Ishan Kishan vs Rishabh Pant- who will make it?

[maniac]

Personally want both to succeed.like them both 

 

Seen both and both are impressive and incredibly talented.

 

For some reason Kishan comes across as someone who has a better temperament than Pant.

 

On the other hand Pant seems like the guy who can take even the best attacks to task.

 

Early on I thought Kishan was the better keeper and Pant the better batsman but Pant has improved his keeping and Kishan his batting.

 

I hope we don’t see a Dhoni vs Karthik type scenario here were 2 incredible talents, one went on to achieve great success and the other still trying to establish himself after 12 years.

 

Obviously we all want both to do well and kick out some deadwood but if you had to pick one who would it be?

 

Love Pant but something tells me Ishan has the temperament which is half the battle won.

[kosingh]

If I were to bet I would say none. We have a pool of talented prospects thankfully out of which 2-3 will move in front of both Pant and Kishan

[maniac]

Just now, kosingh said:

If I were to bet I would say none. We have a pool of talented prospects thankfully out of which 2-3 will move in front of both Pant and Kishan

Can you name some keeper batsman who have made an impact like these 2....not being confrontational, just want to see who you have in mind.

[velu]

will vote after this IPL

 

[kosingh]

3 minutes ago, maniac said:

Can you name some keeper batsman who have made an impact like these 2....not being confrontational, just want to see who you have in mind.

my bad...i was thinking Shreyas Iyer and not Kishan. Yeah Kishan to me is a definite international prospect. 

[maniac]

1 minute ago, kosingh said:

my bad...i was thinking Shreyas Iyer and not Kishan. Yeah Kishan to me is a definite international prospect. 

Yeah , Pant is real good too and extremely talented but Kishan scores in the temperament area where as Pant might have the capacity to pull of more stunning displays of hitting comparatively.

[sandeep]

Banjo resident froggy managed to jinx 2 of our top 'keeper prospects with one post.   

 

 

[maniac]

10 minutes ago, sandeep said:

Banjo resident froggy managed to jinx 2 of our top 'keeper prospects with one post.   

 

 

Ladies and Gentleman I present you above miss.Rosemary Marlow....comes back for more

ownage

 

[maniac]

I think rather than Shaw and Gill...these 2 are ripe for the picking. They should b ready for England.

 

Funny thing is one is from Jharkand and the other from Delhi...so they will eventually have some powerful backers to put it mildly. They are so equal on all fronts it is crazy.

[Suhaan]

Pant is going to leapfrog everyone,Kishan is the other majestic wk,great to see a contest of sorts for that slot,even if anyone of them looses to other ,they have immense talent to walk into the side purely as batsman and a livewire in the field

[Pollack]

Why not both? Alternately keeping.

If one is to be picked, have to go with R Panth.

[maniac]

1 minute ago, Pollack said:

Why not both? Alternately keeping.

If one is to be picked, have to go with R Panth.

We might eventually  face a Dhoni-Karthik situation with these 2

[SUMO]

Pant kishan samson or even harvik koi to succeed hoga hi international level pe

[maniac]

2 minutes ago, SUMO said:

Pant kishan samson or even harvik koi to succeed hoga hi international level pe

Harvik is too raw and Samson don’t think he keeps anymore...these 2 are the next in the pecking order.

[velu]

Just now, maniac said:

Harvik is too raw and Samson don’t think he keeps anymore...these 2 are the next in the pecking order.

 

please dont terminate their careers

 

[maniac]

1 minute ago, velu said:

 

please dont terminate their careers

 

Check my siggy :)

[velu]

5 minutes ago, maniac said:

Check my siggy :)

 

first time reading this phrase :( 

[velu]

2 minutes ago, UnknownGenius said:

Forget the big names.   Narayan Jagadeesan - 22 years, List A avg close to 45 and strike rate above 90+ Overall better List A numbers than Pant or Kishan

 

 

i am his #1 fan , he is from my grandmothers place

 

[maniac]

2 minutes ago, UnknownGenius said:

Forget the big names.   Narayan Jagadeesan - 22 years, List A avg close to 45 and strike rate above 90+ Overall better List A numbers than Pant or Kishan

Maybe...need to take a closer look...impressive stats but he plays for CSK as a keeper...career killed

 

[maniac]

1 minute ago, velu said:

 

 

i am his #1 fan , he is from my grandmothers place

 

Regionalism  still waiting for 1 vote for Pant from Washington DC