rollingstoned Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 Does he deserve a place in the odi setup? He has a not-inconsiderable body of work in domestic cricket, is CSK captain and perhaps the right age. He has some weaknesses against moving ball but seems to have good scoring options against spin. tweaker and Suhaan 2
vvvslaxman Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 He deserves. We should back him as he earned it. Similarly in Tests domestic players should be rewarded. The Hound 1
BacktoCricaddict Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 (edited) 2 hours ago, rollingstoned said: is CSK captain that alone should disqualify him ;-) Seriously though, for the 2027 ODI WC, he should be in the running. Who knows how healthy Iyer will be? So, he could be the one to handle middle-over spinners. Giving him a good run now cannot be a bad thing. Edited December 4, 2025 by BacktoCricaddict
Chakdephatte Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 (edited) I haven't seen many Indian players as comfortable against quality pace as him. Edited December 5, 2025 by Chakdephatte
vvvslaxman Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 18 minutes ago, Chakdephatte said: I haven't seen many Indian players as comfortable against quality pace as him. Can even be tried in Australia for BGT. Far fetched but you get the point. He has starting troubles. Once he goes past that he will get more and more dominating as the innings goes on. Even though he was in the 90s approaching his first ever 100 he didn't waste time like Kohli was doing.
bowl_out Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 Good play against spin and pace. Can play anywhere in the top 4? Honestly, he should be in contention ahead of Jaiswal. 1-4. : Top order batsmen - Rohit, Gill, Kohli, Iyer are a lock for top 4. (Back up : Ruturaj can be the backup in the squad for any of them) 5 : Keeper - KL is locked as keeper. Don't think they'll change it (Back up : Unclear. One of Samson/Jurel) 6-7 : Batting all rounders - Pandya, Axar (back up : Unclear. Not Washi for sure. Probably Parag) 8 : Bowling all rounder - Rana? 9 : Spinner - Kuldeep 10-11: Pacers - Bumrah, Siraj (back up : Arshdeep) That's what our squad looks like. Clarity needed on: 1. Who is the backup keeper? 2. When are they planning to boot out Jadeja and get Axar in? 3. Who is the back up at 6-7? If it is Parag, then he should get some game time. 4. Is Rana a lock? 5. Is Kuldeep a lock? Or should Varun get a look in?
vvvslaxman Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 50 minutes ago, bowl_out said: Good play against spin and pace. Can play anywhere in the top 4? Honestly, he should be in contention ahead of Jaiswal. 1-4. : Top order batsmen - Rohit, Gill, Kohli, Iyer are a lock for top 4. (Back up : Ruturaj can be the backup in the squad for any of them) 5 : Keeper - KL is locked as keeper. Don't think they'll change it (Back up : Unclear. One of Samson/Jurel) 6-7 : Batting all rounders - Pandya, Axar (back up : Unclear. Not Washi for sure. Probably Parag) 8 : Bowling all rounder - Rana? 9 : Spinner - Kuldeep 10-11: Pacers - Bumrah, Siraj (back up : Arshdeep) That's what our squad looks like. Clarity needed on: 1. Who is the backup keeper? 2. When are they planning to boot out Jadeja and get Axar in? 3. Who is the back up at 6-7? If it is Parag, then he should get some game time. 4. Is Rana a lock? 5. Is Kuldeep a lock? Or should Varun get a look in? Indian bowlers are silent enemies because they are pathetic fielders invariably. Batting is non existent. India needs 7 batsmen including pandya. Jadeja cannot be part of the 7.
tapandrun Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 think he was already playing #4 for domestic side, also did some wk in domestic t20 league Manucrick 1
vvvslaxman Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 He has a top gear that can match Rohit sharma. Kela and Gill rcan never produce a 25 run over. Rutu and Iyer can produce big overs. When they pick a side they have to see various attributes of a player. tweaker, Manucrick and sorak 3
Chaos Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 5 hours ago, vvvslaxman said: He deserves. We should back him as he earned it. Similarly in Tests domestic players should be rewarded. Madrassi
vvvslaxman Posted December 4, 2025 Posted December 4, 2025 (edited) 2 minutes ago, Chaos said: Madrassi Are you sad he is not a biryani gulping golt? lol he is a maharastrian by the way much like Rajini kanth. Edited December 4, 2025 by vvvslaxman
maniac Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 Potential national treasure? @BacktoCricaddict nevada and BacktoCricaddict 2
Lord Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 He should play Tests. Very good player of spin especially plays lot of sweeps. Not much of a hitter as required for modern ODIs
vvvslaxman Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 3 hours ago, Lord said: He should play Tests. Very good player of spin especially plays lot of sweeps. Not much of a hitter as required for modern ODIs He has scored 7 sixes in one over. He has better top gear than Gill/Kohli. You could see how he accelerated through the overs. tweaker 1
vvvslaxman Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 3 hours ago, maniac said: Potential national treasure? @BacktoCricaddict SKY has gone from national treasure to national waste much like Rashmika mandanna went from national crush to national cringe. maniac, tweaker and Forever Indian 3
Ajju Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 Should be Indias captain since he already csk captain Manucrick 1
Manucrick Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 35 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said: He has scored 7 sixes in one over. He has better top gear than Gill/Kohli. You could see how he accelerated through the overs. Set ruturaj is deadly I agree that
tweaker Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 Ruturaj Patidar Sarfaraz Should be the Middle order
maniac Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 We have too many o similar type of players in the same squad/ X1 Rutu, Gill- There is a place for only 1 of these 2 Pant, Rahul, Samson, Kishen- there is a room for only 1 of these 4 to give team more depth. They all might have different strengths and weaknesses but overall don’t need 2 of these in the same X1. Axar, Jadeja, Sundar- Again there is a place for only 1 of these 3 in the X1 (in the squad 2/3 max). BacktoCricaddict and tweaker 1 1
tweaker Posted December 5, 2025 Posted December 5, 2025 12 minutes ago, maniac said: We have too many o similar type of players in the same squad/ X1 Rutu, Gill- There is a place for only 1 of these 2 Pant, Rahul, Samson, Kishen- there is a room for only 1 of these 4 to give team more depth. They all might have different strengths and weaknesses but overall don’t need 2 of these in the same X1. Axar, Jadeja, Sundar- Again there is a place for only 1 of these 3 in the X1 (in the squad 2/3 max). Hope Ajit Agarkar understand this maniac 1
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now