar then 4 seamers.

Venky Iyer can play as the opener instead of Dhawan.

 

Dhawan and Kohli playing together in the 11 will be ultra regressive. Ideally both should be benched.

 

Also, Rahul has found his mojo in ODIs as a middle order batsman, should continue to bat there.

 

V. Iyer, Kishan, SKY, Rahul, S. Iyer, Pant, Sundar + bowlers

Posted
1 minute ago, ShoonyaSifar said:

Venky Iyer can play as the opener instead of Dhawan.

 

Dhawan and Kohli playing together in the 11 will be ultra regressive. Ideally both should be benched.

 

Also, Rahul has found his mojo in ODIs as a middle order batsman, should continue to bat there.

 

V. Iyer, Kishan, SKY, Rahul, S. Iyer, Pant, Sundar + bowlers

 

Nobody wants Dhawan. But KL Rahul and Rahul Dravid will go with him. This is a given. Once he is in the squad they are not going to ask him to sit out. This is why selectors should have never given them the option. Besides Ruturaj is a way better opener in this format in current form. Even before this season his record in list A was decent. Ideally Ruturaj should open. 

Posted
21 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

Ruturaj strike rate in 2020 was 120.  His strike rate in 2021 was 136

Padikkal strike rate in 2020 was 124. His strike rate in 2021 was 125

 

Ruturaj subsequently had a fabulous VH. If someone is good in the IPL he should be able to thrash everyone in the VH as well logically. Padikka 2 matches 4 runs in the vijay hazare.

 

that's just because Gaikwad is better player and more talented,nothing to do with franchisees.

Posted
35 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Even Sky will be 33 in 2023.  He did well in that tour to Srilanka. But is he a long term option?  He is 31 years old. At his age normally players would have played over 20 matches. He has played only 3 that too part of second string side.  He was picked as a stop gap arrangement. He might prove us wrong. But i am not sure whether he even get into playing XI. 

 Here we cannot blame selectors . They have selected him in T20 & now in ODI. Captain should give him chances.  KL will be more in tune with Dravid if coach wants that to happen . 

Posted
Just now, Lord said:

 

that's just because Gaikwad is better player and more talented,nothing to do with franchisees.

 

COach and captain does play role. Shane watson himself has acknowledged Stephen Fleming is the best coach he has worked under.

Posted
1 minute ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

COach and captain does play role. Shane watson himself has acknowledged Stephen Fleming is the best coach he has worked under.

 

you want me to list players who sing praises of Kohli as captain?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...