Is is time to make Chahal & Kuldeep as permanent in limited over formats?

[PSB_Zone]

Well, Success of wrist spinners is quite clear in limited over format
We hv two attacking wrist spinners and yet very different..

It will be grt seeing them both play in Odi's and t-20s for India
It will remove the burden on Ashwin/Jadega. They can play in Tests

[Pollack]

Only one of them should play in ODI (kuldeep)with other(Chahal) being backup in the squad.The other spinner must be Jadeja for now who I really hope is replaced by Krunal in near future.

Edited May 3, 2017 by Pollack

[Vijy]

based on this tour, the answer is a yes.

[SK_IH]

i think time is right to permanently drop ashwin n jaddu from odis and t20s,enough is enough

[SUMO]

chahal and kuldeep will give us 3-4 wickets in 20 overs of those middle overs for sure.
But we will lose on some batting and fielding 

Edited July 6, 2017 by SUMO

[Vijy]

Just now, SUMO said:

chahal and kuldeep will give us 3-4 wickets in 20 overs of those middle overs for sure.
But we will lose on some batting and fielding 

anyone is better than ashwin in terms of fielding. yes, jaddu bats and fields better than kuldeep and chahal. But, his batting is not explosive enough for 7 or 8 (hence, in a sense, it's useless). So, this basically boils down to fielding vs bowling, and I think it's important to have an attack capable of taking wickets. Wrist spinners are a must - Kuldeep, chahal and fatty have all done well for this reason.

[SK_IH]

i think we shouldnt overestimate abilities of both leg spinners but they are going to better than both ashwin n jaddu because they will create chances of wickets at same time going for runs

[Vijy]

1 minute ago, SK_IH said:

i think we shouldnt overestimate abilities of both leg spinners but they are going to better than both ashwin n jaddu because they will create chances of wickets at same time going for runs

jaddu has gone for lots of runs recently.

[SK_IH]

6 minutes ago, Vijy said:

jaddu has gone for lots of runs recently.

jaddu is playing as a specialist fielder these days 

[Vijy]

Just now, SK_IH said:

jaddu is playing as a specialist fielder these days 

that he is.

[vishalvirsingh]

Seeing hardik I feel krunal should be given a fair chance to replace jaddu as jaddu does not bat well and is a defensive spinner which krunal is also. 

On batting krunal is better. 

Jaddu is too good in fielding but a dud as batsman n defensive spin bowler. 

[vishalvirsingh]

Ashwin  should not play odi... 

2 reasons 

His uncle style fielding. 

His uncle style batting not meant for odi. 

[sourab10forever]

No

[express bowling]

I will try Kuldeep and Krunal in place of Ashwin and Jadeja, and see how it goes.

[SK_IH]

1 hour ago, express bowling said:

I will try Kuldeep and Krunal in place of Ashwin and Jadeja, and see how it goes.

its a no brainer

 

[RAZPOR]

On 5/3/2017 at 11:42 AM, Pollack said:

Only one of them should play in ODI (kuldeep)with other(Chahal) being backup in the squad.The other spinner must be Jadeja for now who I really hope is replaced by Krunal in near future.

Getting Krunal in the squad is a must,not just for his bowling but his batting is going to be a match winner in itself.

[Ankit_sharma03]

Try them and let them perform n earn........

Get krunal in also as an all rounder not as spinner 

[Pollack]

2 hours ago, RAZPOR said:

Getting Krunal in the squad is a must,not just for his bowling but his batting is going to be a match winner in itself.

Yes. The post was written few months back. Now don't think Jadeja should be around in ODI's for long.

Plus point of Krunal is he isn't a bad fielder either. Infact as good as Hardin at the moment.

Batting+ Fielding ---> Good to Very Good

Bowling --------->   Don't know but looks okay to start in ODI. Another plus point is krunal appears as a hardworking, down to earth and mentally strong character with very high self belief. So he has basic ingredient to learn and grow once introduced at international level.

[Tibarn]

Yes 

[Mosher]

Yes. Chahal is a wicket taker too. Both can form a potent combo in LOI's.