Stuart Binny is uesless

[Gollum]

He atleast doesn't say "come to India" :hysterical: Saved the match.. It is worth 150 runs

:hysterical::hysterical::hysterical:

[Gunner]

Played a good knock today, still doesn't make him Test material.

[King Tendulkar]

Played a good knock today' date=' still doesn't make him Test material.[/quote'] Bingo

[maniac]

Bingo

Seriously people are talking as if his innings was a widen top 100 innings of all time :haha:

[Lord]

Seriously people are talking as if his innings was a widen top 100 innings of all time :haha:

whos talking like that?But he did save us from a precarious position,that too in debut match overseas. If it was Nohit,you'd have made it sound like that,we all know what he did in similar position in 2nd Test in SA :cantstop:

[vvvslaxman]

whos talking like that?But he did save us from a precarious position,that too in debut match overseas. If it was Nohit,you'd have made it sound like that,we all know what he did in similar position in 2nd Test in SA :cantstop:

And in NZ

[Yoda-esque]

Go FCB!

[ThePhenomenal1]

Binny atleast saved the match, something rohit sharma could never do! But id drop him to add another seamer. Makes sense tbh. No hate on binny, just saying what we need. Even better would be for dhoni to go and saha come in. With ashwin at 7, thats a really solid top 6-7 incl kumar at 8.

[SLICKR392]

Kates, you gotta pick 1 here- Irfan Pathan or Stuart Binny? :cantstop:

[King Tendulkar]

Joke player

[coffee_rules]

Joke player

Ball going 6 in over the wicket, ump gives him out.

[ThePhenomenal1]

unlucky today, but looked ok. see how he bowls. If he doesnt do much id drop him

[WeStMiDz]

Will bowl well on this wicket I feel.

[maniac]

Looked like a world beater with the bat after watching Dhoni and Jaddu :giggle: but still not convinced

[Old guy]

Looked like a world beater with the bat after watching Dhoni and Jaddu :giggle: but still not convinced

easily better than jadeja :giggle: just drop jaddu and play ashwin and lets hope binny gets 1-2 wickets tomorrow

[TheWall]

He will come good in 2nd innings.

[BeautifulGame]

easily better than jadeja :giggle: just drop jaddu and play ashwin and lets hope binny gets 1-2 wickets tomorrow

Jadeja is first choice spinner should be judged on how he bowls.But he should come after Bhuvi in the 2nd inns. Cant pick bowlers based on batting credentials

[virufan]

Well played but still pointless...I mean Anderson,Bhuvan,shami,broad have played knocks in some capacity to help their teams cause so in that context wonderful innings by Stuart....the difference being all the other names mentioned actually bowled a lot of overs and contributed in some form where as Stuart binny was pointless in every other aspect. This 78 should qualify him as a batsman....but do you think he is good enough to make the side solely as a batsman? Don't think so

U r right. If it is a pitch where he can move the ball, its good. But does he have the ability to bat on the same pitch where the ball is moving is yet to be seen.

[virufan]

Jadeja is first choice spinner should be judged on how he bowls.But he should come after Bhuvi in the 2nd inns. Cant pick bowlers based on batting credentials

Or let jaddu go after the bowling as he tried to in SA. Atleast that way, some runs can be added to the kitty.

[Temujin Khaghan]

Binny might be a bad selection, but definitely not the worst. that is jadeja atm. even he is not a bad player, but shouldn't be picked in this format, definitely not in England, and most definitely not on the greenest track in the history of Lords.