Taking so much from the game just for entertainment': Rohit on Impact Player rule

[Suhaan]

Rohit Sharma echoes ICF concerns

 

https://m.cricbuzz.com/cricket-news/130184/taking-so-much-from-the-game-just-for-entertainment-rohit-on-impact-player-rule

[cowboysfan]

it the fault of BCCI and the idiot Shah boy,basically it has killed all development of all rounders in  LOIs and we desperately need new allrounders.

[cricketfan28]

It will be removed. 

[Lord]

Will be removed now

[maniac]

To be honest, it’s fine. True allrounders will bowl anyway. I mean green, Pandya bros, Jadeja, Curran: decent bowlers will still bowl despite being allrounders.

[Lord]

5 minutes ago, maniac said:

To be honest, it’s fine. True allrounders will bowl anyway. I mean green, Pandya bros, Jadeja, Curran: decent bowlers will still bowl despite being allrounders.

 

They are already developed allrounders.

 

Issue is developing one from batter or bowler.

[Serpico]

10 minutes ago, maniac said:

To be honest, it’s fine. True allrounders will bowl anyway. I mean green, Pandya bros, Jadeja, Curran: decent bowlers will still bowl despite being allrounders.

If Pandya wasn't the captain he would have been bowled lot less in his current form

[Lord]

Impact sub needs to be tweaked, not removed.

 

TBH if not for impact sub, we won't have found guys like Jurel,Ashutosh,Sai Sudarshan etc.

[punjabi_khota]

Rohit was disappointed because when he heard about impact sub, he went to subway and ordered one...only to realize its not what he thought it was.

[Laaloo]

28 minutes ago, punjabi_khota said:

Rohit was disappointed because when he heard about impact sub, he went to subway and ordered one...only to realize its not what he thought it was.

 

https://images.app.goo.gl/9TZbU6ZttSzhTPDt5

 

 

[tapandrun]

In last so many seasons IPL has given just 1 allrounder -Pandaya, IPL is not the place where teams will try to make a player out of some1.

They come, they play and get paid.

 

Impact sub rule is similar to how bcci used it to prolong Sachin's career  using super-sub till they find another high marketable player in Kolhi and Dhoni.

Rt. now after Kolhi and Rohit they have no big names thats why bcci will try to prolong their IPL careers.

 

One of the reason why Kolhi and Rohit got backdoor entry to t20 wc was sponsors and hosts asking for big names, no 1 will pay to watch say a Samson in USA-just look at the price of those tkts. Think bcci sent Kolhi and Rohit on a tour where they sat-out was just to find sponsors.

 

Assuming this is their last stint in intnl t20s, who is next superstar.....?? they placed all their eggs in one basket -Pant and KL.

Till now Pant has not proved himself as a good white-ball player has a SR of 125 2nd worse by In Ind batter in t20is. and then KL is KL...

 

As for allrounders now only proper allrounders will get to play unlike players who are neither batter nor bowler. No place for players who give illusion of an allrounder for balancing the team

 

 

Edited April 18, 2024 by tapandrun

[express bowling]

Impact-sub rule is blocking bits snd pieces players and not true all-rounders.

 

Not bad.

 

Batsmen had stopped bowling long before the impact-sub rule came ... probably to cut down on chance of injury.

 

Only area getting affected is ... the bowlers who could bat a bit are not getting that many chances with the bat. But, then again, those chances were very limited anyway in T20s.

 

Impact-sub rule is giving rookie bowlers and batters chances and that's a plus.

 

 

Edited April 19, 2024 by express bowling

[MediumPacer]

Impact sub  allows the batters to attack the spinners in the middle overs.Otherwise with shorter batting lineups and on slow pitches ,spinners have it too easy and it's an eyesore.

 

 

In int cricket batting lineups are longer and pitches are less helpful  hence our spinners are not as effective.

Edited April 19, 2024 by MediumPacer

[Lord]

17 hours ago, tapandrun said:

In last so many seasons IPL has given just 1 allrounder -Pandaya, IPL is not the place where teams will try to make a player out of some1.

They come, they play and get paid.

 

Impact sub rule is similar to how bcci used it to prolong Sachin's career  using super-sub till they find another high marketable player in Kolhi and Dhoni.

Rt. now after Kolhi and Rohit they have no big names thats why bcci will try to prolong their IPL careers.

 

One of the reason why Kolhi and Rohit got backdoor entry to t20 wc was sponsors and hosts asking for big names, no 1 will pay to watch say a Samson in USA-just look at the price of those tkts. Think bcci sent Kolhi and Rohit on a tour where they sat-out was just to find sponsors.

 

Assuming this is their last stint in intnl t20s, who is next superstar.....?? they placed all their eggs in one basket -Pant and KL.

Till now Pant has not proved himself as a good white-ball player has a SR of 125 2nd worse by In Ind batter in t20is. and then KL is KL...

 

As for allrounders now only proper allrounders will get to play unlike players who are neither batter nor bowler. No place for players who give illusion of an allrounder for balancing the team

 

 

 

Sachin and Dhoni will  still attract biggest crowd, lets get them in WT20 team

[tapandrun]

8 minutes ago, Lord said:

 

Sachin and Dhoni will  still attract biggest crowd, lets get them in WT20 team

Dhoni just need to tell he is thinking of calling off his retirement, there will be ppl, commentators, ex players, experts who would be rallying around and asking for him to be included in T20 WC team as they are doing for Pant who bats at 125 SR at #4 and 60 matches is a v,good sample size.

[vvvslaxman]

7 hours ago, tapandrun said:

Dhoni just need to tell he is thinking of calling off his retirement, there will be ppl, commentators, ex players, experts who would be rallying around and asking for him to be included in T20 WC team as they are doing for Pant who bats at 125 SR at #4 and 60 matches is a v,good sample size.

 

Dhoni can barely run for more than 2 overs. He is pulling through for one season after a surgery.  This probably is going to be his last IPL.

[Vijy]

10 hours ago, tapandrun said:

Dhoni just need to tell he is thinking of calling off his retirement, there will be ppl, commentators, ex players, experts who would be rallying around and asking for him to be included in T20 WC team as they are doing for Pant who bats at 125 SR at #4 and 60 matches is a v,good sample size.

tony would saunter into the team

[Vijy]

3 hours ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

Dhoni can barely run for more than 2 overs. He is pulling through for one season after a surgery.  This probably is going to be his last IPL.

he'll say that 10 years from now.

[vvvslaxman]

16 minutes ago, Vijy said:

he'll say that 10 years from now.

 

Based on captaincy hand over i think this probably will be his last one.

[Vijy]

10 hours ago, vvvslaxman said:

 

Based on captaincy hand over i think this probably will be his last one.

and then he will take it back next season, hand it over the season after, and so on.