All time ODI XI- India vs Pakistan- who will win?

[Majestic]

Rohit Sharma

Sachin Tendulkar

Virat Kohli

Yuvraj Singh

Mohammad Azharuddin 

MS Dhoni(c/wkt)

Kapil Dev

Anil Kumble

Mohammad Shami

Zaheer Khan 

Jasprit Bumrah

 

V/s

 

Saeed Anwar

Babar Azam

Zaheer Abbas

Javed Miandad 

Inzamam ul haq

Mohammad Rizwan(wkt)

Imran Khan (c)

Wasim Akram 

Saqlain Mushtaq

Waqar Younis 

Shoaib Akhtar 

[Gollum]

Pak would win 6/10 times.

[zen]

The Ind 11 in OP is a bit like a collection of stats padders!

Edited September 1, 2023 by zen

[the don]

11 minutes ago, Majestic said:

Rohit Sharma

Sachin Tendulkar

Virat Kohli

Yuvraj Singh

Mohammad Azharuddin 

MS Dhoni(c/wkt)

Kapil Dev

Anil Kumble

Mohammad Shami

Zaheer Khan 

Jasprit Bumrah

 

V/s

 

Saeed Anwar

Babar Azam

Zaheer Abbas

Javed Miandad 

Inzamam ul haq

Mohammad Rizwan(wkt)

Imran Khan (c)

Wasim Akram 

Saqlain Mushtaq

Waqar Younis 

Shoaib Akhtar 

Saqlain is better than Kumble. Wasim is the ODI goat and Akhtar is better than Zaheer. 
The difference in bowling lineups is too big. Pak would win 6-7 out of 10 as reflected im over all stats probably.

[zen]

Thodi "Joshwali" Ind 11

 

Sehwag - will smash from ball one 

Ganguly - will compete furiously 

GG - crisis man 

SKY - can confuse Pak bowlers 

Yuvi - passion

Dhoni - coolness

Hardik - Aus, Eng, & Pak are his favorite teams

Kumble - in for his performances like 10 wkts against Pak in tests (I know it is a different format) 

Srinath - at his best is as good as anyone 

Zak - for left arm angle 

Shami - for the new ball 

 

* Removed Bumrah as he can be a mental midget relatively speaking 

* Considered Kapil but he only averages 15 with the bat against Pak 

* Irfan v Zak - went with the overall better bowler 

 

 

 

Edited September 1, 2023 by zen

[Norman]

What on earth is fixeruddin doing there ? Remove him and add Ganguly who is probably the most underrated ODI batsman of all time..

 

Coming to the question, as you'd expect... Our batting is better and their bowling is ahead. 50-50 really...

[Number]

Rohit

Sachin

Virat

Ganguly

Yuvraj

MSD

Kapil

 

Tough to find a match of this batting line up. Limited overs matches are won by batting.

 

 

[Number]

8 minutes ago, zen said:

Thodi "Joshwali" Ind 11

 

Sehwag - will smash from ball one 

Ganguly - will compete furiously 

GG - crisis man 

SKY - can confuse Pak bowlers 

Yuvi - passion

Dhoni - coolness

Hardik - Aus, Eng, & Pak are his favorite teams

Kumble - in for his performances like 10 wkts against Pak in tests (I know it is a different format) 

Srinath - at his best is as good as anyone 

Zak - for left arm angle 

Shami - for the new ball 

 

* Removed Bumrah as he can be a mental midget relatively speaking 

* Kapil only averages 15 with the bat against Pak 

 

 

 

 bas karo

[Norman]

19 minutes ago, the don said:

Saqlain is better than Kumble. Wasim is the ODI goat and Akhtar is better than Zaheer. 
The difference in bowling lineups is too big. Pak would win 6-7 out of 10 as reflected im over all stats probably.

 

 

Lol not really...

 

In this day and age of two new balls and no bottle caps, Saqlain's off spin and Waqar/Dimran's bowling will be rendered useless by that Indian batting order. Only genuine threat is Wasim...

[the don]

Just now, Norman said:

 

 

Lol not really...

 

In this day and age of two new balls and no bottle caps, Saqlain's off spin and Waqar/Dimran's bowling will be rendered useless by that Indian batting order. Only genuine threat is Wasim...

Yeah in this day and age nonsense again. Lol @ two new balls somehow making kumble a better bowler than Saqi. Saeed anwar would murder him with modern bats lol, he didnt soare him back in the day.

[Majestic]

1 hour ago, Norman said:

What on earth is fixeruddin doing there ? Remove him and add Ganguly who is probably the most underrated ODI batsman of all time..

 

Coming to the question, as you'd expect... Our batting is better and their bowling is ahead. 50-50 really...

Bhai competitors are Dravid, Raina, A Jadeja, S Iyer and KL Rahul for those spots. 

 

Ganguly is a top 3 bat.

[Majestic]

1 hour ago, zen said:

Thodi "Joshwali" Ind 11

 

Sehwag - will smash from ball one 

Ganguly - will compete furiously 

GG - crisis man 

SKY - can confuse Pak bowlers 

Yuvi - passion

Dhoni - coolness

Hardik - Aus, Eng, & Pak are his favorite teams

Kumble - in for his performances like 10 wkts against Pak in tests (I know it is a different format) 

Srinath - at his best is as good as anyone 

Zak - for left arm angle 

Shami - for the new ball 

 

* Removed Bumrah as he can be a mental midget relatively speaking 

* Considered Kapil but he only averages 15 with the bat against Pak 

* Irfan v Zak - went with the overall better bowler 

 

 

 

At his best, he gets sledged by batsman himself. A meek cricketer who had pace but no fire and intimidation.

[vvvslaxman]

Ganguly/Tendulkar/Gauti/Kohli  - top 4. Shikar Dhawan  has a shout. But given the amount of encounters Ganguly and Tendulkar faced against best Pak bowling attack not the current pak bowling, they are obvious picks. Both have 8 man of the match awards against them. Both have the highest by some distance. Plus Both can bowl.  Kohli has always stepped against Pakistan with a few aberrations. Gauti is clutch.  Sehwag in one dayers never lived up to expectations. Doesn't matter what the opposition was. 

[Norman]

1 hour ago, the don said:

Yeah in this day and age nonsense again. Lol @ two new balls somehow making kumble a better bowler than Saqi. Saeed anwar would murder him with modern bats lol, he didnt soare him back in the day.

 

Lahori logic at play again..

 

 

The question is not whether Saqlain is a better bowler than Kumble. OP is asking who will win if those teams face each other. No matter what names pak will put up , saqlain will always bowl to superior players of spin than Kumble. So it doesn't matter who's better...

[Norman]

30 minutes ago, Majestic said:

Bhai competitors are Dravid, Raina, A Jadeja, S Iyer and KL Rahul for those spots. 

 

Ganguly is a top 3 bat.

 

Ganguly played bulk of his odi career in the middle order. Besides, he's certainly better than Fixeruddin anywhere he plays.

[the don]

2 minutes ago, Norman said:

 

Lahori logic at play again..

 

 

The question is not whether Saqlain is a better bowler than Kumble. OP is asking who will win if those teams face each other. No matter what names pak will put up , saqlain will always bowl to superior players of spin than Kumble. So it doesn't matter who's better...

Pakistan’s head to head is significantly better for a reason.

overall

in india

in pakistan

[vvvslaxman]

2 hours ago, the don said:

Saqlain is better than Kumble. Wasim is the ODI goat and Akhtar is better than Zaheer. 
The difference in bowling lineups is too big. Pak would win 6-7 out of 10 as reflected im over all stats probably.

 

Not with MSD. YOu can bring the best of the best.  With MSD in the team India's record against Pakistan is 61%. With VIK in the team INdia's record is 61%. When both play together win % goes up to 66%.

[wanted_desi]

We need Prasad and we are good to bowl them out. 

[Norman]

2 minutes ago, the don said:

Pakistan’s head to head is significantly better for a reason.

 

Yes that reason is - No regular bilateral cricket between the 2008-2020 period where your team used to get pumped by us 80% of the time. 

 

Thanks for the Lahori logic exhibit #63638992

[Norman]

The likes of Kohli, Rohit, Bumrah and shami hardly played any bilaterals against Pakistan. And guys like Yuvi, Dhoni, Zak dominated Pakistan in the 2000s period where they won 3 out of the 4 ODI series' played between the two sides...

 

 

But the resident Abduls want to take the bloated H2H record and convince us that their all time XI is better..... I mean what can I even say here?