Will Kohli end up being considered a worse Test captain than Dhoni?

[sergio04]

dhoni was a **** captain 

dont compare him with virat in test

[Rasgulla]

6 minutes ago, speedheat said:

 

But you said sachin was not performing in first post, ok he was not may be coz he was at last stage of career but but the greatest captain in the history of the universe can't deal with that?? why does he depends so much on superstars?? Why are we 8.7% ??

It's all in your mind.. quote that post maybe ?  He did deal with it pretty well he kicked him out and percentage went up high.. So its a success.

[Texan]

This seems like picking between Satan and Devil. Who is better?

[Straight Drive]

VK will be worse than Dhoni if he continues like this.

[speedheat]

@sscomp32 

Edited January 13, 2018 by speedheat

[Ankit_sharma03]

Lets not make it dhoni vs kohli 

Its what a captain does with avl resources and living in present. 

Now kohli is not even using his best resources.

 

Kohli has a very capable team and he shud be judged to what he does with them not with previous captains 

[bsriharsha]

Idiotic Team Selection. Nowhere near the dhoni standard of ineptitude on the field though. 

I thought he captained the team pretty okay today.

[putrevus]

1 hour ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Lets not make it dhoni vs kohli 

Its what a captain does with avl resources and living in present. 

Now kohli is not even using his best resources.

 

Kohli has a very capable team and he shud be judged to what he does with them not with previous captains 

Dhoni also had a team which was world no1 and had best batting lineup in history, how is Kohli having better resources.

[Gollum]

As much as I hate brat's politics, team selections and mannerisms, under Cool we would have finished the day at 330/3. There is something different about this bunch, hope it translates into results...for too long we have had to endure pyyrhic moral victories. 

[Ankit_sharma03]

6 minutes ago, putrevus said:

Dhoni also had a team which was world no1 and had best batting lineup in history, how is Kohli having better resources.

I never said dhoni didnt have a good team ,

I just said kohli not using his best resources ....i didnt mean he has the best resources avl in history 

Rahane is a better player then rohit ....he is not playing him, same when rahul benches. Thats my point...that he is not even using his best team in 1st place 

Edited January 13, 2018 by Ankit_sharma03

[putrevus]

Kohli is the best test captain in Indian team's history and he would go down as one of the better captain world has seen if he wins in SA, Australia.

 

His batting failed him not his captaincy in first test.

[MechEng]

While Dhoni was an ordinary test captain, we must also consider that he had no other choice other than captaining the test side which was going through a transition phase at that time. It is very well known that Dhoni does not enjoy test cricket, he captained the test side as a part of his job, the day all seniors retired and Kohli matured as a test cricketer he immediately left the captaincy post, this is evident from his mid series retirement in Australia.

Edited January 14, 2018 by MechEng

[Khota]

Too much power in hand of Kohli. He should only captain one format.

[Texan]

Good consistent run for Kohli pick Rohit Sharma here in South Africa. 11, 10, 10.... can't get more consistent than that. Top pick Kohli! Great job dropping our best batsman away from home.

[Forever Indian]

Well done Kohli. Rohit scoring consistently in double figures - 11, 10, 10

[Straight Drive]

2-0 looks unavoidable now. Series seems to be lost by end of this test. More pressure on Kohli.