Jaddu vs Sundar vs Axar vs Krunal vs Tewatia - Who has a better power game for No.7 ??

[Mesky99]

Sundar does not fit well as a all rounder, nothing of substance yet bar one/two cameos. Bowling ok but nothing special, Ashwin can still outbowl him. Axar does well with the ball every outing and has batting credentials, can play cameos, decent bat swing and a good timer but has been categorized as lower order bat than a all rounder, contray to the popular belief krunal fits the role better than the rest, can bat anywhere from 3-7 and open the bowling or bowl at death, he has a couple of 3 fors in t20 cricket and a better strike with the bat than axar, jadeja and sundar.

 

 

 

[Mesky99]

On 3/20/2021 at 10:13 AM, Serpico said:

tewatia-jadeja-thakur can be 7-8-9 and with bhuvi at 10, we will have only one no.11 for the wc

None of these bowlers will win any games, what's the obsession with batting deep? Hardik is back at his best, you have iyer, surya, Sanju, pant in the middle order with Hardik the all rounder that his more than enough batting, pick your five best bowlers. Prasidh, umran, bumrah, harshal and jaddu.

[Majestic]

Based on this season's performance, who have been standouts with bat and bowl and overall?

 

I would say,

 

Bat - Tewatia, Shahbaz, Axar, Krunal, Jadeja in this order

 

Bowl - Krunal, Axar, Jadeja, Shahbaz, Tewatia

 

[vvvslaxman]

Nobody has power game.  Tewatia probably hits sixes more effortlessly. At the end of the day bowling is what matters. If Tewatia scores 30 in 10 balls every 3 matches, he can go for 30 in 10 balls every match

[Majestic]

All round skills with slight preference to bowling, Axar is the best.

 

In Australia, Krunal's batting won't work. Neither would the batting of Tewatia and Axar too won't do much. Sundar probably has the best shot in these conditions.

[Lord]

On 4/30/2022 at 12:25 AM, vvvslaxman said:

Nobody has power game.  Tewatia probably hits sixes more effortlessly. At the end of the day bowling is what matters. If Tewatia scores 30 in 10 balls every 3 matches, he can go for 30 in 10 balls every match

 

doesn't need to bowl every game. Just on batting he deserves a place

[Lone Wolf]

40 minutes ago, Lord said:

 

doesn't need to bowl every game. Just on batting he deserves a place

Better to give him a run in coming 7 T20 games vs SA & Ireland. 

[vvvslaxman]

5 hours ago, Lord said:

 

doesn't need to bowl every game. Just on batting he deserves a place

 

He has to prove everywhere. Last season he was a disaster.

[Lord]

4 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

He has to prove everywhere. Last season he was a disaster.

 

that'll happen only if he plays T20Is . IPL happens majorly in India and UAE only and hes done well in both

[vvvslaxman]

6 minutes ago, Lord said:

 

that'll happen only if he plays T20Is . IPL happens majorly in India and UAE only and hes done well in both

 

In all the matches he made runs Rashid Khan, Miller (who was clearly out of form in IPL for few seasons) also clicked big with bat. It cannot be a coincidence. Didn't have the same consistency in SMAT. Harshal patel was more destructive than him in SMATfor his side. It looks like a big anomaly.

[Lord]

26 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

In all the matches he made runs Rashid Khan, Miller (who was clearly out of form in IPL for few seasons) also clicked big with bat. It cannot be a coincidence. Didn't have the same consistency in SMAT. Harshal patel was more destructive than him in SMATfor his side. It looks like a big anomaly.

 

yeah so what if he smashed Hazelwood,couldn't smash random trundler in SMAT

[Pollack]

 Jaddu, Sundar and krunal are not power hitters.

Axar is a bowler who can bat a bit. Just a bit. He is too malnourished to even consider his shots power hitting.

It's astonishing that there are 13 votes for Jaddu.

[vvvslaxman]

19 minutes ago, Lord said:

 

yeah so what if he smashed Hazelwood,couldn't smash random trundler in SMAT

 

There was this guy in the same match making his debut made 25 in 6 balls. That too smashed Lockie Ferguson. Should we back him as well? 

[Lord]

1 hour ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

There was this guy in the same match making his debut made 25 in 6 balls. That too smashed Lockie Ferguson. Should we back him as well? 

 

has he done it over multiple seasons?

 

lets select Chennai SMAT guys like SRK instead

[I6MTW]

Tewatia is the only option for finishing and power hitting. Axar, Sundar and Jadeja just don't have the potential, power and range to hit in the slog overs. Krunal is hit or miss.

 

 

[Vijy]

most of these 5 players suffer in one discipline or another (or both).

[Lord]

10 hours ago, Vijy said:

most of these 5 players suffer in one discipline or another (or both).

 

these are best we have unless we go without a spin AR . I will do that

[The Realist]

I hear scraping of the barrel. The talent pool is extremely shallow. Just have to go with the least worst option.

[Vijy]

3 hours ago, Lord said:

 

these are best we have unless we go without a spin AR . I will do that

no need for a spin AR in LOIs. go with 1 pace bowling AR (e.g., Paaandu) and proper wkt-taking spinners like Kuldeep.

[Vijy]

3 minutes ago, The Realist said:

I hear scraping of the barrel. The talent pool is extremely shallow. Just have to go with the least worst option.

it's even worse. if one is scraping the bottom of a barrel, at least: (1) there are some remnants of material, and (2) there is a barrel. In this case, a better statement is that we are left with thin air.

 

"These our actors, As I foretold you, were all spirits, and Are melted into air, into thin air"

 

@Mariyam might find the unexpected literature reference amusing.

Edited May 4, 2022 by Vijy