Who is India's best ever ODI spinner?

[SRT_1OO]

4 hours ago, Gollum said:

Jadeja, Ashwin won us the 2013 CT. Ashwin did well in 2015 WC, Jaddu this time.

 

Chahal OTOH cost us the 2019 WC. 

Yes, but the OP is about spinner's avg and eco specifically. If you go by stats alone Chahal trumps others. 
He also played on much flatter decks and with 4 fielders restriction. 

[Haarkarjeetgaye]

48 minutes ago, SRT_1OO said:

This thread is not about spinners who can field.

 Fielding should be the first and the must skill  in ODIs. Bowling theek bhi karega lekin 10 catch chodega aud 20 run fielding mein dega to what is the point of that spinner

[Majestic]

2 hours ago, SRT_1OO said:

As I thought

[vvvslaxman]

2019 world cup was an utterly terrible world cup for all the spinners. They deliberately prepared pitches unsuitable for spinners. Somewhat similar in 2015 as well. 

[vvvslaxman]

6 hours ago, Gollum said:

Jadeja, Ashwin won us the 2013 CT. Ashwin did well in 2015 WC, Jaddu this time.

 

Chahal OTOH cost us the 2019 WC. 

 

Ashwin in the lonely  quarter final against Australia in 2011 world cup opened the bowling. The over numbers that Ashwin bowled in that match were

 

1, 3, 5, 7, 10,12, 38, 43, 47, 49.       5 overs in power play  3 overs in death.   He took out Watson in power play. Later in death overs took out Punter.

[MediumPacer]

i was expecting a bit more than this,shows the standard of indian spin.

[Majestic]

Harbhajan at its peak was pretty good too.

[Nikola]

Yuvi

[Chaos]

Shahid afridi… if yall know what i mean. Which spinner cricket balls like apple. His IQ is one to aspire!

 

oops didnt read the part “indian” haha

Edited November 25, 2023 by Chaos

[vvvslaxman]

1 hour ago, Majestic said:

Harbhajan at its peak was pretty good too.

 

You mean with "doosra"?

[Majestic]

11 hours ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

You mean with "doosra"?

Bhajji has greater peer reputation than many spinners out there. A lot of players who played with or against him rate him highly.

 

Some years ago, when Graeme Smith was asked, "who was more tougher to bowl, Kumble or Bhajji? He said Bhajji even though Kumble was part of commentary panel and sitting besides him. 

[vvvslaxman]

40 minutes ago, Majestic said:

Bhajji has greater peer reputation than many spinners out there. A lot of players who played with or against him rate him highly.

 

Some years ago, when Graeme Smith was asked, "who was more tougher to bowl, Kumble or Bhajji? He said Bhajji even though Kumble was part of commentary panel and sitting besides him. 

But after his doosra was banned he was not the same. But he was an useful batsman down the order as he could power hit.

[singhvivek141]

On 11/25/2023 at 8:06 AM, Majestic said:

The World Cup is done now so we can debate it.

 

The contenders are :

 

Anil Kumble, AVG 30, Econ 4.3

Harbhajan Singh, AVG 33, Econ 4.3

Ravindra Jadeja, AVG 36, Econ 4.8

Ravi Ashwin,, AVG 33, Econ 4.9

Kuldeep Yadav, AVG 26, Econ 5.1

 

World Cup stats :-

 

Kumble 31 wickets, Avg 22

Jadeja 27 wickets, Avg 31

Kuldeep 21 wickets, Avg 36

Harbhajan 20 wickets, Avg 40

Ashwin 18 wickets, Avg 25

 

 

Stats sums up how poor our spinners has been, despite us being known as a land of spinners.

 

Anyway, I will go with Jumbo, despite not being a "spinner" in traditional sense, he has picked up 300+ wickets in ODI's & was able to play for almost 15+ years. 

 

Ashwin started with a bang but fell flat later, Kuldeep is doing well but have to see how much he will be able to contribute. Bhajji's graph too went down a lot faster once his strengths were neutralized.

[Lord]

Kumble

[figo6762]

He would have been if he was given the same rope that was given to every one else mentioned in this thread 

 

[vvvslaxman]

1 hour ago, figo6762 said:

He would have been if he was given the same rope that was given to every one else mentioned in this thread 

 

 

Who is this specimen?

[figo6762]

20 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

Who is this specimen?

[Singh bling]

According to ICC , Maninder Singh was India's best bowler ever in ODI with rating of 851. No indian bowler has achieved this rating

 

https://www.icc-cricket.com/rankings/mens/player-rankings/odi/all-time-bowling

 

 

[Lord]

Its a bit tough to compare with ever changing rules among other things.

 

Ashwin/Jaddu would have been permanent and maybe greats with older rules.

 

I hope Kuldeep ends up as our greatest. Its only a mental thing for him.

[Rightarmfast]

Kumble is the safest option. He was pretty lethal and a fox. Only thing is, he was more of a medium pace bowler than a spinner. By the end of his career, he did start spinning though