Have Chahal/Yadav done enough to displace Ashwin/Jadeja from ODI squad for WC?

[surajmal]

IMO, Yes. 

[Gollum]

Yes. Ash-Jaddu have won us many matches in the past but are clearly past it, both should stick to test cricket and IPL only. Time for GenNext to take over the mantle in white ball cricket. 

[mani sha]

kuldeep in tests abroad esp in sa and aussie. will get u wickets 

one day jadeja still has a role on fla pitches 

[AmreekanDesi]

Jaddu yes

 

not Ashwin

 

come the big tournaments and Ashwin will come to the party 

[fineleg]

10 or 11 out of 11 for WC squad should be good to very good fielders (apart from their primary skill)

Jadeja , Chahal are very good, and good fielders respectively.

KY is average

Ashwin is below average

[Temujin Khaghan]

I want to try krunal pandya instead of kuldeep at wt20 and give him enough intl experience in the next 2 years.

[02/04/11]

Need jadeja for batting and fielding, can't win the world cup with bhuvi at 8 and three number 11's behind him

[speedheat]

More then enough

[PSB_Zone]

yes ashwin will be in the squad though as a 3rd spinner for W cup

[gakgupta]

Now middle overs are exciting to watch....thanks to both these players...

Gone are those days where curtailing runs was more important than taking wickets...

Sent from my XT1068 using Tapatalk

[jf1gp_1]

Jaddu is an exceptional fielder, has a good record in England with bat and ball he will be in the squad.

[ThePhenomenal1]

Yes absolutely, Chahal has been on fire and kuldeep picking up wickets too. both are ideal for taking out the tail as well which is a plus

[ThePhenomenal1]

38 minutes ago, AmreekanDesi said:

Jaddu yes

 

not Ashwin

 

come the big tournaments and Ashwin will come to the party 

cant use this argument after CT17, in the final both went bust and i'd rather have wicket taking options like chahal and kuldeep

[adi B]

Atm,absolutely  yes. Ashwin and jadeja were good for a while but have regressed a lot ,deservedly dropped 

[adi B]

Jadeja though should be in the reckoning and ahead of axar,he's a better bat and an exceptional fielder 

[Vijy]

yes, given ash/jaddu's odi form.

[AmreekanDesi]

31 minutes ago, ThePhenomenal1 said:

cant use this argument after CT17, in the final both went bust and i'd rather have wicket taking options like chahal and kuldeep

It was an aberration and he was unlucky too. And the opener was lucky. Got a catch dropped 

[Gollum]

After Jadeja's show in CT final, never want to see that selfish mediocre coward in colored jersey. Ashwin isn't selfish and isn't a coward but has regressed dramatically. 

[SK_IH]

25 minutes ago, adi B said:

Jadeja though should be in the reckoning and ahead of axar,he's a better bat and an exceptional fielder 

bhai maaf karo,time to move on

 

krunal should be part of set up as well,also karn sharma had some wonderful performnaces last year,he should also be in the reckoning 

[SUMO]

Jaddu should be 3rd spinner in WC