Who should replace KL Rahul & Hardik Pandya in the ODI squad?

[SecondSlip]

Since both players are on their way home and won’t be in India’s ODI squad for now, who should be their replacements?

These are my choices: 

 

OUT - KL Rahul & Hardik Pandya 

IN - Mayank Agarwal & Vijay Shankar

[nsareen]

Shubman Gill. /. Shivam Dube


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GautiMaan]

Hope:Pant and Gill 

Probable:Manish Pandey and Axar Patel

When will the great ones announce, the replacements should have already been on a flight 

[beetle]

Grey one won't allow Pant to get in.

[bowl_out]

Rayudu chucking his way through.. 

[jf1gp_1]

Manish and Pant

[Vijy]

2 hours ago, SecondSlip said:

Since both players are on their way home and won’t be in India’s ODI squad for now, who should be their replacements?

These are my choices: 

 

OUT - KL Rahul & Hardik Pandya 

IN - Mayank Agarwal & Vijay Shankar

not shankar. anyone but him. maybe krunal. dubey has zero "A" team experience.

[speedheat]

Pant and agrawal

[diehardpacer]

For KL Rahul-Mayank/Gill

For Pandya-Pant.

 

[express bowling]

Shankar   and    Pant

[Tendulkar1996]

Pant and agarwal.

[SK_IH]

Shankar was really impressive vs NZ in A series and Pant surely.

[rkt.india]

12 minutes ago, SK_IH said:

Shankar was really impressive vs NZ in A series and Pant surely.

Mayank who is an opener will replace Rahul who was a backup opener.  Pandya will either be replaced by a seamer alrounder which we dont have, i don't count Shankar as a seam alrounder, as he is a batsman who can bowl part-time, or by a fast bowler as we only have 4 seamers in the squad.  I would like them to develop former U19 Darshan Nalkande as a fast bowling alrounder who is known for his big hitting and can bowl quite quick for a 20 year old.

[rkt.india]

1 minute ago, Kannadiga said:

Agarwal and Gowtham are my choices... Gowtham will be a better spin allrounder than Jadeja, Chahal and even Krunal. 

already have 3 spinners in Aus, you want 4th.  Need a seamer.

[rkt.india]

4 minutes ago, Kannadiga said:

Two out of three spinners are duds. We need an allrounder. 

how? Chahal averages 25 in ODIs, Kuldeep 20.  together, they are as good as any.

[fineleg]

When are the replacements being announced?

Are there even any replacements being announced?

[Jimmypage]

For Rahul - Agarwal or Gill

For Hardik - not a lot of seam all-round options, but can select Shivam Dube, you never know might turn out be an inspiring selection, there is always an opportunity in adversity

 

But to take such decisions you gotta have gumption, which clearly nobody has in the selection process, so expect the likes of Pandey for Rahul and may be Chahar for Pandya

 

[SK_IH]

I want a 3-0 in this series.Phonies were exposed today, another round of bashing would be useful in the long run.

[Samcric]

Pant and Shankar. Shankar was brilliant with the bat in NZ and economical with the ball.

[tweaker]

Pant & Shankar

Edited January 12, 2019 by tweaker