Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
20 hours ago, Gollum said:

Though no one here has seen Major Dhyan Chand play even in videos, he is to India what Bradman is to Australia. 

 

Apart from that, agree. 

 

overrated?

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Lord said:

 

overrated?

If anything Aussies underrate their legendary sportspersons.

 

Margaret Court has 24 grand slams, yet they don't hype her up like how other western countries hype up Serena, Navratilova, Evert, Graff etc.

 

Rod Laver was as great as current Big 3 and then they had Emerson, Rosewall, Newcombe...all comparable to Sampras/Borg. No hype. 

 

Ian Thorpe was Phelps' idol. How many times have Aussies hyped him? For many Dawn Fraser is female GOAT, yet is treated like a joke by Aussies.

 

In absolute terms, Jamie Dwyer is the GOAT hockey player. Most Aussies are unaware of him. 

 

Nobody even received Cummins at the airport after Nov 19th thing. 

 

That is why I never buy this Bradman overrated thing, if someone was twice as good as the second best of his time, that is a statistical marvel. 

 

Here is Jeff Thomson about his experience of bowling to an old Bradman Thommo relives bowling to The Don. No need to praise him because his generation Aussie players despised Bradman due to his administrative decisions. Even today Ian Chappell is so bitter about Don. 

 

Like Don, Dhyan Chand too was a statistical outlier, even today people (including goras) omit him out of respect when rating hockey players......because number 1 spot is undisputed, like it is for Bradman. 3 Olympic gold medals and could have won more, but hockey wasn't featured in 1924 Paris....and no Olympics in 1940 and 1944 due to WW 2. 

 

In absolute terms there have been better batsmen than Don, better hockey players than Dhyan. But compared to peers nobody maintained as big a gap between 1 and 2......Viv and Greg Chappell comparable, Sachin and Lara comparable, Kohli/ABDV/Smith, Shahbaz Ahmed/Hassan Sardar, de Nooijer/Jamie Dwyer.

 

 

Edited by Gollum
Posted
20 hours ago, Gollum said:

If anything Aussies underrate their legendary sportspersons.

 

Margaret Court has 24 grand slams, yet they don't hype her up like how other western countries hype up Serena, Navratilova, Evert, Graff etc.

 

Rod Laver was as great as current Big 3 and then they had Emerson, Rosewall, Newcombe...all comparable to Sampras/Borg. No hype. 

 

Ian Thorpe was Phelps' idol. How many times have Aussies hyped him? For many Dawn Fraser is female GOAT, yet is treated like a joke by Aussies.

 

In absolute terms, Jamie Dwyer is the GOAT hockey player. Most Aussies are unaware of him. 

 

Nobody even received Cummins at the airport after Nov 19th thing. 

 

That is why I never buy this Bradman overrated thing, if someone was twice as good as the second best of his time, that is a statistical marvel. 

 

Here is Jeff Thomson about his experience of bowling to an old Bradman Thommo relives bowling to The Don. No need to praise him because his generation Aussie players despised Bradman due to his administrative decisions. Even today Ian Chappell is so bitter about Don. 

 

Like Don, Dhyan Chand too was a statistical outlier, even today people (including goras) omit him out of respect when rating hockey players......because number 1 spot is undisputed, like it is for Bradman. 3 Olympic gold medals and could have won more, but hockey wasn't featured in 1924 Paris....and no Olympics in 1940 and 1944 due to WW 2. 

 

In absolute terms there have been better batsmen than Don, better hockey players than Dhyan. But compared to peers nobody maintained as big a gap between 1 and 2......Viv and Greg Chappell comparable, Sachin and Lara comparable, Kohli/ABDV/Smith, Shahbaz Ahmed/Hassan Sardar, de Nooijer/Jamie Dwyer.

 

 

 

Agree - the number of legendary Australian athletes are too many to name. 

 

I think Ian Thorpe and Cathy Freeman were probably the only major athletes who were feted quite a bit.

Posted
5 hours ago, bharathh said:

 

Agree - the number of legendary Australian athletes are too many to name. 

 

I think Ian Thorpe and Cathy Freeman were probably the only major athletes who were feted quite a bit.

Cos of 2000 Sydney Olympics.

 

They were the face, also being an aboriginal woman helped Cathy Freeman, that Olympics placed lot of emphasis on honoring Aus indigenous people, that was also a pitch when they bid. Sally Pearson today is a more decorated athlete but hardly ever talked about.

 

Ian Thorpe is a gay icon, so he gets lot of coverage. 

 

Aussie sports culture is next level. Pound for pound the greatest sporting country, so many icons.

Posted
On 5/19/2024 at 12:22 PM, Gollum said:

But compared to peers nobody maintained as big a gap between 1 and 2.

Is that an indictment of the overall lack of quality in their eras?

 

If there are players who are better in absolute terms, I would rank them higher because maintaining a gap may just be a function of how good or bad the others were at the same time.

Posted
1 hour ago, BacktoCricaddict said:

Is that an indictment of the overall lack of quality in their eras?

 

If there are players who are better in absolute terms, I would rank them higher because maintaining a gap may just be a function of how good or bad the others were at the same time.

As the saying goes, champion in one era will be champion in another. These guys were pioneers, I am sure they would have adapted their games in the modern era to rule their sports. 

 

If you look at the bats Bradman played with, how he practiced with golf clubs, the legends about Dhyan Chand playing with umbrella handle or practicing his dribbling skills with raw eggs, these were superhumans. Paul Morphy was a similar legend but in chess, you may find his story interesting. 

Posted (edited)
On 5/19/2024 at 12:22 PM, Gollum said:

If anything Aussies underrate their legendary sportspersons.

 

Margaret Court has 24 grand slams, yet they don't hype her up like how other western countries hype up Serena, Navratilova, Evert, Graff etc.

 

Rod Laver was as great as current Big 3 and then they had Emerson, Rosewall, Newcombe...all comparable to Sampras/Borg. No hype. 

 

Ian Thorpe was Phelps' idol. How many times have Aussies hyped him? For many Dawn Fraser is female GOAT, yet is treated like a joke by Aussies.

 

In absolute terms, Jamie Dwyer is the GOAT hockey player. Most Aussies are unaware of him. 

 

Nobody even received Cummins at the airport after Nov 19th thing. 

 

That is why I never buy this Bradman overrated thing, if someone was twice as good as the second best of his time, that is a statistical marvel. 

 

Here is Jeff Thomson about his experience of bowling to an old Bradman Thommo relives bowling to The Don. No need to praise him because his generation Aussie players despised Bradman due to his administrative decisions. Even today Ian Chappell is so bitter about Don. 

 

Like Don, Dhyan Chand too was a statistical outlier, even today people (including goras) omit him out of respect when rating hockey players......because number 1 spot is undisputed, like it is for Bradman. 3 Olympic gold medals and could have won more, but hockey wasn't featured in 1924 Paris....and no Olympics in 1940 and 1944 due to WW 2. 

 

In absolute terms there have been better batsmen than Don, better hockey players than Dhyan. But compared to peers nobody maintained as big a gap between 1 and 2......Viv and Greg Chappell comparable, Sachin and Lara comparable, Kohli/ABDV/Smith, Shahbaz Ahmed/Hassan Sardar, de Nooijer/Jamie Dwyer.

 

 

Dhyan Chand is indubitably No. 1, the Bradman of his time. And Balbir Singh Sr was arguably as great a player in clutch matches. Our hockey riches can leave all other Ind sportspeople in the dust - despite isolated (i.e., one-off) legends like Vishy Anand, Neeraj, etc

 

what do you think @Gollum?

Edited by Vijy
Posted (edited)
4 hours ago, Sandz said:

Arshad Nadeem on his heels, might pip him one day!

H2H is 12-0 or something like that. Neeraj has never lost to him in a direct faceoff. 

 

Arshad is a champ but Neeraj is another level especially in terms of consistency and clutchness. 

Edited by Gollum
Posted

Goat of the goat. Undisputed champ. 

 

Kiss his feet not pussy virat and roro

 

Indians don't deserve true champ athletes. Disgusting attitude. 

 

 

Posted
1 hour ago, Kron said:

Goat of the goat. Undisputed champ. 

 

Kiss his feet not pussy virat and roro

 

Indians don't deserve true champ athletes. Disgusting attitude. 

 

 

for every champ, you need several chimps, and many more chumps

Posted
20 hours ago, randomGuy said:

 

 

 

why do we need to watch this f**kwit Dinesh Crapthik along with Champ neeraj?

×
×
  • Create New...