Gollum Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 Did you see the DK plumb LBW overturned by TV umpire now? This is either corruption or incompetence of the highest order. Why are all Indian umpires this bad?
singhvivek141 Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 Just now, Gollum said: Did you see the DK plumb LBW overturned by TV umpire now? This is either corruption or incompetence of the highest order. Why are all Indian umpires this bad? Lack of accountability. Our selectors are bad coz no one questions them. Our coaches are just bad coz they have zero ownership. Our team is poor, yet same faces continue to play match after match. Mediocrity promotes mediocrity. Texan, Gollum and Ultimate_Game 2 1
kosingh Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 People sometimes say that in the past, India had great umpires. I don't remember that. I hope people aren't saying that the likes of Venkatraghavan, Philoo Reporter, Bansal, Ramaswamy were good umpires.
Real McCoy Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 1 hour ago, singhvivek141 said: Lack of accountability. Our selectors are bad coz no one questions them. Our coaches are just bad coz they have zero ownership. Our team is poor, yet same faces continue to play match after match. Mediocrity promotes mediocrity. Whip them for mistakes singapore style
Gollum Posted May 22, 2024 Author Posted May 22, 2024 2 hours ago, kosingh said: People sometimes say that in the past, India had great umpires. I don't remember that. I hope people aren't saying that the likes of Venkatraghavan, Philoo Reporter, Bansal, Ramaswamy were good umpires. Venkat was a damn good umpire. Real McCoy 1
Real McCoy Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 48 minutes ago, Gollum said: Venkat was a damn good umpire. True. The current international umpires from India are pretty good esepcially the one from Kerala with glasses.
Scarface Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 1 hour ago, Scarface said: How is that out? He was not in control of the ball while breaking stumps Jurel runout
bowl_out Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 (edited) 2 hours ago, Scarface said: Jurel runout Next time someone should touch the ball with one hand and break the stumps with the other hand. We used to have something called "Current" in gully cricket. This has been reduced to that Edited May 22, 2024 by bowl_out Scarface and AuxiliA 2
Vijy Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 4 hours ago, Gollum said: Did you see the DK plumb LBW overturned by TV umpire now? This is either corruption or incompetence of the highest order. Why are all Indian umpires this bad? RCB effect
Vijy Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 1 hour ago, Gollum said: Venkat was a damn good umpire. I think he was on the elite panel, for what it's worth
Chaos Posted May 22, 2024 Posted May 22, 2024 3 hours ago, Lord said: That was not even in top 5 worst decisions this IPL lol oh rly? Either u r blind af or just naive. Easily in top 5 for umpiring blunders. Bat hit the pad way before.
bowl_out Posted May 23, 2024 Posted May 23, 2024 The more I think about Mitch Mcclenegan's tweet, the more I feel Jurel was not out. On reading the rule, it feels like the wrong decision was made.. Green wasn't holding the ball Key word = HELD @Lord @Gollum @vvvslaxman Thoughts? Scarface and vvvslaxman 2
vvvslaxman Posted May 23, 2024 Posted May 23, 2024 3 minutes ago, bowl_out said: The more I think about Mitch Mcclenegan's tweet, the more I feel Jurel was not out. On reading the rule, it feels like the wrong decision was made.. Green wasn't holding the ball Key word = HELD @Lord @Gollum @vvvslaxman Thoughts? I watched the full replay. He lost the ball. No control whatsoever. His finger disturbed the bails
bowl_out Posted May 23, 2024 Posted May 23, 2024 8 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said: I watched the full replay. He lost the ball. No control whatsoever. His finger disturbed the bails Reading the rule again, even if he held the ball and broke the bails with his forearm, it would be out. But he did not hold the ball. Poor umpiring. And the worst part is all the so called expert commentators think it is out. Vijy and Scarface 2
bowl_out Posted May 23, 2024 Posted May 23, 2024 45 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said: I watched the full replay. He lost the ball. No control whatsoever. His finger disturbed the bails One more video/photo for the claim. It looks like he broke the stumps with his left hand and the ball was touching his right hand.
Vijy Posted May 23, 2024 Posted May 23, 2024 (edited) 7 hours ago, vvvslaxman said: I watched the full replay. He lost the ball. No control whatsoever. His finger disturbed the bails Green giving RR the Finger. And Fraudulent 3rd Umpire indulging this elite-level Fingering. Edited May 23, 2024 by Vijy
Ultimate_Game Posted May 24, 2024 Posted May 24, 2024 That was not out. At best there was doubt, and the benefit of doubt goes to the batsman. Poor umpiring and generally these poor umpiring decisions goes in favor of teams with star players, i.e. MI, RCB etc.
Gollum Posted May 24, 2024 Author Posted May 24, 2024 Jurel was not out, only an Indian umpire can make such a decision.
Chaos Posted May 24, 2024 Posted May 24, 2024 20 hours ago, bowl_out said: The more I think about Mitch Mcclenegan's tweet, the more I feel Jurel was not out. On reading the rule, it feels like the wrong decision was made.. Green wasn't holding the ball Key word = HELD @Lord @Gollum @vvvslaxman Thoughts? Why tag those three for opinions, as if they r “anal-ists”. Tag me
Recommended Posts