Jump to content

Government tells WhatsApp, Telegram and others to link services to SIM cards


Recommended Posts

Posted
1 hour ago, randomGuy said:

Digital arrest n other frauds are happening over WhatsApp calls...

But sims can be made available easily as well with fake docs in India. 

Posted
24 minutes ago, diga said:

But an active sim can also be traced for its location (atleast the last known)... digital surveillance unfortunately, but the fact of life 

 

7 hours ago, gattaca said:

In India you need this. They are no 1 frauds and scams. 

SIM requirement in the phone for UPI apps like phonePe is also a necessary evil. I can't figure out a way to use UPI app from secondary phone with secondary SIM. Probably there isn't a way sadly?

Posted
13 hours ago, gattaca said:

In India you need this. They are no 1 frauds and scams. 


But users need flexibility too. For example, I have North American #, Indian #, and so on, where the sim or eSIM can be activated based on the region I am in while using the other number for phone apps. 

 

 

Posted
2 hours ago, zen said:


But users need flexibility too. For example, I have North American #, Indian #, and so on, where the sim or eSIM can be activated based on the region I am in while using the other number for phone apps.

 

 

Yes, you can continue that provided your sim remains active ( valid plan or allowed to connect to the network for data/call)

Posted
Quote

 

More bad news for mobile phone users in India (after SIM binding): Our government is mandating a government app (sanchar saathi) on every new phone, permanently,  Will be pushed to your phone via OTA. New smartphones need to have it. Users cannot delete it. This is a first. India has never before required an unremovable state app on every device. Russia does btw, with its MAX Messenger (started September 2025).

 

 

This is taking surveillance to unprecedented levels...  Hope someone files a PIL and stops this 

 

Posted
19 hours ago, gattaca said:

In India you need this. They are no 1 frauds and scams. 

This

 

The govt is simply reacting to rein in the dis-honest and scam artists. Remember, there is a good supply of them in this country.

 

We complain of babu over-reach and red tape. But to reign in this civic-senseless and selfish aam aaadmi's we need a fascist babu. They deserve each other.

 

 

 

 

Posted (edited)

Anyone in US or West think their phones can not be hacked into or providers wont provide the data if asked for is living in LaLa land. What GoI has problem is that everytime say it makes a request to meta for whatsapp data, someone in US/UK/EU may come to know and alert Asim Munir to remove the trail

 

Government needs to enforce a solution so that foreign encrypted apps can not be used without pottential to survellience and/or Applying for permissions from Uncle Sam

 

 

Edited by mishra
Posted
2 hours ago, mishra said:

Anyone in US or West think their phones can not be hacked into or providers wont provide the data if asked for is living in LaLa land. What GoI has problem is that everytime say it makes a request to meta for whatsapp data, someone in US/UK/EU may come to know and alert Asim Munir to remove the trail

 

Government needs to enforce a solution so that foreign encrypted apps can not be used without pottential to survellience and/or Applying for permissions from Uncle Sam

 

 


This also should restrict the tool kit that is deployed during the farmers protest. 

Posted
1 hour ago, gattaca said:


This also should restrict the tool kit that is deployed during the farmers protest. 

Its not about restricting. GoI is still a decade away when it comes proactive action. Currently its more about investigation. May be lesson learned from Pahalgham and Lal Quila investigations.

Posted

Data privacy is a myth everywhere. You discuss something even offline and will start seeing ads everywhere. 

 

If these measures can prevent frauds then why not?

Posted
13 hours ago, vvvslaxman said:

Telegram is notorious for some bad activities especially epstein kind of activities. I have seen Catch a predator on youtube. Most of the criminals that get caught are on telegram.

There is no bad app. Telegram is bad because its not in Western Government Control, So chats are not trackeable. For Russians/Chinese, Getting data from Whatsapp or Signal or any other app is equally difficult. 

×
×
  • Create New...