Jump to content

Should Suresh Raina be given another chance in test team?


Should Suresh Raina be given another chance in test team?  

  1. 1.

    • Yes - He is an asset
    • Definitely not in overseas
    • Might worth trying in home conditions
    • Should be no where near test squad irrespective ofconditions


Recommended Posts

Posted
Come out of the Sehwag shell man. Gambhir-Sehwag are done. Lets move on. Good one from Raina. Gun ODI player!
Don't put Gambhir - Sehwag in same bucket. Sehwag can still offer a lot in Indian/SC pitches where he can hit the ball without moving his feet. Honestly I can see Sehwag coming back into our test side if Dhoni is removed from captaincy. Dhawan is horribly out of form, Gambhir is done and Kohli will definitely take a gamble with his Delhi mate Sehwag.
Posted
Come out of the Sehwag shell man. Gambhir-Sehwag are done. Lets move on. Good one from Raina. Gun ODI player!
His reflex/eye sight have dwindled significantly. He relied on his reflexes. That coordination is gone. Even otherwise he was not a great player in swinging conditions.
Posted
His reflex/eye sight have dwindled significantly. He relied on his reflexes. That coordination is gone. Even otherwise he was not a great player in swinging conditions.
I totally gave up on him after the way he was struggling to put a 120KPH Bret Lee away on a road during that MCC game.
Posted
okay. How many odi centuries should he make to consider him as a test player?
Zero. That's the point. You don't take the ODI performances as the yardstick to select test players. The only way for him to make the test squad is to show his prowess in first class cricket, be it Ranji, county or A tours.
Posted

If T20 can destroy a batsman's test skills, then test cricket can destroy a batsman's T20 skills. And no Indian wants to see Raina fail for CSK. So no. No Raina in Indian test team.

Posted
If T20 can destroy a batsman's test skills, then test cricket can destroy a batsman's T20 skills. And no Indian wants to see Raina fail for CSK. So no. No Raina in Indian test team.
I am an Indian.. I want him to fail for CSK :cantstop:
Posted
R Sharma has only played 6 tests and averages 50+. He deserves his chance. Raina is a short' date=' fat coward who[b'] can't play the short ball. No thanks.
correct, if only he learns he doesnt have to play short ball in test cricket he would be fine. I find this statement curious whom does shastri visualize makes way for raina? Raina isnt an opener, no 3,4,5 are not going to be disturbed so the only opening is Jaddu. Aswhin as main spinner and raina as backup with 3 seamers against aussies ??? is that what he is thinking ?
Posted
correct, if only he learns he doesnt have to play short ball in test cricket he would be fine. I find this statement curious whom does shastri visualize makes way for raina? Raina isnt an opener, no 3,4,5 are not going to be disturbed so the only opening is Jaddu. Aswhin as main spinner and raina as backup with 3 seamers against aussies ??? is that what he is thinking ?
Raina gets out more often to full lengths balls to slips due to fear of short balls and hanging on the back foot. Heck he was clueless against NZL spinners in the home test series he was dropped . He simply isn't suited to test cricket.
Posted

Can't understand why we keep going back to proven failures... Yuvi and Raina are tried, tested and failed test batsmen... All the talk about improved technique and confidence playing the short ball has got him back into the ODI squad... Let's stop at that.. Tests are a completely different ball game...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...