Shikar Dhawan bigger liability than MSD in T20

[Pollack]

1 minute ago, King Tendulkar said:

The mob is fickle . Iyer was pimped relentlessley here but suddenly I notice quite a few having a pop at him and sayjng he creates weak middle order !!

 

the cycle goes on like this . Hype a player . Gets in after one or few games knives out and they must go. Despite all the words on icf of get kids in and let them develop !! Siraj also being slaughtered

 

last game was his debut knock . This game 8 over slog fest in sticky pitch . How on earth we can judge him on these games is beyond me 

Mob is not the problem. Your comprehension of mob is. Those who backed Iyer are still backing him. They haven't changed their opinion. As far as my personal opinion is concerned I assure you even I am consistent in my views. I, for one, never ever hyped Iyer. So again my friend what are you complaining about? Everyone is consistent in their views.

[PSB_Zone]

59 minutes ago, bowl_out said:

I would get new openers - Pant and Rahul... and play Rohit at 4 like he does for MI..

 

We'll have dashing openers and more middle order stability..

 

 

Thats exactly my words used many times in the forum :0

[jalebi_bhai]

1 hour ago, G_B_ said:

cant remember the last time this guy gave us a good start in the shortest format.

 

Sucks out the momentum.

He is a member of Kohli's chaddi buddy selfie group. 

 

 

Ashwin's presence is just a red herring. 

[King Tendulkar]

7 minutes ago, Pollack said:

Mob is not the problem. Your comprehension of mob is. Those who backed Iyer are still backing him. They haven't changed their opinion. As far as my personal opinion is concerned I assure you even I am consistent in my views. I, for one, never ever hyped Iyer. So again my friend what are you complaining about? Everyone is consistent in their views.

Ok on iyer . How on earth can you write him off after 1.3 games ( this was not even a proper game ) . Has done great stuff in fc and a tours . 

 

Lets see him play sl odi s . Perfect way to ease a young gun in . 

[Pollack]

1 minute ago, King Tendulkar said:

Ok on iyer . How on earth can you write him off after 1.3 games ( this was not even a proper game ) . Has done great stuff in fc and a tours . 

 

Lets see him play sl odi s . Perfect way to ease a young gun in . 

I am not writing him off. I am just not hyping him. There is a difference between the two. He may or may not succeed. Based on my personal observation of batsmen over years , my opinion is he won't. Let's wait and watch. He deserves chances due to his FC performances plus it's not like he is completely talentless.

[King Tendulkar]

12 minutes ago, Pollack said:

I am not writing him off. I am just not hyping him. There is a difference between the two. He may or may not succeed. Based on my personal observation of batsmen over years , my opinion is he won't. Let's wait and watch. He deserves chances due to his FC performances plus it's not like he is completely talentless.

Fair enough . Agree actually 

[Vijy]

11 hours ago, bowl_out said:

I would get new openers - Pant and Rahul... and play Rohit at 4 like he does for MI..

 

We'll have dashing openers and more middle order stability..

 

 

pant did not look like a dashing opener to me in his T20

[rkt.india]

14 minutes ago, Vijy said:

pant did not look like a dashing opener to me in his T20

he played 2 t20s and he did not open in any of them. He was one of the the Highest SR Indian batsman in IPL.

[SK_IH]

21 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

he played 2 t20s and he did not open in any of them. He was one of the the Highest SR Indian batsman in IPL.

deleted

wrong interpretation

Edited November 8, 2017 by SK_IH

[Vijy]

5 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

he played 2 t20s and he did not open in any of them. He was one of the the Highest SR Indian batsman in IPL.

I know he didn't open. But in one of those innings, he certainly had enough balls to build an innings didn't he?

[SK_IH]

15 minutes ago, Vijy said:

I know he didn't open. But in one of those innings, he certainly had enough balls to build an innings didn't he?

player with best strike rate and most sixes in ipl ,what more you need 

[PSB_Zone]

I just wonder how our established T-20 X1 WILL PERform against the challenger X1 which is comprising of those who are not able to get in the original X1

 

Rohit/Dhawan/Kohli/Iyer/Dhoni/Pandya/Bhuvi/Kuldeep/Bumrah/Chahal/Siraj

 

Aaginst

 

Pant/Rahul/Raina/Manish/Jadav/Krunal/Shankar/Jadega/Ashwin/Shami/Thampi

[chewy]

20 minutes ago, PSB_Zone said:

I just wonder how our established T-20 X1 WILL PERform against the challenger X1 which is comprising of those who are not able to get in the original X1

 

Rohit/Dhawan/Kohli/Iyer/Dhoni/Pandya/Bhuvi/Kuldeep/Bumrah/Chahal/Siraj

 

Aaginst

 

Pant/Rahul/Raina/Manish/Jadav/Krunal/Shankar/Jadega/Ashwin/Shami/Thampi

Challenger XI would edge a series win 2-1

[chewy]

You can probably add Robin, Tripathi, Manan Vohra, Samaon...hell even Papu outperforms Dhawan in IPL lol

 

it tells you something when likes Amla and Shaun Marsh have a much Supererior strike rate than Rohit and Dhawan

[Pollack]

2 hours ago, PSB_Zone said:

I just wonder how our established T-20 X1 WILL PERform against the challenger X1 which is comprising of those who are not able to get in the original X1

 

Rohit/Dhawan/Kohli/Iyer/Dhoni/Pandya/Bhuvi/Kuldeep/Bumrah/Chahal/Siraj

 

Aaginst

 

Pant/Rahul/Raina/Manish/Jadav/Krunal/Shankar/Jadega/Ashwin/Shami/Thampi

Original eleven would win . Challenger x11 has garbage bowling for a t20. Our top 3 would make merry against them.

[Vijy]

11 hours ago, PSB_Zone said:

I just wonder how our established T-20 X1 WILL PERform against the challenger X1 which is comprising of those who are not able to get in the original X1

 

Rohit/Dhawan/Kohli/Iyer/Dhoni/Pandya/Bhuvi/Kuldeep/Bumrah/Chahal/Siraj

 

Aaginst

 

Pant/Rahul/Raina/Manish/Jadav/Krunal/Shankar/Jadega/Ashwin/Shami/Thampi

It would be a close match but the bowling of the original XI is better. Ash and Jaddu would get a royal thumping from Kohli and Pandya.

[King Tendulkar]

13 hours ago, PSB_Zone said:

I just wonder how our established T-20 X1 WILL PERform against the challenger X1 which is comprising of those who are not able to get in the original X1

 

Rohit/Dhawan/Kohli/Iyer/Dhoni/Pandya/Bhuvi/Kuldeep/Bumrah/Chahal/Siraj

 

Aaginst

 

Pant/Rahul/Raina/Manish/Jadav/Krunal/Shankar/Jadega/Ashwin/Shami/Thampi

Established t20 11 would win easily 

[SecondSlip]

13 hours ago, PSB_Zone said:

I just wonder how our established T-20 X1 WILL PERform against the challenger X1 which is comprising of those who are not able to get in the original X1

 

Rohit/Dhawan/Kohli/Iyer/Dhoni/Pandya/Bhuvi/Kuldeep/Bumrah/Chahal/Siraj

 

Aaginst

 

Pant/Rahul/Raina/Manish/Jadav/Krunal/Shankar/Jadega/Ashwin/Shami/Thampi

Challenger XI has a poor bowling attack.

 

Easy whitewash for Team India  

 

 

 

 

[SUMO]

dhawan hasn't been that bad to be thrown out... benchmark for him is much lower because he is in kohli's good books.

We can only hope for him to fail so poorly that virat can't hide his face...

same is the case with dhoni...wish they lose india 3-4 games on trot

Edited November 8, 2017 by SUMO

[Vijy]

55 minutes ago, SUMO said:

dhawan hasn't been that bad to be thrown out... benchmark for him is much lower because he is in kohli's good books.

We can only hope for him to fail so poorly that virat can't hide his face...

same is the case with dhoni...wish they lose india 3-4 games on trot

Loosing games on the trot is the real issue here - won't happen. Instead what will happen is that they lose us a few games and we win a few, and people focus on the latter and ignore the former. Look at Dhoni's tuk-tuk in WI... already forgotten.