Who should replace Bumrah ?

[Ankit_sharma03]

 

1. Umesh- i think has played most in Aus
2. shami 
3. thakur
4. chahar
5. Siraj- dont think he has played white ball cricket 

 

[coffee_rules]

9 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

 

1. Umesh- i think has played most in Aus
2. shami 
3. thakur
4. chahar
5. Siraj- dont think he has played white ball cricket 

 

Ishant

[vvvslaxman]

24 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

 

1. Umesh- i think has played most in Aus
2. shami 
3. thakur
4. chahar
5. Siraj- dont think he has played white ball cricket 

 

 

Siraj is better bet. He can hit high spees when he wants. Also bowls that test match length that can be handy in late overs if he gets it right. And also he can bowl bouncer better.

[Ankit_sharma03]

9 hours ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

Siraj is better bet. He can hit high spees when he wants. Also bowls that test match length that can be handy in late overs if he gets it right. And also he can bowl bouncer better.

yes , my choice is also siraj coz his hard lengths are better then others and he does have all other skills

[nitinbwj]

A, B, C, D  .. Doesn't matter. Sabki pitai pakki. 

[vvvslaxman]

1 minute ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

yes , my choice is also siraj coz his hard lengths are better then others and he does have all other skills

 

india has to take a chance. No option. Not the perfect choice. But he has the ability to break the game with one seriously good over even when he is not doing well. Steady eddies are much riskier compared to these erratic bowlers like Siraj who can go both ways.

[Ankit_sharma03]

9 hours ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

india has to take a chance. No option. Not the perfect choice. But he has the ability to break the game with one seriously good over even when he is not doing well. Steady eddies are much riskier compared to these erratic bowlers like Siraj who can go both ways.

yup every option is a gamble now 

[IndianRenegade]

Total eff up, Bumrah & Harshal are supposed to come back & fix our bowling.

 

one is injured &  other has terrible form since return.

 

now we will figure out Bumrah replacement once we reach Australia. Next to WI we must be the worst at managing personal.
 

 

[adi B]

Out of the options I'd definitely pick siraj .

We already have Bhuvi and Arshdeep ,Don't need another similar one dimensional bowler in Chahar .

Tbh ,This current set up is bound to fail ,The bowling line up is non existent with hardly any t20 specialist in it. The coaches are clueless and don't have an iota of how this format should be approached. 

A couple of final tweaks to the bowling line up won't change anything especially when the gameplan is so defensive 

[putrevus]

While everyone is focussed on lack of fast bowlers right so  but we don't have spinners either. 

 

Hasranga , Shadab, Zampa, Rashid , even Maharaj all have outbowled Indian spinners.Axar tooks a pounding in this series, his bowling speeds and lengths are perfect for  LHB to tee off.

[adi B]

2 minutes ago, putrevus said:

While everyone is focussed on lack of fast bowlers right so  but we don't have spinners either. 

 

Hasranga , Shadab, Zampa, Rashid , even Maharaj all have outbowled Indian spinners.Axar tooks a pounding in this series, his bowling speeds and lengths are perfect for  LHB to tee off.

True ,some fools here think that the spinners will suddenly perform miracles and that too on Australian pitches.

They are getting smashed here in India when there's still some purchase off the wkt ,in Australia it'll be 0!

We don't have any t20 specialist in the line up and the spinners in the squad are bang average ,they'll get lined up by good teams ,make no mistake .

 

[vvvslaxman]

18 minutes ago, adi B said:

Out of the options I'd definitely pick siraj .

We already have Bhuvi and Arshdeep ,Don't need another similar one dimensional bowler in Chahar .

Tbh ,This current set up is bound to fail ,The bowling line up is non existent with hardly any t20 specialist in it. The coaches are clueless and don't have an iota of how this format should be approached. 

A couple of final tweaks to the bowling line up won't change anything especially when the gameplan is so defensive 

 

You just need 4 bankable overs. We will be in much better shape.

[adi B]

1 minute ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

You just need 4 bankable overs. We will be in much better shape.

No one is bankable in this squad tbh

[vvvslaxman]

16 minutes ago, putrevus said:

While everyone is focussed on lack of fast bowlers right so  but we don't have spinners either. 

 

Hasranga , Shadab, Zampa, Rashid , even Maharaj all have outbowled Indian spinners.Axar tooks a pounding in this series, his bowling speeds and lengths are perfect for  LHB to tee off.

 

Hasaranga travelled in Australia. Going at 10 an over.  These fast skiddish bowlers may not have the same success in Australia. You have to generate bounce. Kuldeep did. Bowled well 4 years back. Most recently Sundar is an exception. Lot of spinners travelled there. Theekshana was very good. But you can't call him strictly a spinner. He can also swing the ball while spinning. 

[IndianRenegade]

28 minutes ago, putrevus said:

While everyone is focussed on lack of fast bowlers right so  but we don't have spinners either. 

 

Hasranga , Shadab, Zampa, Rashid , even Maharaj all have outbowled Indian spinners.Axar tooks a pounding in this series, his bowling speeds and lengths are perfect for  LHB to tee off.

apart from batting we have nothing else going for us, pathetic fielding & bowling. 1st round exit loading.

[The Realist]

1 hour ago, adi B said:

Out of the options I'd definitely pick siraj .

We already have Bhuvi and Arshdeep ,Don't need another similar one dimensional bowler in Chahar .

Tbh ,This current set up is bound to fail ,The bowling line up is non existent with hardly any t20 specialist in it. The coaches are clueless and don't have an iota of how this format should be approached. 

A couple of final tweaks to the bowling line up won't change anything especially when the gameplan is so defensive 

 

 

This is a lesson in HOW NOT TO PREPARE for international tournament. 

[vvvslaxman]

42 minutes ago, IndianRenegade said:

apart from batting we have nothing else going for us, pathetic fielding & bowling. 1st round exit loading.

 

Only scenario where India can completely turn it around is when there is swing on offer. We have like 3 bowlers who can do that. Bhuvi, Chahar, Arshdeep.  At the WACA during December and early Jan fremantle doctors is very strong which aids swing bowling.  During fall as well you get a bit of breeze.  Oct/November. I think it starts in the afternoon. Swing bowlers play a big part during this phase.

[vvvslaxman]

@SRT100  You think there will be swing on offer? How is the weather?

[straighttalk]

The nos 8 to 11 in my opinion should be 

Chahar

Ashwin or Bishnoi

Arshdeep

Umesh or Shami or Siraj

[vvvslaxman]

2 hours ago, adi B said:

No one is bankable in this squad tbh

 

It comes down to match ups. Pandya the bowler will be required more than Pandya  the batsman. He has to extract bounce off the pitch against Paksitan. Entire line up is susceptible against short ball. Knowing fully well, going in with floaty bowlers will be a crime.