Jump to content

Can dinesh karthik replace Yuvi for the first match.

Pollack

By Pollack
in Cricket Talk

Recommended Posts

jusarrived Community Regular

jusarrived

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, maniac said:

People talking about dropping our 2nd best odi bat???had he performed in the warmup it would be look he is bashing in useless games etc.

 

Rohit is truly an xfactor....if Rohit fails and every one fails india will lose-obvious 

 

if Rohit fail and the rest perform- India will get a good score and still might win

 

if Rohit performs doesn't matter if the rest fail or perform-India will win hands down hence rightfully called the X factor.

 

on one hand we cry about players not having the. X factor and when we have one you want to drop him? Ridiculous 

Rohit is just incapable of doing well where every one else has failed . it kind of exposes that he scores when every one else does , which is basically easy runs . 

Austin 3:!6 Grand Master

Austin 3:!6

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, maniac said:

People talking about dropping our 2nd best odi bat???had he performed in the warmup it would be look he is bashing in useless games etc.

 

Rohit is truly an xfactor....if Rohit fails and every one fails india will lose-obvious 

 

if Rohit fail and the rest perform- India will get a good score and still might win

 

if Rohit performs doesn't matter if the rest fail or perform-India will win hands down hence rightfully called the X factor.

 

on one hand we cry about players not having the. X factor and when we have one you want to drop him? Ridiculous 

Brother its no IPL. Rohit will face his biggest nightmare Amir next game. For heavens sake...hope he comes good this time :pray:

 

Ultimate_Game Grand Master

Ultimate_Game

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, maniac said:

People talking about dropping our 2nd best odi bat???had he performed in the warmup it would be look he is bashing in useless games etc.

 

Rohit is truly an xfactor....if Rohit fails and every one fails india will lose-obvious 

 

if Rohit fail and the rest perform- India will get a good score and still might win

 

if Rohit performs doesn't matter if the rest fail or perform-India will win hands down hence rightfully called the X factor.

 

on one hand we cry about players not having the. X factor and when we have one you want to drop him? Ridiculous 

If Rohit is an X factor, then every Indian batsman is an X factor :giggle: 

Laaloo Grand Master

Laaloo

Posted
Posted
6 hours ago, wanted_desi said:

Thank god Yuvi wasn't well for these Warm Up Games. You can't take players out of form into the tournament just because they have done well 6 years ago. That guy and Rahane can lose games on their own. 

Yuvi has done just as well as Dhoni has done in recent times. Not sure where this out of form only applies to Yuvi....

maniac Grand Master

maniac

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, jusarrived said:

Rohit is just incapable of doing well where every one else has failed . it kind of exposes that he scores when every one else does , which is basically easy runs . 

Wc Qf 2015??? 1st ODI vs South Africa last year??? Many such more instances...anyway I see he is not in the best of form coming back from injury but dropping a batsman who is your 2nd best odi bat and a feared match winner? That is not a smart move

maniac Grand Master

maniac

Posted
Posted
46 minutes ago, Austin 3:!6 said:

Brother its no IPL. Rohit will face his biggest nightmare Amir next game. For heavens sake...hope he comes good this time :pray:

 

Amir got the better of him in Asia cup in a match where Hardik Pandya and Mowgli Sami in his 1000th comeback looked threatening with the ball too ....those were some ridiculous conditions.

 

in Wt20 Rohit got out trying to treat Amir with total disdain by trying to slog him.

 

wait and watch this time

Cricketics Rising Star

Cricketics

Posted
Posted

Rohit has to play against Pak.

 

We don't want to make crazy funny changes for Pak game and give them any momentum. indoPak game is more mental than any other game India plays.

 

 

Anyway, its silly to drop one of your openers. This is short tournament so even if they fail in more than one game, I will stick to our openers till the end of the tournament.

 

Changing openers unsettles the line up. We don't want to do this drama a shoet competitive tournament. This is not a 5 game bilateral series. 

Vilander Veteran

Vilander

Posted
Posted
5 hours ago, maniac said:

People talking about dropping our 2nd best odi bat???had he performed in the warmup it would be look he is bashing in useless games etc.

 

Rohit is truly an xfactor....if Rohit fails and every one fails india will lose-obvious 

 

if Rohit fail and the rest perform- India will get a good score and still might win

 

if Rohit performs doesn't matter if the rest fail or perform-India will win hands down hence rightfully called the X factor.

 

on one hand we cry about players not having the. X factor and when we have one you want to drop him? Ridiculous 

its ODI rohit is a good player in ODI. 

Khota Veteran

Khota

Posted
Posted
54 minutes ago, Cricketics said:

Rohit has to play against Pak.

 

We don't want to make crazy funny changes for Pak game and give them any momentum. indoPak game is more mental than any other game India plays.

 

 

Anyway, its silly to drop one of your openers. This is short tournament so even if they fail in more than one game, I will stick to our openers till the end of the tournament.

 

Changing openers unsettles the line up. We don't want to do this drama a shoet competitive tournament. This is not a 5 game bilateral series. 

No. It should be Rahan and Dhawan opening. Rohit shuld go back.

Khota Veteran

Khota

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, Cricketics said:

If you would have some other name, I might have understood but Rahane? Rahane hasn't done anything to play ahead and replace Rohit. 

I agree with you. Unforyunately the genius selectors dont give us any choice in this case. Rahane is not my first choie but lesser of the two evils.

Pollack Mentor

Pollack

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Rohit being a good ODI player is an illusion. It is as much an illusion as Rahane can adjust to ODIs or t20s is or Raina can be a test player after that century was.

Rohit hit the purple patch for 2 years. Indeed looking at his stats in those two years anyone would believe he is a good ODI player. But the harsh truth is he is good for nothing player.  Sorry. Nothing against him and more than happy to be proven wrong by him (Mumbai Indians fan hehe) but I certainly don't believe that he is a good ODI batsman. A batsman who has so many ifs to actually score isn't worth the risks. He is not even one someone whom you can trust 100 percent even on flatter conditions.Even on flatter conditions one needs to hope Rohit somehow gets set and then go berserk. 

Edited by Pollack
Khota Veteran

Khota

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, tweaker said:

Kohli has very good equations with some players, they will be in the team irrespective of performance, form, fitness etc

If true that is wrong.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...