Bumrah ruled out of test series versus SA due to minor lower back stress fracture, Umesh named as replacement

[Nikhil_cric]

23 minutes ago, express bowling said:

Every pacer sustains multiple injuries ... and more than half of them sustain frequent injuries.

 

But with Bumrah, it will be linked to his action.

 

So why have fast bowlers with more classical actions, like Pattinson, Starc, and Rabada been injured so many times. !!

Pattinsons earlier action was not efficient at all. And then he aggravated it over and over again just like Shane bond. Starc hasnt had a stress fracture since the age of 23 . Last six years he has bowled at high pace even in tests without any back issues. Rabada was a case of mismanagement. He was made to bowl at high intensity match after match acrossn formats at a tender age. 

[putrevus]

Thats why I kept saying India need more fast bowlers.You cannot just depend on Bumrah to be your ace.Are Saini and  Siraj in that class.They look like no11s with the bat.

[putrevus]

6 minutes ago, Nikhil_cric said:

Pattinsons earlier action was not efficient at all. And then he aggravated it over and over again just like Shane bond. Starc hasnt had a stress fracture since the age of 23 . Last six years he has bowled at high pace even in tests without any back issues. Rabada was a case of mismanagement. He was made to bowl at high intensity match after match acrossn formats at a tender age. 

Anderson's action was also termed very risky and injury waiting to happen, they totally changed his action and that led him to lose his rythm and confidence.He went back to his original action and has not looked back.

 

Bumrah's action is unique unless he is getting injured very often , no point in tinkering with it.

 

Denis Lillee's action is picture perfect for any youngster but he was also injured with back stress fracture.

Edited September 24, 2019 by putrevus

[ShoonyaSifar]

Terrible news. Hope the injury is not serious and Bumrah makes a quick recovery.

 

In hindsight, playing him in WI tests 6 weeks after a punishing schedule till the WC wasn’t the right call. 

[Suhaan]

Steyn mostly played without injuries up until 2016-17

[Nikhil_cric]

20 minutes ago, putrevus said:

Anderson's action was also termed very risky and injury waiting to happen, they totally changed his action and that led him to lose his rythm and confidence.He went back to his original action and has not looked back.

 

Bumrah's action is unique unless he is getting injured very often , no point in tinkering with it.

 

Denis Lillee's action is picture perfect for any youngster but he was also injured with back stress fracture.

Anderson barely qualifies as fast medium. Bumrah is a genuine quick in tests capable of clocking upto 95 mph. Besides, the English don't really understand fast bowling as well as the Aussies and the Saffers. 

[bowl_out]

Would have liked to see Siraj, but Umesh done well at home. So not a bad replacement

[putrevus]

37 minutes ago, Nikhil_cric said:

Anderson barely qualifies as fast medium. Bumrah is a genuine quick in tests capable of clocking upto 95 mph. Besides, the English don't really understand fast bowling as well as the Aussies and the Saffers. 

What about Lilee??He was out 18 months.Stress fracture to back is very common injury for fast bowlers.This notion that only fast bowler get injured is also silly.Anderson was quite nippy in his hey day too.

 

Bumrah will have to evolve and he will evolve .Hope he gets proper rest and rehab before playing again

Edited September 24, 2019 by putrevus

[LordPrabhzy]

ho gaya beda garak 

But i think we can use our spinners in home tests and give him time to rest till the next away test series.

[rkt.india]

15 hours ago, cowboysfan said:

where are the guys who said he should  play all formats?this was bound to happen with his action, I would  not play him in any bilateral LOIs  from now on.

what about the action of Cummins, Starc, Pattinson, Aaron, Umesh.  They all have had multiple stress fractures.  Stress fracture are normal for tearaways.  This is  the reason we need to build backups but idiot selectors brought Umesh back instead of trying new ones. 

[ShoonyaSifar]

48 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

what about the action of Cummins, Starc, Pattinson, Aaron, Umesh.  They all have had multiple stress fractures.  Stress fracture are normal for tearaways.  This is  the reason we need to build backups but idiot selectors brought Umesh back instead of trying new ones. 

As if selectors have any powers. The jokers who are our captain and coach currently have ZERO faith in any youngster. Both these idiots played as teenagers for India but suddenly have no time for grooming youngsters. And both of them shamelessly feel they have achieved something extraordinary in int'l cricket by winning a few bilateral series.

[Suhaan]

Wonder where does their accountability lie

After the recent WC debacle(yes it was ,when you were nearly invincible in league stages)

They have been constantly ignoring the upcoming talent both in batting and bowling for years now and there is no upper body which can reign in and question their decision

What's the point of going back to umesh ?do you have the balls to play them(Saini,Siraj and others) in alien conditions if not at home?

Edited September 25, 2019 by Suhaan

[Suhaan]

Not a single youngster feels secure these days

This is cricket's version of terrorism

[Suhaan]

21 minutes ago, Shaz1 said:

Ye sach hai mere dost

[putrevus]

what about the action of Cummins, Starc, Pattinson, Aaron, Umesh.  They all have had multiple stress fractures.  Stress fracture are normal for tearaways.  This is  the reason we need to build backups but idiot selectors brought Umesh back instead of trying new ones. 

What should selectors have done. If they brought in a newcomer what will happen to Umesh.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[G_B_]

considering its the home season where the spinners do the heavy work i dont think its a bad time to get injured.

 

Truth is with the amount of cricket being played India need to handle likes of Bumrah with care. A few months rest and he will be back as new.

 

I think in general the more we have specialists for every format the better. Its time to move even Shami to become a test only player to prolong his career (dont go by his official birth date)

[vvvslaxman]

Stress fracture is common for repetitive errort actions.  Action has to be smooth right from run up till delivery  to stay injury free. But Bumrah puts a lot of effort in his last stride which is the reason why he picked up the injury.  Ishant is the example of stress free action.

[Forever Indian]

Rohit comeback, then Umesh comeback... Next who? Dhoni comeback to tests 

[cricketfan28]

Umesh will shine.

[rkt.india]

19 hours ago, putrevus said:

What should selectors have done. If they brought in a newcomer what will happen to Umesh.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Umesh had his time. We need to find new alternatives. Someone who can do well in all conditions. Umesh isn't one. It's not certain that new one will do well but we will never know until they play.