Jump to content
sage

Virat Kohli in danger of suspension after remonstrating with on-field umpire over DRS call

Recommended Posts

Poms can whine and moan all they want. Did Kohli go overboard yes but we have seen aggressive captains do that before too. That does not deserve ban, Is Bumble too old to remember  Ponting dressing down Aleem Dar , did he get any ban then.

 

This nonsense that umpires are beyond reproach is ridiculous.

Link to post
2 hours ago, ShoonyaSifar said:

Err there was a small matter of Root scoring only 218 runs after winning the toss. Kohli won the toss and scored a grand duck!

Didnt have any bearing on result. On flipside Without Roots 200 good chance India would have drawn the match at least. 

Link to post
13 hours ago, putrevus said:

Poms can whine and moan all they want. Did Kohli go overboard yes but we have seen aggressive captains do that before too. That does not deserve ban, Is Bumble too old to remember  Ponting dressing down Aleem Dar , did he get any ban then.

 

This nonsense that umpires are beyond reproach is ridiculous.

So on field captains are the ones who will reproach the umpires?

 

We have formal process to lodge complaints, not shout and scream on the field. England got way more bad decisions 

 

And i am baffled people don't have the common sense  to realize that if powerful captains get away with shouting and intimidating umpires, we will be back to shakoor Rana age where umpires will never give decisions against powerful captains

 

India really does not need to win like this

 

Edited by New guy
Link to post
9 hours ago, New guy said:

So on field captains are the ones who will reproach the umpires?

 

We have formal process to lodge complaints, not shout and scream on the field. England got way more bad decisions 

 

And i am baffled people don't have the common sense  to realize that if powerful captains get away with shouting and intimidating umpires, we will be back to shakoor Rana age where umpires will never give decisions against powerful captains

 

India really does not need to win like this

 

Did India win that decision where Kohli was complaining. No they did not so what is your point in comparing with Shakoor rana. You cannot  go back to Shakoor Rana days with all these replays. 

 

Why is players are the only ones who are penalized for umpiring blunders. Yes umpires might get kicked out after the fact. So players in my view should be allowed to vent to certain extent.

 

To me players especially captains need to be allowed to protest a bad decision without any repercussion.  Good Umpires should know how to deal with aggressive captain in their own way  and that is part of being a good umpire.

 

Root was very calm and England got more bad decisions in their favor.It does not mean every captain has to have calm demeanour on the field.

Edited by putrevus
Link to post
12 hours ago, New guy said:

So on field captains are the ones who will reproach the umpires?

 

We have formal process to lodge complaints, not shout and scream on the field. England got way more bad decisions 

 

And i am baffled people don't have the common sense  to realize that if powerful captains get away with shouting and intimidating umpires, we will be back to shakoor Rana age where umpires will never give decisions against powerful captains

 

India really does not need to win like this

 

 

Agree Kohli was wrong there if anything Root showed why he is better in the way he handled it. Kohli would comeout looking better if he just calms down. 

Link to post
On 2/18/2021 at 11:21 AM, putrevus said:

Did India win that decision where Kohli was complaining. No they did not so what is your point in comparing with Shakoor rana. You cannot  go back to Shakoor Rana days with all these replays. 

 

Why is players are the only ones who are penalized for umpiring blunders. Yes umpires might get kicked out after the fact. So players in my view should be allowed to vent to certain extent.

 

To me players especially captains need to be allowed to protest a bad decision without any repercussion.  Good Umpires should know how to deal with aggressive captain in their own way  and that is part of being a good umpire.

 

Root was very calm and England got more bad decisions in their favor.It does not mean every captain has to have calm demeanour on the field.


England got Roots decision in favour plus all the umpires call. Also he is not a saint

 

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/talksport.com/sport/cricket/446485/joe-root-england-reprimand/amp/

Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...