Kohli vs Root vs Smith vs Williamson - Performance tab for WC 19'

[maniac]

1 minute ago, chewy said:

Pretty clear after 4 ICC events since WC 2011, Kohli is a bottler

 

Williamson bossing this WC, playing according to situation and guiding his team to key victories with bat, sometimes ball and most importantly brain.

 

Kohli is a great batsmen, but in a World Cup, give me Williamson or Smith anyday over him. 

Three WCs now and not really racked up those big runs the other three are making.

 

Making him captain of ODI side was a big mistake.

 

Next IPL, this guy will be playing second fiddle to likes of Rohit Sharma, Williamson, Warner, Smith, Pant, Iyer.  

He already is as a captain. Losing is acceptable but even in RCB Nehra was running like a headless chicken and shouting instructions in the final over where he was just standing clueless. Now his cluelessness is not acceptable 

 

 

Edited July 10, 2019 by maniac

[Ajju]

Bump

 

as of now Williamson tops the list

[Nikola]

On 6/8/2019 at 12:52 AM, Nikola said:

Williamson is overrated. Most of his innings are against minnows or in home conditions. Taylor is better than him as overall odi batsman. Other than one or two innings i don't know what he has done enough to get mentioned with other 3.

Even though his innings have been slow but that has helped nz win matches so till now he has proven me wrong and i am happy for him as well.

[Ajju]

On 27 May 2019 at 10:44 AM, Ajju said:

My Bet on SMITH- Not in terms of runs but influence and quality of innings matter.

 

ROOT out of equation due to England pitches

 

now look into SMITH vs Kohli vs WIlliamson

Surpassed when it matters. Predicted long back

[Stan AF]

So how much is the final tally for Smith and Kohli???

 

Root and Williamson still have one more game!!

 

It's fair enough to say Williamson had more impact on his team performances than the remaining three in comparison?

Along with his batting his captaincy also has made a difference??

[Nikola]

4 minutes ago, Stan AF said:

So how much is the final tally for Smith and Kohli???

 

Root and Williamson still have one more game!!

 

It's fair enough to say Williamson had more impact on his team performances than the remaining three in comparison?

Along with his batting his captaincy also has made a difference??

True williamson played with weaker batting lineup and had more responsibility on him to perform in every single match. Root had many other batsman around himself. 

[Stan AF]

Kohli scores

 

18 , 82 , 77 , 67 , 72, 66, 26, 34*, 1      -  443 with 1 not out in 9 games

 

Smith

18 , 73 , 69 , 10 , 73 , 1 , 38 , 5 , 7 , 85  -       379 in 10 games.

 

Please Correct if i'm wrong

 

[SK_IH]

I will update the table post the finals but  Williamson is leading the battle comprehensively. Root has scored similar amount of runs but he has a better batting attack to fall back upon. Lets see who plays major role between the two in the finals and wins this battle of numero uno.

 

Virat has been the most disappointing, he never looked like the number one batsman in the world. 

Edited July 12, 2019 by SK_IH

[Nonbeliever]

One century In bilateral series and everybody will start .

 

[-Robin-]

Williamson miles ahead than all 3

[rageaddict]

Can't wait for the next series against WI and SL where Virat Kohli will silence all his critics and haters. 

[Ajju]

Yes Virat kohli shows who is the actual boss in office with Coming SL series

[Vijy]

On 7/12/2019 at 3:47 AM, -Robin- said:

Williamson miles ahead than all 3

he is technically the most purest of the big 4 and a big favourite of mine, but I feel that he is not "miles ahead". Smith is slightly better than him in Tests, Root arguably in ODIs (because of that extra gears he has), and Rat in T20s (incl. even the T20 WCs).

[Nikola]

Root didn't look much clutch to me in finals. Stokes ahead of everyone listed from fab four. Kane failed as well.

[Sgattick10]

All except Kane flopped. 

[diga]

First to 10k club .. Smith 

[Gollum]

48 minutes ago, diga said:

First to 10k club .. Smith 

Fastest you mean? Root has 12.5k IIRC.

[diga]

2 minutes ago, Gollum said:

Fastest you mean? Root has 12.5k IIRC.

oops .. 

[Gollum]

Wonderful to see Smith getting these 100s again. Get that average above 60 again 

 

I am sure @Laaloo shares my joy. 

[LordPrabhzy]

Williamson is like 700/800 runs away from the 10K runs will be the first NZ batter to achieve this.

 

Kohli even though has only 80 runs less than Kane mama, doesnt have the hunger or technique to ever get to that 10K mark at the rate he is going and his shi*ty average