IF it is just abt No. 6 , How is Jadhav better then Raina?

[Ankit_sharma03]

7 minutes ago, express bowling said:

The question is whether Jadhav is good enough till 2019 WC   ?

The question is has he done so bad that he shud be dropped- No

 

As much as i dnt see jadhav fitting 2019 plans , he has done well in given chances and it wnt be right to drop him 

[express bowling]

1 hour ago, jusarrived said:

Nothing against Jadhav , but hes choked everytime under pressure . The one knock where he played brilliantly with Virat, did everything right till the point he played a stupid shot and got out and India lost eventually . Hes a good player when we bat first and does most things Raina would do for us , but its when chasing Raina is special . 

 

Jadhav should not bat at No.4 or No.5, he is not good there  .... he is ideal at No.6

 

Everyone but Pandya failed in the CT final.... apart from that, he is good while chasing

 

Jadhav's  innings while chasing batting at No.6

 

 

Career averages

	Mat	Runs	HS	Bat Av	100	Wkts	BBI	Bowl Av	5	Ct	St	Ave Diff
unfiltered	29	566	120	47.16	2	14	3/29	22.21	0	15	0	24.95	Profile
filtered	10	280	120	56.00	1	-	-	-	-	-	-	-

Match by match list

Bat1	Wkts	Conc	Ct	St		Opposition	Ground	Start Date
-	-	-	0	0		v Zimbabwe	Harare	11 Jun 2016	ODI # 3742
-	-	-	2	0		v Zimbabwe	Harare	13 Jun 2016	ODI # 3744
-	-	-	0	0		v Zimbabwe	Harare	15 Jun 2016	ODI # 3746
10*	2	6	1	0		v New Zealand	Dharamsala	16 Oct 2016	ODI # 3796
41	1	11	0	0		v New Zealand	Delhi	20 Oct 2016	ODI # 3797
DNB	3	29	1	0		v New Zealand	Mohali	23 Oct 2016	ODI # 3798
-	0	27	0	0		v New Zealand	Ranchi	26 Oct 2016	ODI # 3799
120	0	23	0	0		v England	Pune	15 Jan 2017	ODI # 3819
90	-	-	0	0		v England	Kolkata	22 Jan 2017	ODI # 3824
-	-	-	0	0		v South Africa	The Oval	11 Jun 2017	ODI # 3886
DNB	2	22	0	0		v Bangladesh	Birmingham	15 Jun 2017	ODI # 3891
9	1	27	1	0		v Pakistan	The Oval	18 Jun 2017	ODI # 3894
10	-	-	1	0		v West Indies	North Sound	2 Jul 2017	ODI # 3900
DNB	1	13	1	0		v West Indies	Kingston	6 Jul 2017	ODI # 3902
DNB	2	26	1	0		v Sri Lanka	Dambulla	20 Aug 2017	ODI # 3905

 

http://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/player/290716.html?batting_fielding_first=2;batting_positionmax1=6;batting_positionmin1=6;batting_positionval1=batting_position;class=2;filter=advanced;orderby=start;spanmin1=16+Nov+2015;spanval1=span;template=results;type=allround;view=match

 

 

Edited September 3, 2017 by express bowling

[express bowling]

Today again , Jadhav is batting at No.5 and it is not the ideal slot for him.

Edited September 3, 2017 by express bowling

[Forever Indian]

13 minutes ago, express bowling said:

Today again , Jadhav is batting at No.5 and it is not the ideal slot for him.

No, he is good for no.5 and 6, not higher than that. He needs to come in when 20 overs or so are left.

[vvvslaxman]

His shot selection can be bizzarre at time. When it comes off it is good. But it carries some risk.  There is something unconventional about his approach. 

[Forever Indian]

3 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

His shot selection can be bizzarre at time. When it comes off it is good. But it carries some risk.  There is something unconventional about his approach. 

He plays some bizarre shots, because he tries to play where there are gaps. For eg. if a bowler bowls wide on offside with an offside heavy field he still hits it unconventionally into the gap on legside.

 

There is no way his gameplay is risky if he has been able to maintain an average of 50 with 108 SR in List A over a number of years. The only player to be able to do so.

[tweaker]

Due to fitness issues Raina has skipped most of the domestic season last year.

He should play this full Ranji season to assess his fitness & form

[PSB_Zone]

Jadhav proving me Wrong today..After initial struggle he is playing beautifully ..Anyways not against him..All good for indian cricket but raina has lot more cricket left.

[G_B_]

its the post marriage Raina who to be fair is nothing like the Raina of 5 years ago

 

has thrown in the towel on international cricket basically.

[tweaker]

1 minute ago, PSB_Zone said:

Jadhav proving me Wrong today..After initial struggle he is playing beautifully ..Anyways not against him..All good for indian cricket but raina has lot more cricket left.

Raina can get in the squad in the place of Rahane.

Rahane may be rested

[Ankit_sharma03]

4 minutes ago, PSB_Zone said:

Jadhav proving me Wrong today..After initial struggle he is playing beautifully ..Anyways not against him..All good for indian cricket but raina has lot more cricket left.

Then Let Raina earn his place back by perfomance 

[NareshK]

To be honest, Raina has his short comings against spin, swing and bounce. His main strengths are hitting ability, playing well under pressure(finishing job), running between wickets and fielding. But he has some flaws in technique. Nothing wrong with looking for alternatives who could bat better than him in different conditions and against different attacks.

 

Also, Raina went through a bad patch of form and had put on weight and stopped working on his fitness( he had failed a fitness test which even Ashwin and Kedhar had passed  ), so it was natural that he was dropped. If he works hard on his fitness and does well in FC, he could have a shot at coming back.

[beetle]

Raina keeps posting pics of him gyming and about fitness and then  he goes and fails the yo yo test.

 

That makes one wonder about his seriousness about getting match fit for international level.

[King Tendulkar]

How fat is raina these days ? Would he pass new fitness tests lol

 

 

[Ankit_sharma03]

2 hours ago, beetle said:

Raina keeps posting pics of him gyming and about fitness and then  he goes and fails the yo yo test.

 

That makes one wonder about his seriousness about getting match fit for international level.

Raina is acting like Umar akmal these days 

 

About his seriousness - his own coach questioned it so that shud be taken seriously 

[Kerberos]

This is how.

[Khota]

In my opinion Raina and Jadhav are both good. 

[wanted_desi]

Raina is one of my favourite player in ODI. Coming at #6, he can score from ball 1. His inning against Pakistan is one of the best 40 odds runs made.

[Gollum]

How can any team accommodate such a poor fielder cum catcher? Never seen anything like this for many years now, he is worse than the worst Pak fielders. 

[PSB_Zone]

Chalo Even if jadhav is better ,raina still deserves to be in squad of 15.
What the likes of rahane has to offer in Odi/T-20 cricket anyway..
Already hv 3 openers in rahul/rohit/dhawan and even Manish can open.

If we lack finishers why we select 4th opener in the squad?

Edited September 4, 2017 by PSB_Zone