vvvslaxman Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 Are we under-rating SMAT? Almost all the SMAT performers are doing well here. Is it high time Indian selection committed factor SMAT in as well? That doesn't have impact sub crap.
Lone Wolf Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 Said it before... SMAT > Ranji>VHT = CK Nayudu... Quality is improving very fast. It is already better than PSL BBL imo. Vijy and singhvivek141 2
rkt.india Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 (edited) 19 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said: Are we under-rating SMAT? Almost all the SMAT performers are doing well here. Is it high time Indian selection committed factor SMAT in as well? That doesn't have impact sub crap. It does have impact rule. In fact all domestic T20 tournaments have it Edited April 27, 2024 by rkt.india
singhvivek141 Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 9 minutes ago, Lone Wolf said: Said it before... SMAT > Ranji>VHT = CK Nayudu... Quality is improving very fast. It is already better than PSL BBL imo. I think Deodhar Trophy is better than Ranji. It helps playing best XI of a zone vs other. SMAT>Deodhar>VHT>Ranji I am keeping Ranji last purely because of the quality of bowlers I saw in recently concluded season. No Yudhvir, no Gurnoor, no Prithviraj, no Tyagi, no Harshit, no Mayank, no Hangargekar. It was a pure bore fest for the quick bowlers. Lone Wolf, Vijy, JaFanatic and 1 other 1 3
Lone Wolf Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 (edited) 22 minutes ago, singhvivek141 said: I think Deodhar Trophy is better than Ranji. It helps playing best XI of a zone vs other. SMAT>Deodhar>VHT>Ranji I am keeping Ranji last purely because of the quality of bowlers I saw in recently concluded season. No Yudhvir, no Gurnoor, no Prithviraj, no Tyagi, no Harshit, no Mayank, no Hangargekar. It was a pure bore fest for the quick bowlers. Oh yes... Irani trophy is also considered to be very competitive and prestigious one even though it is a one off game. Edited April 27, 2024 by Lone Wolf singhvivek141 and express bowling 2
Nikhil_cric Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 26 minutes ago, singhvivek141 said: I think Deodhar Trophy is better than Ranji. It helps playing best XI of a zone vs other. SMAT>Deodhar>VHT>Ranji I am keeping Ranji last purely because of the quality of bowlers I saw in recently concluded season. No Yudhvir, no Gurnoor, no Prithviraj, no Tyagi, no Harshit, no Mayank, no Hangargekar. It was a pure bore fest for the quick bowlers. Yep. Deodhar is of much better quality than whatever else Ive seen. It's why Parag should start being selected for the ODI team.
singhvivek141 Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 10 minutes ago, Lone Wolf said: Oh yes... Irani trophy is also considered to be very competitive and prestigious one even though it is a one off game. Irani Can be competitive if we make it a zonal test team...instead of one off game. Vijy, Lone Wolf and express bowling 3
tweaker Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 For Duleep Trophy the top players of each zone are selected . Duleep.trohy and Irani Trophy ' s perfomance should be given more weightage while selecting squad for test series Mosher, express bowling, Lone Wolf and 1 other 4
rkt.india Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 50 minutes ago, singhvivek141 said: Irani Can be competitive if we make it a zonal test team...instead of one off game. For that, you have duleep trophy.
rkt.india Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 Just now, jf1gp_1 said: what the hell is SMAT ? Syed Mushtaq Ali trophy jf1gp_1 1
jf1gp_1 Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 Some of the decisions in terms of fielding some of these players in IPL has been baffling. Rinku who was a sure shot for t20 WC will most likely miss the bus. Why ? Because KKR always played him down the order, giving him limited to no opportunity to perform. Umran who was recently handed fast bowling contract is the only guy who hasnt got a game. I was hoping for Jhural to shine but again limited opportunities. Sarfarz is not even in IPL. Sometimes i wonder if some of them are held back on purpose either both by Indian captains who dont want them taking their spot in India team or non-indian captains cause they dont want young local talent to develop.
Lone Wolf Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 1 hour ago, Lone Wolf said: Oh yes... Irani trophy is also considered to be very competitive and prestigious one even though it is a one off game. Reckon RoI should get to play both finalists of Ranji Trophy instead of just champions. That would be justified.
Lone Wolf Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 1 minute ago, jf1gp_1 said: Some of the decisions in terms of fielding some of these players in IPL has been baffling. Rinku who was a sure shot for t20 WC will most likely miss the bus. Why ? Because KKR always played him down the order, giving him limited to no opportunity to perform. Umran who was recently handed fast bowling contract is the only guy who hasnt got a game. I was hoping for Jhural to shine but again limited opportunities. Sarfarz is not even in IPL. Sometimes i wonder if some of them are held back on purpose either both by Indian captains who dont want them taking their spot in India team or non-indian captains cause they dont want young local talent to develop. Impact player rule might get revoked next season but it has given chances to likes of Shashank Ashutosh & even allowed Reddy Ramandeep types to fit in as well. Lord 1
Lord Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 1 minute ago, Lone Wolf said: Impact player rule might get revoked next season but it has given chances to likes of Shashank Ashutosh & even allowed Reddy Ramandeep types to fit in as well. Yes it should be tweaked not scrapped
singhvivek141 Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 50 minutes ago, rkt.india said: For that, you have duleep trophy. Ah..forgot about that. Scrap Irani then...it serves no purpose.
jf1gp_1 Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 11 minutes ago, Lone Wolf said: Impact player rule might get revoked next season but it has given chances to likes of Shashank Ashutosh & even allowed Reddy Ramandeep types to fit in as well. Instead of turning Rinku into a finished product we run towards next shiny object. Realistically Shashank is unlikely to play for India. Nitesh has hardik and dube ahead of him. Ashutosh is the only one i have some hope.
vvvslaxman Posted April 27, 2024 Author Posted April 27, 2024 (edited) Rohit Kohli Rahul SKY Pant Jadeja Hardik Axar Bumrah Arshdeep Kuldeep vs Jaiswal Abishek Gill Samson Parag Dube Rinku Harshit Kuldeep sen Nattu Chahal Who will win. If you take out Bumrah first team is likely to lose. Edited April 27, 2024 by vvvslaxman
Lord Posted April 27, 2024 Posted April 27, 2024 3 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said: Rohit Kohli Rahul SKY Pant Jadeja Hardik Axar Bumrah Arshdeep Kuldeep vs Jaiswal Abishek Gill Samson Parag Dube Rinku Harshit Kuldeep sen Nattu Chahal Who will win. If you take out Bumrah first team is likely to lose. Don't even need to make a combined team Every IPL team will beat the Indian team with the one selected playing for India, except maybe RCB Vijy and vvvslaxman 2
vvvslaxman Posted April 27, 2024 Author Posted April 27, 2024 3 minutes ago, Lord said: Don't even need to make a combined team Every IPL team will beat the Indian team with the one selected playing for India, except maybe RCB They totally rely on Kubum . If they are a no show we are going to get thrashing of our life time. Lord 1
Recommended Posts