Jump to content

What are the positive accomplishments of this Coaching staff?


maniac

Recommended Posts

Just wondering. These coaches have been around for a while.

 

Bharat Arun might have done some good work with the bowlers but apart from him

 

Can some educated fans here actually give me  examples of what else has been this coaching staff’s accomplishments? In terms of strategy, grooming/mentoring  a youngster, fixing technical issues of existing players etc.

 

I know this will turn into a rant which is fine and understandable but just searching for some Positivity here. What exactly is their legacy? 

Link to comment

 

 

Pissing away a golden opportunity to win the WC by beating England in their own house - by screwing around with our own team, playing silly selfish games with the #4 batting slot.  

 

We had Peak Bumrah, peak Kulcha, Bhuvi, Shami - one of our best bowling attacks - and we lost the ODI WC because of batting.  An Indian team may have many flaws, but ODI batting is one aspect where we have been consistently world class for 30 years.  And this coaching staff screwed the pooch to such an extent that the team couldn't chase 240 in the age where 340 is considered gettable.  

 

That's their legacy. 

 

Selection snafus under Kuptaan Wrogn, unchallenged and unquestioned by 'Smashtri'.   Ruining chances of historica test victories from England to SA.  That's their legacy.

 

Selecting Dhawan ahead of Pujara in a crucial 1st test match of an England series that we lost by 30 runs.  That's the legacy. 

 

 

UNDERACHIEVEMENT.  Chronic and consistent underachievement, especially relative to the available talent, and quality of opposition.  

 

 

Edited by sandeep
Link to comment
1 minute ago, sandeep said:

Pissing away a golden opportunity to win the WC by beating England in their own house - by screwing around with our own team, playing silly selfish games with the #4 batting slot.  

 

We had Peak Bumrah, peak Kulcha, Bhuvi, Shami - one of our best bowling attacks - and we lost the ODI WC because of batting.  An Indian team may have many flaws, but ODI batting is one aspect where we have been consistently world class for 30 years.  And this coaching staff screwed the pooch to such an extent that the team couldn't chase 240 in the age where 340 is considered gettable.  

 

That's their legacy. 

 

Selection snafus under Kuptaan Wrogn, unchallenged and unquestioned by 'Smashtri'.   Ruining chances of historica test victories from England to SA.  That's their legacy.

 

Selecting Dhawan ahead of Pujara in a crucial 1st test match of an England series that we lost by 30 runs.  That's the legacy. 

 

 

 


you covered  the strategy aspect. What about other responsibilities like fixing technique or mentoring youngsters  or even man management that Shastri is apparently famous for. The tension between Rohit and Kohli, no clue on injury management of contracted players, communication issues etc etc.

 

This has been a disaster from the start.

 

 

Link to comment
8 hours ago, R!TTER said:

The only positivity, if you can call it that, is HP & JB. Now they're still relatively young & have a good possible future in all three formats, whether they go on & do what's expected is another story altogether. Rest is just  :damnmate:

Both are MI finds. They will do well no matter who the Indian coach is. When he had injury, Bumrah went with MI team for treatment, not the NCA. Remember the controversy about NCA refusing to certify him as fit because he was fixed up elsewhere? 

Back on topic - Arun the bowling coach has done some good work. The fielding coach seems to not have much impact if any. The players deserve the blame, as they seem too casual and just grin after dropping catches. It's time to appoint a hard taskmaster as fielding coach. Chief coach Shastri is only for cheerleading and we know the results. Did a new batting get appointed after Bangar's ouster or is bevda filling in? 

Link to comment
7 hours ago, Malcolm Merlyn said:

Except Bharat Arun, none of the staff deserve a place. They are rank average.

Sent from my HD1901 using Tapatalk
 

Bharat Arun has been the bowling coach since 2014 replaced Joe Dawe after England tour. What exactly has he achieved? Do we have a pool of young pacers ready to step up? Ishant's resurgence was due to Jason Gillespie, Shami and Bumrah owe not much of their success to Arun. All other pacers/trundlers have come and gone - Aaron, Barinder Sran, Khaleel, Kaul, Unadkat, Mohit Sharma. We are stuck with Shardul Thakur and Deepak Chahar, even they will soon be gone. Saini and Siraj are almost on the verge of being derailed like KulCha.

Link to comment
2 hours ago, nevada said:

Both are MI finds. They will do well no matter who the Indian coach is. When he had injury, Bumrah went with MI team for treatment, not the NCA. Remember the controversy about NCA refusing to certify him as fit because he was fixed up elsewhere? 

Back on topic - Arun the bowling coach has done some good work. The fielding coach seems to not have much impact if any. The players deserve the blame, as they seem too casual and just grin after dropping catches. It's time to appoint a hard taskmaster as fielding coach. Chief coach Shastri is only for cheerleading and we know the results. Did a new batting get appointed after Bangar's ouster or is bevda filling in? 

Rathour.. Vikram Rathour

Link to comment
49 minutes ago, Vk1 said:

Rathour.. Vikram Rathour

Fire that limp wristed focker now! He was a weakling who could barely clear mid on/off during his playing days.

At-least Bangar knew how to make the most out of his meager talent. Played a clutch innings in England as a makeshift opener in swinging conditions and knows a thing or two about how to bat. Rathour is useless.

Link to comment
17 minutes ago, nevada said:

Fire that limp wristed focker now! He was a weakling who could barely clear mid on/off during his playing days.

At-least Bangar knew how to make the most out of his meager talent. Played a clutch innings in England as a makeshift opener in swinging conditions and knows a thing or two about how to bat. Rathour is useless.

Its only politics that counts.. when praveen amre was available they went for rathour

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...