jalebi_bhai Posted May 8, 2015 Posted May 8, 2015 Reminds me a lot of Lendl Simmons. Similar frame, batting, bowling and fielding style.
Ironhide Posted May 8, 2015 Posted May 8, 2015 Only genuine pace all rounder in India who can bowl 135K+ and also can bat well, should be tried in ODI and t20 but not possible until Roger Binny is in selection panel.
vvvslaxman Posted May 8, 2015 Posted May 8, 2015 Only genuine pace all rounder in India who can bowl 135K+ and also can bat well' date=' should be tried in ODI and t20 but not possible until Roger Binny is in selection panel.[/quote'] If IRfan can up his pace he is also one. But he has no real skill that i could notice with ball.
vvvslaxman Posted May 8, 2015 Posted May 8, 2015 Is Pandya better than Binny? Binny is a proper dibbly dobbly swing bowler who can be quiet a handful in helpful conditions. He is eerily similar to his dad in swinging the ball. His dad was quiet good in such conditions. He is definitely a yard quicker than his dad was. Pandya's bowling needs a lot to be desired. If you want an all rounder i would want his bowling skills to be better than his batting skills.
flamy Posted May 8, 2015 Posted May 8, 2015 Yes, this is what I've observed. Bowling-wise, Binny edges out. And, haven't really seen a lot of batting from either (this IPL) to make an assessment. Pandya ~ Hooda, so far in terms of slogging.
rkt.india Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 We have hitters against spin.. in Hooda' date=' Pandya.. and few more.. How about hitters agianst pace[/quote'] We are not going to find readymade hitters against pace. They will only develop once they play them.
vvvslaxman Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 We are not going to find readymade hitters against pace. They will only develop once they play them. The best player against pace among the lower order is Ashwin. Sadly he has no power game.
rkt.india Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 The best player against pace among the lower order is Ashwin. Sadly he has no power game. We dont have any genuine pacers in domestic cricket, the reason we lack hitters against pace too.
maniac Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 Pandya can get 130+ which is a lot more than Binny...but in T20 130 speed is no benchmark as 4 overs you get a chance to go all out so 130 is not very impressive. He played a little cameo today which is good but still can't beleive I am saying this but binny is ahead at the moment....Binny's innings in the one or 2 occasions i saw him,shows he can play good bowling and in swinging conditions can be handful with the ball We seem to get impressed easily if some one can slog his ways to a quickfire cameo but that should never be the criteria....a genuine allrounder who can bat can bring both types of games ,a quickfire cameo or in case of collapse stabilize the ship and score an imprtant knock...don't trust either Pandya or Negi in such situations. Take Irfan for example,he has shown ability to play both these kind of knocks,Jadeja has regressed but still if you ask me,the sad state of Indian allrounders this is my ranking Ashwin(doesn't have the power game but a very good orthodox batsman) Irfan(FUlly fit) Binny Jadeja Axar Pandya and Negi have potential but still need them to play those back to the wall innings. Because even likes of Andhra SYmonds,PK,Karan sharma,Shami,Zaheer have played some knocks with those big hits that added value and were entertaining
rkt.india Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 Maniac, you are comparing seasoned cricketers to youngsters.
Temujin Khaghan Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 I hope this Pandya guy isnt easily satisfied and keeps improving we have replacements for jadeja, which is very good.
maniac Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 Maniac' date=' you are comparing seasoned cricketers to youngsters.[/quote'] true but 6 F.C games and 4 LIST A games over 2 years shows that,he is not even in the starting line up for his state...while he has shown to be a good utility player so far....not writing him off obviously but an allrounder has to be in the side as a front line bowler or a bat. Ashwin,Irfan are frontline bowlers for their state,where as bradman incarnate 3 300 Jadeja a frontline batsman....Binny is bits and pieces so not sure where he fits in but has shown neat technique with the bat and has done well for KTK. Hopefully this will give him a run in the ranji side and let us see where he gets from there.
rkt.india Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 true but 6 F.C games and 4 LIST A games over 2 years shows that,he is not even in the starting line up for his state...while he has shown to be a good utility player so far....not writing him off obviously but an allrounder has to be in the side as a front line bowler or a bat. Ashwin,Irfan are frontline bowlers for their state,where as bradman incarnate 3 300 Jadeja a frontline batsman....Binny is bits and pieces so not sure where he fits in but has shown neat technique with the bat and has done well for KTK. Hopefully this will give him a run in the ranji side and let us see where he gets from there. Because he is just 21 odd. He doesn't get pitches favoring pacers in his home state, so, they prefer spinners. Also, we need seam alrounder for overseas, not India.
vipin Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 I think he should be given a consistent run in the ODI A side as well as in T20s for India. Definitely has potential.
CricketAnalyst Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 Reminds me a lot of Lendl Simmons. Similar frame' date=' batting, bowling and fielding style.[/quote'] Not just reminds. It's actually difficult to tell whether it's Simmons or Pandya who took the catch. The boy will be a star though. To score 3 sixes in an over needing 30 off 12 is a performance of highest class. He's shown ability throughout and hopefully MI start being less stupid and leaving chases so late.
tweaker Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 Pandya has great benifit in having coaches like Tendulkar,Ponting,Bond,Rhodes .If he is hardworking,he can improve under their guidance
Recommended Posts