How long will the Mumbai lobby keep pushing for Shreyas Iyer?

[G_B_]

Simply lacks the technique or flair to work in SENA countries...

 

huge flaw

[tweaker]

Mumbai looby should pursue the case of Sarfaraz Khan ,Prithvi Shaw and Yaishavi Jaiswal

[Majestic]

This management and selectors have no brain.

 

They rate everything based on performance but no understanding of the factors that leading to performance or loss of that.

 

Iyer is not a T20 player. He can smash spin but will struggle vs pace. That will be enough to give him 30 runs of 20 balls but he will always struggle to play a match winning knock on his own in T20s. 

 

Samson must play. Keep S Iyer in ODIs only.

[prudent_kreeda]

8 minutes ago, Majestic said:

This management and selectors have no brain.

 

They rate everything based on performance but no understanding of the factors that leading to performance or loss of that.

 

Iyer is not a T20 player. He can smash spin but will struggle vs pace. That will be enough to give him 30 runs of 20 balls but he will always struggle to play a match winning knock on his own in T20s. 

 

Samson must play. Keep S Iyer in ODIs only.

In 50 overs , opposition with 3 pacers has more balls to smoke him out . Then case of hitting spinners goes out of the window. 

[Majestic]

2 minutes ago, prudent_kreeda said:

In 50 overs , opposition with 3 pacers has more balls to smoke him out . Then case of hitting spinners goes out of the window. 

SA had Rabada and Nortje. Didn't stopped him from getting a hundred. He is happy to leave those short balls in ODIs. T20s is where he sucks. Teams with two spinners will bowl 15-16 overs of spin in middle overs, he cashes in those situations.

 

Rest if you are looking for a perfect batsman then there isn't any in Indian team now. Rahul, Kishan, Samson all have flaws.

Edited November 22, 2022 by Majestic

[Number]

2 minutes ago, prudent_kreeda said:

In 50 overs , opposition with 3 pacers has more balls to smoke him out . Then case of hitting spinners goes out of the window. 

 

Agree. Oppositions are not that naive, they will chalk out a plan and won't feed him spinners. However I think he will still get away with it in Indian conditions.

[Nikola]

I don't want him in both tests & t20s as of now. Considering odi worldcup is in india and his record is pretty good he can be in consideration. Also how about Delhi lobby pushing for pant to play for 100 T20I milestone?

[jalebi_bhai]

Shreyas Iyer boom-bust cycle:

 

Score runs in Asia --> Get picked in the XI --> Get exposed against bounce in SENA --> Get dropped

 

Rinse and repeat.

[G_B_]

He is a home track bully with temperament issues. Simple...

[Nikhil_cric]

Why force him in formats he's clearly not good at . He will play the 50 over WC next year because he's a good ODI bat. 

[vvvslaxman]

4 hours ago, Majestic said:

SA had Rabada and Nortje. Didn't stopped him from getting a hundred. He is happy to leave those short balls in ODIs. T20s is where he sucks. Teams with two spinners will bowl 15-16 overs of spin in middle overs, he cashes in those situations.

 

Rest if you are looking for a perfect batsman then there isn't any in Indian team now. Rahul, Kishan, Samson all have flaws.

 

SPot on. He had a very good run in the one dayer last time. Last time he made 103,52,62 in NZ in the one dayers. Yes he has issues on pitches with extra bounce. If you look at it INdian main line up all failed at Perth.

[cricketfan28]

T20 is probably not our format, iyer will become a 50-50 goat for India.

[vvvslaxman]

4 hours ago, Majestic said:

SA had Rabada and Nortje. Didn't stopped him from getting a hundred. He is happy to leave those short balls in ODIs. T20s is where he sucks. Teams with two spinners will bowl 15-16 overs of spin in middle overs, he cashes in those situations.

 

Rest if you are looking for a perfect batsman then there isn't any in Indian team now. Rahul, Kishan, Samson all have flaws.

 

DK plays short ball well lol But his mental midgetry will trump everything.  For now Samson can replace him in T20. In ODI he is a must. IT is a 50 over game only guy who shows capability of building an innings.

[Chakdephatte]

5 hours ago, jalebi_bhai said:

Shreyas Iyer boom-bust cycle:

 

Score runs in Asia --> Get picked in the XI --> Get exposed against bounce in SENA --> Get dropped

 

Rinse and repeat.

 

That's not an issue. The issue is that New Zealand doesn't even have deadly pace and bounce. 

[Frustrated]

Should never be anywhere near the t20 team unless it's held in India. Fed up with him.  The guy's technique against short ball is so terrible that he got exposed even against **** windies pace bowlers on carribean pitches which had some bounce and carry. 

[khadekhademaaro]

Shreya Iyer to selectors - haan jab tak hai jaan, jaane jahan Mai naachungi

 

Dance to karta hai pitch pe 

 

 

[vvvslaxman]

1 hour ago, Frustrated said:

Should never be anywhere near the t20 team unless it's held in India. Fed up with him.  The guy's technique against short ball is so terrible that he got exposed even against **** windies pace bowlers on carribean pitches which had some bounce and carry. 

 

Even in India he is not suitable for T20I. He is an innings builder. He can't go bang bang from t he get go.

[Malcolm Merlyn]

Mumbai lobby is responsible for the Thakur selection as well.

[vvvslaxman]

24 minutes ago, Malcolm Merlyn said:

Mumbai lobby is responsible for the Thakur selection as well.

 

That was  

[Vijy]

need to get this lobby to push for sarfaraz, jaiswal, and maybe (but a big maybe) mulani.