BacktoCricaddict Posted February 27 Share Posted February 27 9 hours ago, express bowling said: A lot may change from now to then ... but based on the info we have now. 1. Rahul 2. Jaiswal .. LHB 3. Gill 4. Kohli 5. Pant .. LHB / Sarfraz if Pant is not ok 6. Jurel ( wk ) 7. Jadeja .. LHB 8. Harshit Rana .. quick and low average pacer who can bat 9. Akashdeep .. quick and low average pacer who can bat 10. Bumrah 11. Shami / Kuldeep in Sydney etc. Who is kaptaan? Link to comment
express bowling Posted February 27 Share Posted February 27 42 minutes ago, BacktoCricaddict said: Who is kaptaan? Eenie meenie miney moe We don't have anyone who would make a difference, so does not matter. Link to comment
Muloghonto Posted February 27 Share Posted February 27 10 hours ago, Majestic said: Jaiswal Rohit Gill Kohli Pant(wkt) KLR(wkt) Jadeja Shami Kuldeep Bumrah Siraj Others :- Sarfaraz Akash Deep Jurel(wkt) 1 top order bat Axar/Sundar( in case of Jaddu's injury) On what basis would Pant be ahead of Jurel at this moment in time ? Pant was demoted from keeping even when he was fit and with his whole fitness and ability into question now, he gets to be the wicketkeeper ?!? Link to comment
Muloghonto Posted February 27 Share Posted February 27 my XI: Rohit (c) Jaiswal Gill Kohli Sarfaraz Jurel (wk) Jadeja Ashwin Shami Bumrah Akash Deep extras: Siraj KL Rahul Kuldeep Sundar Link to comment
New guy Posted February 27 Share Posted February 27 (edited) 21 minutes ago, Muloghonto said: On what basis would Pant be ahead of Jurel at this moment in time ? Pant was demoted from keeping even when he was fit and with his whole fitness and ability into question now, he gets to be the wicketkeeper ?!? Pant was demoted from keeping? Dude you are straight up lying now. And you realise we are talking about tests right? After the saha experiment for TWO years pant was the best keeper in the world and always outkeeping the opposition keeper in every series. Your point about his current fitness is fine but you don't need to lie about the past to make it. Funniest thing is you pretend to be a sehwag fan but when we have similar type of player you crap all over him. Pant has 4 100s in Sena in countries where sehwag or laxman never had a single 100 or less than him His keeping at peak fitness and his batting both are a 100 times better than Jurel Edited February 27 by New guy putrevus and Majestic 1 1 Link to comment
Muloghonto Posted February 27 Share Posted February 27 10 minutes ago, New guy said: Pant was demoted from keeping? Dude you are straight up lying now. And you realise we are talking about tests right? After the saha experiment for TWO years pant was the best keeper in the world and always outkeeping the opposition keeper in every series. LOL He is a terrible keeper. 10 minutes ago, New guy said: Your point about his current fitness is fine but you don't need to lie about the past to make it. Funniest thing is you pretend to be a sehwag fan but when we have similar type of player you crap all over him. Pant has 4-5 100s in Sena in countries where sehwag or laxman never had a single 100. His keeping at peak fitness and his batting both are a 109 times better than Jurel Nope. Jurel is a far better batter with the tail and a far better keeper than Pant, who is ordinary as a keeper. Link to comment
singhvivek141 Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 15 hours ago, Muloghonto said: On what basis would Pant be ahead of Jurel at this moment in time ? Pant was demoted from keeping even when he was fit and with his whole fitness and ability into question now, he gets to be the wicketkeeper ?!? Pant was always a good keeper vs pace..he had issues against spin earlier but he improved leaps & bounds from 2021 onwards. I won't call out now if he is better than Jurel in keeping, but he for sure a good keeper. express bowling, putrevus and BacktoCricaddict 3 Link to comment
singhvivek141 Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 17 hours ago, BacktoCricaddict said: Who is kaptaan? No 10. is your captain. If not him then there is Kamaal Lajawab Rahul. Link to comment
BacktoCricaddict Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 2 hours ago, singhvivek141 said: No 10. is your captain. If not him then there is Kamaal Lajawab Rahul. No. 10 often goes under load management (as he should). So, that makes it difficult. South Africa had a left-handed opener become kaptaan at age 21. I don't even remember how much success he had as a batsman when that happened. We have one such guy, who is also a successful and respected batsman already. Either him or #3. Link to comment
singhvivek141 Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 20 minutes ago, BacktoCricaddict said: No. 10 often goes under load management (as he should). So, that makes it difficult. South Africa had a left-handed opener become kaptaan at age 21. I don't even remember how much success he had as a batsman when that happened. We have one such guy, who is also a successful and respected batsman already. Either him or #3. I am all for left handed opener or no 3 as captain. But after the last brave decision of making young MSD a captain, I don't see that happening it again coz of the seniority culture. Link to comment
putrevus Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 (edited) 1 hour ago, singhvivek141 said: I am all for left handed opener or no 3 as captain. But after the last brave decision of making young MSD a captain, I don't see that happening it again coz of the seniority culture. It was not a brave decision at all. 2007 world t20 gave him that cache.Plus Dravid did not want to be captain and after Kumble retired in 2008 there was no one left so Dhoni became captain by default. If tomorrow Rohit is gone as Kohli is done as captain. Gill or even Jaiswal will become captain. Edited February 28 by putrevus Link to comment
AKane Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 So with Bumrah, Harshit and Akashdeep, is there any point in the Aussies even playing the series? They will have been beaten before the series begins .....? I mean Bumrah, Harshit, Akashdeep is better than peak Ambrose, Walsh, Bishop so why have the series - just give India the BG trophy? But First.... but first.... the big beatdown to laydown on RoW by Indian IPL stars will be the T20 WC. Link to comment
express bowling Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 (edited) 1 hour ago, AKane said: But First.... but first.... the big beatdown to laydown on RoW by Indian IPL stars will be the T20 WC. India never does well in the T20 World Cups these days. No point in focusing too much on them as long as seniors sneak in, and Rohit and Kohli have. Edited February 28 by express bowling raki05 and Mosher 1 1 Link to comment
Need4Speed Posted February 28 Share Posted February 28 On 2/27/2024 at 3:08 AM, express bowling said: A lot may change from now to then ... but based on the info we have now. 1. Rahul 2. Jaiswal .. LHB 3. Gill 4. Kohli 5. Pant .. LHB / Sarfraz if Pant is not ok 6. Jurel ( wk ) 7. Jadeja .. LHB 8. Harshit Rana .. quick and low average pacer who can bat 9. Akashdeep .. quick and low average pacer who can bat 10. Bumrah 11. Shami / Kuldeep in Sydney etc. 12. Sudarshan .. LHB 13. Sarfraz 14. Padikkal .. LHB 15. Ashwin / Axar 16. Kuldeep 17. Prasidh / Himanshu Chauhan 18. Siraj .. Need to move away from Rohit, Shardul, Mukesh etc. .. Both Harshit Rana and Akashdeep are fast, tall, hit the deck, bouncy, have low FC averages and can bat somewhat. Need both of them in the playing 11. .. I have alternating RHB and LHB to make it tough for bowlers. .. Siraj is blowing hot and cold these days. Usually cold and rarely hot. No way should he be a first choice starter in the 11. .. Pant should not keep wickets. Infact, his batting ability after accident is not known either. So, must keep backup. I like this one bhai..hope Harshit keeps on improving to make a mark..dont need Mukesh and Shardul in bowling there.. But I think selectors will pick Boom,Siraj,Akashdeep and Shami(based on fitness)..so Harshit may not make it in the xi..unless injury concerns in first xi.. raki05 and express bowling 1 1 Link to comment
Kron Posted February 29 Share Posted February 29 16 hours ago, AKane said: So with Bumrah, Harshit and Akashdeep, is there any point in the Aussies even playing the series? They will have been beaten before the series begins .....? I mean Bumrah, Harshit, Akashdeep is better than peak Ambrose, Walsh, Bishop so why have the series - just give India the BG trophy? But First.... but first.... the big beatdown to laydown on RoW by Indian IPL stars will be the T20 WC. What? Sarcasm Link to comment
New guy Posted February 29 Share Posted February 29 (edited) On 2/28/2024 at 2:17 AM, Muloghonto said: LOL He is a terrible keeper. Nope. Jurel is a far better batter with the tail and a far better keeper than Pant, who is ordinary as a keeper. He was always an excellent keeper, he only made mistakes first year where dhoni fans were literally booing him, even dhoni made similar mistakes when he started. And yes someone who has 4 sena 100s before 25 years of age is an ordinary bat and Jurel is better. Pant literally batted with the tail to win the gAbba test against a much better attack at their home. Better stick to time pass section buddy. Edited February 29 by New guy putrevus 1 Link to comment
Adamant Posted February 29 Share Posted February 29 The 5 venues would probably be Adelaide, Brisbaine, Perth, Melbourne, Sydney. For Adelaide, Scg and Mcg play both Jadeja and Ashwin. If one of them flops in two matches replace him with Sundar. I am counting Pant out as I don’t see a chance of him being there. In Gabba and Perth, we should go with this lineup: Sharma Jaiswal Gill Kohli Rahul Jurel Sundar Jadeja Shami / Akashdeep Siraj Bumrah In scg, Mcg and adelaide we will need Ashwin over Sundar. Also spinners can operate even at 40+ and their job doesn’t require much fitness, Murali, Herath, Warne, Qadir all had a belly. No reason to exclude Ashwin from the only away country where he actually wins matches. Link to comment
Kron Posted February 29 Share Posted February 29 30 minutes ago, Adamant said: The 5 venues would probably be Adelaide, Brisbaine, Perth, Melbourne, Sydney. For Adelaide, Scg and Mcg play both Jadeja and Ashwin. If one of them flops in two matches replace him with Sundar. I am counting Pant out as I don’t see a chance of him being there. In Gabba and Perth, we should go with this lineup: Sharma Jaiswal Gill Kohli Rahul Jurel Sundar Jadeja Shami / Akashdeep Siraj Bumrah In scg, Mcg and adelaide we will need Ashwin over Sundar. Also spinners can operate even at 40+ and their job doesn’t require much fitness, Murali, Herath, Warne, Qadir all had a belly. No reason to exclude Ashwin from the only away country where he actually wins matches. Nice one. Need 2 backup pacers too Go with harshit, mayank Link to comment
deepdynamo Posted February 29 Share Posted February 29 For the Day Night Test , go with just 4 bowlers. Need proper 6 batsman + WK to avoid a 36 A O situation. Rohit Jaiswal Gill Kohli Rahul Pant Jurel Jadeja Shami Bumrah Siraj Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now