Jump to content

India vs Pakistan - September 4 - Pre Match Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

Posted

Super 4 round. In Dubai again. No Jadeja.

 

Who is your 11?

 

Rohit

Pant

SKY

Lohli

KL

Pandya

DK/Hooda

Ashwin

Bhuvi

Arshadeep

Bishnoi/Chahal

 

Tough to fit both DK and Pant and have six bowling options. Avesh will feature no matter what imo. How can you avoid Avesh and keep a good balance?

Posted (edited)

Shadab picked 4 wickets against Hong Kong where as our hero went wicketless. Infact, Chahal is yet to pick a wicket this Asia cup. He did not bowl badly but I would play Bishnoi on Sunday.

 

Also, we need to drop Avesh but the question is replace him with whom? Our selectors screw it up by going only 3 seamers with all of them being trundlers. Now we are desperate for a replacement of Avesh but there is none. I would still drop him and play a spinner rather.

 

Our top 3 remains a concern. I would rather open with Kohli and ask him to play shots.

 

The crucial thing will be toss. If we win the toss, we can again win like last week. But if we are batting first, we are losing the game 100%. If HK can score 152/5 against us, Pakistan will fancy chasing down any target India sets.

 

Kohli

Rohit

Rahul

Pant

SKY

Pandya

Hooda

Ashwin

Bishnoi

Bhuvi

Arshdeep

Edited by Austin 3:!6
Posted
13 minutes ago, Austin 3:!6 said:

Shadab picked 4 wickets against Hong Kong where as our hero went wicketless. Infact, Chahal is yet to pick a wicket this Asia cup. He did not bowl badly but I would play Bishnoi on Sunday.

 

Also, we need to drop Avesh but the question is replace him with whom? Our selectors screw it up by going only 3 seamers with all of them being trundlers. Now we are desperate for a replacement of Avesh but there is none. I would still drop him and play a spinner rather.

 

Our top 3 remains a concern. I would rather open with Kohli and ask him to play shots.

 

The crucial thing will be toss. If we win the toss, we can again win like last week. But if we are batting first, we are losing the game 100%. If HK can score 152/5 against us, Pakistan will fancy chasing down any target India sets.

 

Kohli

Rohit

Rahul

Pant

SKY

Pandya

Hooda

Ashwin

Bishnoi

Bhuvi

Arshdeep

Pak played in Sharjah which is a slower pitch. Your squad is better than mine. How do we fit both DK and Pant? Have to drop one of them

Posted

Seriously its absolute madness what I am reading, need to drop one of Pant or DK????

 

This is the stupidity that is Indian Cricket.

 

You keep both. Its Kohli that should be dropped. Yes I know he is the immovable object in the Indian lineup, which makes this discussion of Pant or DK just insane.

Posted
11 minutes ago, SRT100 said:

Seriously its absolute madness what I am reading, need to drop one of Pant or DK????

 

This is the stupidity that is Indian Cricket.

 

You keep both. Its Kohli that should be dropped. Yes I know he is the immovable object in the Indian lineup, which makes this discussion of Pant or DK just insane.

Considering we can’t drop top3, Pandya, Sky, we have Pant/DK and 5 bowlers is our conundrum bowlers  

Posted
42 minutes ago, the don said:

It would be interesting to see how India bat first and defend.

152 /0 could happen but the choker bumrah is not playing so india will probably win I guess.

Posted

Rohit

Kohli

Pant

Sky

Hooda

Pandya

DK

Axar

Bhuvi

Arshdeep 

Chahal

 

6 bowling options.

3 spinners - an offie, a leggie and a left arm spinner.

Batting till 9th place so just go bang bang from beginning till end.

Good lefty righty balance.

 

Beat this XI.

Posted
35 minutes ago, Number said:

Rohit

Kohli

Pant

Sky

Hooda

Pandya

DK

Axar

Bhuvi

Arshdeep 

Chahal

 

6 bowling options.

3 spinners - an offie, a leggie and a left arm spinner.

Batting till 9th place so just go bang bang from beginning till end.

Good lefty righty balance.

 

Beat this XI.

One pacer short 

Posted

I watched last few overs of Pak batting against HK. Last over first two deliveries were around shoulder and batsman didnt know how to handle them. 3rd delivery he tried the same but ball didn't bounce and was in the slot to be tonked , after that bowler lost the plot. Given what we saw in first t20 i wish we had an Ishant like bowler, pak lineup might have a short ball problem. 

Posted (edited)

Won't read too much into Pak batting. HK bowling as expected was atrocious once they were under pressure. Full Tosses, Wides and juicy half volleys.

 

Pak's bowling is better than India in these conditions and we do not have a spin basher. Who will hit Shadab and Nawaz for sixes? KL's manhoos presence in this team makes it all the more difficult. Drop him in middle order and open with Kohli. I will take a 35 ball 50 from him. Pant has to play. Avesh might play again to execute short ball ploy. 

Edited by nitinbwj
Posted

Yes we do need a spin basher in middle order.  Pak spinners almost choked us last time. 

Chahal is below average spinner with zero variations but he will play still. 

Probably best option will be to play Hooda instead of Jaddu & Ashwin instead of Avesh. 

Posted
40 minutes ago, Lone Wolf said:

Yes we do need a spin basher in middle order.  Pak spinners almost choked us last time. 

Chahal is below average spinner with zero variations but he will play still. 

Probably best option will be to play Hooda instead of Jaddu & Ashwin instead of Avesh. 

I wonder whats sundars state of fitness

Posted

Axar must play now that Jadeja is gone. Pakistanis are weak against left arm spinnes. Ideally, I would play him in Avesh's place and Hooda for Jadeja but TM will certainly go with Avesh considering the short ball ploy.

 

Likely team... 

 

Rohit

Rahul

Kohli

SKY

Pant

Pandya

Hooda

Bhuvi

Avesh

Arshdeep

Chahal

Posted

Since they are playing 5 bowlers only, we must try to put one of their spinners under pressure early. If it comes off it will throw all their planning off track.

Rohit tried that against Nawaz last game but got out unfortunately but it was worth it definitely.

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...