Syed Mushtaq Ali trophy 2022

[Suhaan]

3 minutes ago, coffee_rules said:

HP with no IPL stars beat a team (Punjab) full of IPL stars. Gill, Abhishek, Prabsimran Singh, Harpreet Brar. S Kaul (OK, Maybe not S Kaul). Still it shows how picking Indian team from IPL performances is causing us to lose out in WT20 since 2007. No-Shows all of them.

We aren't even picking the best from IPL

[raki05]

3 minutes ago, coffee_rules said:

HP with no IPL stars beat a team (Punjab) full of IPL stars. Gill, Abhishek, Prabsimran Singh, Harpreet Brar. S Kaul (OK, Maybe not S Kaul). Still it shows how picking Indian team from IPL performances is causing us to lose out in WT20 since 2007. No-Shows all of them.

It doesn't matter ip or domestic . A selector should have an eye to identify potential talent than solely based on stats based judgement. They might have lost due to one bad game but if you see flip side do you believe any of the HP guy deserve chances ahead of Gill, Abhishek or Prabhsimran Singh. they are even more Pathetic than the ipl star you are calling out. BTW only Gill must  and may be Abhishek might have slight probability to represent India.

[coffee_rules]

1 minute ago, raki05 said:

It doesn't matter ip or domestic . A selector should have an eye to identify potential talent than solely based on stats based judgement. They might have lost due to one bad game but if you see flip side do you believe any of the HP guy deserve chances ahead of Gill, Abhishek or Prabhsimran Singh. they are even more Pathetic than the ipl star you are calling out. BTW only Gill must  and may be Abhishek might have slight probability to represent India.

 

my comment was not about Gill/Abhishek, but in general about selection. Sometimes, we even pick red ball specialists based on recent IPL form. 

[raki05]

Just now, coffee_rules said:

 

my comment was not about Gill/Abhishek, but in general about selection. Sometimes, we even pick red ball specialists based on recent IPL form. 

That's right we should choose player based on talent and potential. Like this wc completely exposing hacks and providing opportunities to sign technically good players. Like Kohli  even Kl if he sort out his mental disintegration. Selectors should always plan well where the tournament will be hosted what would be condition like who are players in form and who can flourish in all conditions maintaining good sr. But one thing in common is players with most potential should be back than any aira gaira hacks who can only flourish and hack in ipl or domestic we shouldn't just look at the wkt column but also how the wkts were taken. Unless they do such fine grain filtering we will always have these issues like Harshal and Avesh type selection who dint even played a single game in wc inspite of playing all biletrals since 21 wt20.

[express bowling]

1 hour ago, coffee_rules said:

. No-Shows all of them.

 

 

Gill scored 45 at a SR of 140 

 

Scored 120 odd at a very high SR last game

 

Abhishek bowled well with 2 for 20 from 4 overs. 

 

But I get your overall point.

[express bowling]

Jitesh Sharma 46 off 24 balls at a SR of 191

[Vk1]

1 hour ago, express bowling said:

Jitesh Sharma 46 off 24 balls at a SR of 191

this guy is ready unless there are some chinks in the armour that we don't know

[express bowling]

17 minutes ago, Vk1 said:

this guy is ready unless there are some chinks in the armour that we don't know

 

Finisher material.

 

Something we really need.

[Vk1]

2 hours ago, express bowling said:

 

Finisher material.

 

Something we really need.

I am curious to know how far is he able to hit sixes.. in some Indian grounds they can just about clear boundary for six which can easily be a catch in other grounds 

[prudent_kreeda]

Strange the Mumbai players who are near to national contention look so unathletic . Shaw, Sarfraz , and Mulani too. Hope  Selection to state level will have YO Yo test too.  

 

[raki05]

Painful to watch 2 top domestic teams rules by trundlers. Now these trundlers get all the highlights . How come these states have no tall fast bowlers looks like there are more politics at state level than in national selection.

[Suhaan]

4 minutes ago, MultiB48 said:

Not politics ,we just dont like pacers.

There is politics in UP, Rajasthan,Bihar,MP
Yes,we dont like them,trundelrs and spinners are flavours of each season

 

[prudent_kreeda]

Did not like the game sense of any of our next line of national players in SF/ Final level . These players need to show their cricket smarts & game sense and carrry their teams and win matches.  If they cannot do that at domestic level , doubts will come how they will do in international level ?

Most just threw their wickets in such crucial matches.

Gill in SF , Shaw in SF & Final, Jaiswal in SF & Final

[vvvslaxman]

Anyone is showing SMAT live?

[vvvslaxman]

One stat that caught my attention

 

Tewatia 

 

8 matches 14 wickets 10.91 avge 6.51 ER

 

Which is pretty impressive. But batting is average this season.

[vice]

On 10/31/2022 at 3:34 PM, coffee_rules said:

Is that why Saurashtra played pre-quarters while Gujarat placed above them in NRR didn't?

Also Punjab placed above Delhi had to play PQs while Delhi didn't. Haryana placed third could still play. How was the PQs allocated? Strange draws in our domestics. Sometimes the top 2 teams play each other in Qs? WTF!

yeah i think so , the standings on bcci website inidicate that.

[tweaker]

11 hours ago, vvvslaxman said:

One stat that caught my attention

 

Tewatia 

 

8 matches 14 wickets 10.91 avge 6.51 ER

 

Which is pretty impressive. But batting is average this season.

Why the selectors have completely ignored him,never gave him an opportunity 

[Vijy]

On 11/3/2022 at 10:50 AM, Vk1 said:

this guy is ready unless there are some chinks in the armour that we don't know

doesn't seem so well-suited for short balls directed into the body?

[Need4Speed]

Probably next ipl we will see how he performs after teams have enough data against him..

[Need4Speed]

Maza nhi aaya SMAT mei..does anyone see any promising players this time..very disappointed with Prithvi Shaw in last few important matches..should hv gone up one level to put trenendous oressure on selectors..