Tri Nation A series in Srilanka | June 9th - June 21 | India, Srilanka, Afghanistan | 10 am IST | Dambulla

[tapandrun]

4 minutes ago, mishra said:

Nepotism and favouritism is part of game. India A is not going to replace playing XI in international. They are to provide one or max two replacement options. Can we really say that Tilak or Suryavanshi play odis after this tournament?

Tilak is not good when he has to rotate strike, he gets too defensive and stops scoring because of the lack of grounded shots be it off -side or leg-side.

Strike rotation and scoring with minimal risk is v.impt part of odi cricket thats why when suggesting pure t20 batters it wont work in Odis

 

Vaibhav -- He is young has scored ton every series he has played so far ,its okay even if he does do well here , he should play some t20is and give him some Odis here and there may be start in mo as the opening will be done by rohit+Gill and later Gill+Jaiswal.

 

 

Vibhav/Vipraj/Arshad/Shegde are the only good picks in the side rest are not. not really sure of Thakur he looks good in domestic but never looked good in these A tours, may be give him test not white-ball

 

 

Edited June 15 by tapandrun

[vvvslaxman]

In the current ODI line up Padikkal deserved it more than Tilak.

[mishra]

Also BCCI needs to sell cricket to Indians. So it needs a New Rock Star so that crowds come to stadiums. Not everything is about just cricket. If Suryavanshi gets couple of good knocks, BCCI would have achieved what it needs now n Business Sense

[vvvslaxman]

Just now, tapandrun said:

Tilak is not good when he has to rotate strike, he gets too defensive and stops scoring because of the lack of grounded shots be it off -side or leg-side.

Strike rotation and scoring with minimal risk is v.impt part of odi cricket thats why when suggesting pure t20 batters it wont work in Odis

 

Vaibhav -- He is young has scored ton every series he has played so far ,its okay even if he does do well here , he should play some t20is and give him some Odis here and there may be start in mo as the opening will be done by rohit+Gill and later Gill+Jaiswal

Devdutt padikkal had a very good VH season. Surprised they ignored him but picked Tilak and made him captain as well.

[mishra]

1 minute ago, tapandrun said:

Tilak is not good when he has to rotate strike, he gets too defensive and stops scoring because of the lack of grounded shots be it off -side or leg-side.

Strike rotation and scoring with minimal risk is v.impt part of odi cricket thats why when suggesting pure t20 batters it wont work in Odis

 

Vaibhav -- He is young has scored ton every series he has played so far ,its okay even if he does do well here , he should play some t20is and give him some Odis here and there may be start in mo as the opening will be done by rohit+Gill and later Gill+Jaiswal

Yes, neither Tilak nor Suryavanshi have shown that they are option. I liked our bowlers though.

[Need4Speed]

33 minutes ago, BCCISelector said:

The batter was in a crouching stance. The ball would have comfortably passed below the waist in a normal upright position.

 

It didnt look enough crouching to me to not call a no ball..with that pace and trajectory..it looked above waist

[BCCISelector]

5 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Hedge might come in place of Dube , Reddy in place of pandya in the long run.

Too early to consider Hedge, he needs to work a lot on his bowling. But he is still young, so can become a good prospect in a few years.

[tapandrun]

1 minute ago, vvvslaxman said:

Devdutt padikkal had a very good VH season. Surprised they ignored him but picked Tilak and made him captain as well.

He should have been tried in mo right after the Odi wc-2023 , he is unreal in List A. Not sure if he is intnl material or not but give him chances where he is best.

[vvvslaxman]

Just now, mishra said:

Yes, neither Tilak nor Suryavanshi have shown that they are option. I liked our bowlers though.

Vaibhav is a smart kid from what i understand. He has changed gears in various age group matches when need arose.  He has all the shots, defense , gears. He just has to get the combinatione right. He will figure out on his own.  He can afford to be inconsistent for few years. Gill had horror start to his ODI career. It took a while fo rhim to get things right. Same with many players. It took about 60 odd games for ROhit to start showing his ODI prowess that too after MSD making him an opener.

[Tillu]

Tilak will be the next Kela it we keep putting him on a pedestal. Atleast Kela's batting is aesthetically pleasing whereas Tilak's batting looks forced and ugly.

[vvvslaxman]

I think Vaibhav is meant for bigger stages. Not these games. Even in domestic first class he didn't do that well. It would be counter-productive waiting eternally for him to click in lower level. India just has to keep him in the senior set up not let hi m regress in the lower level. That is what England does with Bethell who is not even close to Vaibhav level.

[st12345]

29 minutes ago, BCCISelector said:

Avishka Fernando is also an experienced international player.

I don't see any IPL superstars in this lineup except Vaibhav, Tilak and an out-of-form Gaikwad.

All of abishka dickwaala and samwickrema has played few games for lanka here and there dey r not regular 

[rkt.india]

What's the logic of superover in 50 over cricket. It should have remained a tied game.

[tapandrun]

Just now, st12345 said:

All of abishka dickwaala and samwickrema has played few games for lanka here and there dey r not regular 

SL has 9 intnl capped players, it a v.strong side specially batting line-up. But Ind should do better. 

[test fan]

someone needs to sit down with Vaibhav & tell this is not how it works. Bache ko samjhao galat line pe ja Raha hu 

[BCCISelector]

15 minutes ago, Need4Speed said:

It didnt look enough crouching to me to not call a no ball..with that pace and trajectory..it looked above waist

This ball would have been well above her waist even if she was at the crease. But she's crouching just slightly, so it is actually below waist height.

 

Knee flex is way bigger here. This would have been comfortably below waist height.

Edited June 15 by BCCISelector

[Nikhil_cric]

Keep playing 5 batsmen only and keep losing. 

[Bigg Brother]

What is Dickwella doing in A team, the guy has played 50+ test matches.

[vvvslaxman]

37 minutes ago, Nikhil_cric said:

Keep playing 5 batsmen only and keep losing. 

But bowling is the problem. Look at the new ball bowling in all 3 matches. It is pathetic. THey are going at 8 or 9 an over in a ODI game.

[Lone Wolf]

17 minutes ago, Bigg Brother said:

What is Dickwella doing in A team, the guy has played 50+ test matches.

Showing Indian batters how to play sweep and reverse sweeps...