Jump to content

Discussion on Farmers issues in India


dial_100

Recommended Posts

On 11/25/2021 at 12:16 PM, someone said:

 

I haven't watched the video, but Modi clearly made this decision for peace despite the farm laws being very supportive for small and poor farmers.

 

The protests weren't about the farmers welfare, but the emotion of caste, community pride was overwhelming and Modi had to close this issue.

 

It was a win for casteism, and our armed forces has 20% from that region alone, so their emotions had to kept in check.

You guys have been from day one making an economic issue into a religion and caste. You will never get it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So Delhi and the north will continue to choke under the smoke created by these asses. Punjab will continue to run its water table into the ground growing unwanted paddy and wheat.

 

Middlemen continue their zamindari of the Mandis. And farmers ultimately can continue a system that has not worked for them over the past 80 yrs. 

 

Great job! What a victory for all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, bharathh said:

So Delhi and the north will continue to choke under the smoke created by these asses. Punjab will continue to run its water table into the ground growing unwanted paddy and wheat.

 

Middlemen continue their zamindari of the Mandis. And farmers ultimately can continue a system that has not worked for them over the past 80 yrs. 

 

Great job! What a victory for all.

 

If thats what they want thats what they will get- karma comes back around at some point

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, bharathh said:

So Delhi and the north will continue to choke under the smoke created by these asses. Punjab will continue to run its water table into the ground growing unwanted paddy and wheat.

 

Middlemen continue their zamindari of the Mandis. And farmers ultimately can continue a system that has not worked for them over the past 80 yrs. 

 

Great job! What a victory for all.

No system is going to work for Farmers except subsidy. Look at China a country known for Human rights violations but still provide subsidy of 212 billion dollars. The question is why? Why just they don't snatch land from small farmers and give their land to big farmers which mass produce food cheaply . It is because they too are afraid that large number of farmers will bring another in revolution. So they choose subsidy. India's case is also similar.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Singh bling said:

Farmer protest to takleef  Farmer protest called  off to takleef .  Looks like you people  you people cannot accept that your great leader bowed in front of people who you called khalistani , anti national etc . 

Tarakkhi Aur desh gaye tel lene, as long as the great leader is made to bow down to khalistani and anti-National thugs behind  Anna datas in front 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Singh bling said:

No system is going to work for Farmers except subsidy. Look at China a country known for Human rights violations but still provide subsidy of 212 billion dollars. The question is why? Why just they don't snatch land from small farmers and give their land to big farmers which mass produce food cheaply . It is because they too are afraid that large number of farmers will bring another in revolution. So they choose subsidy. India's case is also similar.

So basically farmers should get free money of tax payers otherwise they will bring in revolution. Why they feel so privileged and authoritative, there are several other poor sections who doesn't have even land to do farming but they don't protest for subsidies why farmers act like goon for subsidies, is it their fundamental right or what?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

36 minutes ago, raki05 said:

So basically farmers should get free money of tax payers otherwise they will bring in revolution. Why they feel so privileged and authoritative, there are several other poor sections who doesn't have even land to do farming but they don't protest for subsidies why farmers act like goon for subsidies, is it their fundamental right or what?

Exactly, What stops MSME sector to demand minimum profit from Mai-baap gormint? Pakodi, Samosa, golagappe walon ko bhi dena chahiye revenue security!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, coffee_rules said:

Exactly, What stops MSME sector to demand minimum profit from Mai-baap gormint? Pakodi, Samosa, golagappe walon ko bhi dena chahiye revenue security!

 

Godam pakodo se bhar jayenge. Congresswale bhi berojgar hai woh bhi MSP pe pakode bechenge gormint ko.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, raki05 said:

So basically farmers should get free money of tax payers otherwise they will bring in revolution. Why they feel so privileged and authoritative, there are several other poor sections who doesn't have even land to do farming but they don't protest for subsidies why farmers act like goon for subsidies, is it their fundamental right or what?

Agriculture in India employ around 20 crores . Total subsidy provided by central and state government is 2 lakh 10 thousand crores . This basically means 10000 per head annually . This is not a big amount. Plus it provide essential food security to country. Tell which other sector can do this?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Singh bling said:

Agriculture in India employ around 20 crores . Total subsidy provided by central and state government is 2 lakh 10 thousand crores . This basically means 10000 per head annually . This is not a big amount. Plus it provide essential food security to country. Tell which other sector can do this?

 

BS Annadata argument. First principles of economics are abandoned, you have to resort to this kind of non sense. 

 

Edited by ravishingravi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had an opportunity to speak with a farmer last week in Uttaranchal. He was talking about struggles to sell Sugarcane. He said he can only grow sugar. I asked why. He said that is what this soil allows.

 

Such is the level of Jahalat of small farmers who are held captive by large farmers and middlemen. Lets not forget. These middlemen and their political operative have pulled off the most elaborate stunt, bringing in Rihanna, Meena Harris, Greta Thunberg and countless other stars. 

 

So anytime anyone comes up with annadata non sense you can ask them to ....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Singh bling said:

Agriculture in India employ around 20 crores . Total subsidy provided by central and state government is 2 lakh 10 thousand crores . This basically means 10000 per head annually . This is not a big amount. Plus it provide essential food security to country. Tell which other sector can do this?

You see everything is essential and interlinked. Moreover they get paid for what they do. No sector is better than other, besides there are so many grains which we still import for better quality. Why do only farmers feel subsidies and free handout is their right. If they feel farming is not working out they can try something else. Just like any other business group does. Just because food is essential commodities they can't take nation hostage for free subsidies for an year. tomorrow if doctors go on strike for 2-3 month for some unwanted demand amid corona delta like wave we can't imagine the mahem which it will create.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...