Jump to content

Gambhir: 'There's no discussion; Kishan should be Rohit's opening partner in ODIs'

sage

By sage
in Cricket Talk

Recommended Posts

sage Grand Master

sage

Posted
Posted

https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/gautam-gambhir-wants-ishan-kishan-to-open-alongside-rohit-sharma-in-odis-1351607

 

Former batter doesn't pick KL Rahul in first-choice ODI XI: "Probably he'll be a back-up wicketkeeper and a back-up batter"

 

Gambhir believes Kishan should be persisted with.

 

"I'm amazed we're discussing this, because someone's got a double-hundred in the previous innings," Gambhir said when asked who he would like to see as Rohit's opening partner. "The discussion is over. It has to be Ishan Kishan. Someone who can get a double-hundred in those conditions against a reasonable attack - especially at [their] home - should play.

 

"He got what 200 by the 35th over mark? You can't look at anyone beyond Ishan Kishan. He has to be given a longer run. He can also keep wickets as well, so he can do two jobs for you. So for me, that discussion shouldn't be there. If someone else had got a double-hundred, I think we would've gone gung-ho over that individual, but it's not the case with Ishan Kishan. Because we still continue to talk about other players. For me, that debate is over."

 

 

Gambhir also believes Suryakumar Yadav can be an asset at No. 4, despite his 50-overs record so far not having been as prolific as his T20 numbers. In 16 ODIs, Suryakumar has made 384 runs with just two half-centuries. In his most recent outing in New Zealand, two of his three knocks ended up being scores of 4 and 6.

 

 

"It's very difficult to look beyond Rohit and Ishan Kishan to open the batting, Virat at three, Surya at four, [and] Shreyas at five, because he's been incredible in the last one-and-a-half years," Gambhir said of his ideal India XI. "Yes, he's had issues against the short ball, but he's been able to manage it. You can't be the best against everything but if you're able to manage it and got the numbers going for you, you can't look beyond Shreyas at No. 5 and Hardik [Pandya] at 6."
 

 

"Prithvi Shaw needs to be looked after"
Gambhir was also unequivocal in his support for Mumbai batter Prithvi Shaw, who finds himself in the cold yet again. Shaw hasn't played for India since July last year.

 

Asked if the perception that Shaw was hard to manage may have gone against him, Gambhir put the onus on the coaches and selectors to give him guidance and keep him in their plans.
 

 

"What are coaches there for? What are selectors there for?" Gambhir asked. "Not to just select the squad or probably to do those throw downs or make them ready for the game. Ultimately it's the selectors and coaches and management who should try and help these guys. Someone like a Prithvi Shaw, we all know the kind of talent he has. Probably they should get him on the right track and that is what one of the jobs of the management is.

 

 

"I feel that if that's the case [fitness and lifestyle issues], someone - whether it's Rahul Dravid or the chairman of selectors - should actually have a word with him, give him clarity and keep him around the group. People who should be on the right path should be around the group, so that they are monitored better. Because the moment you leave them apart, they can go all over the place.

 

 

"Someone like a Prithvi Shaw, the kind of start he had to his international career and the kind of talent he has, you back a player on talent. Yes, you have to look at the upbringing as well - where he comes from and the challenges he's had as well. It makes even more sense for the management and the selectors to keep him around the mix, and help him get on the right track."
 

 

Shouldn't there be onus on the player too?

 

"One-hundred percent," Gambhir said. "If you're dedicated and passionate enough to play for the country, you've got to be able to get all the parameters right, whether it's the fitness or discipline as well. It's got to be both ways. You've got to give a young boy at least one chance or a couple of chances, and if he still doesn't do that, then he's not passionate enough to play for the country and probably you can look beyond him.

 

"But if he's willing to put in the hard yards - and I know how destructive he can be; if he can go on to win games for you, whether it's trainers, management, head coach or chairman of selectors, all these guys should take the onus to try and get these young boys walk on the right path."
 
wanted_desi Veteran

wanted_desi

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, SRT100 said:

Ideally no Rohit or Virat.

 

That frees up two positions and makes India infinitely stronger.

 

Just kick them all: Rohit, KL and Kohli. I don't care they scored many runs in the past, just so tired seeing them now. 

SRT100 Grand Master

SRT100

Posted
Posted
4 hours ago, wanted_desi said:

 

Just kick them all: Rohit, KL and Kohli. I don't care they scored many runs in the past, just so tired seeing them now. 

 

Proven stats padders, failing/slow scoring in WC matches and too old now. Their records and meaningless and insignificant in this context.

Vijy Grand Master

Vijy

Posted
Posted
23 minutes ago, sage said:

 

Knives out for KL :phehe:

 

irrespective of how many knives are out, this git has powerful backers in the highest echelons. he ain't going nowhere sadly.

raki05 Grand Master

raki05

Posted
Posted

https://lm.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fin.mashable.com%2Fculture%2F44620%2Fbcci-former-cricketers-upset-with-loud-mouth-gautam-gambhir-after-he-criticised-team-india-heres-wha&h=AT2ZgmGJS7Zgi-GpvCUA_1mFa3saVfFdd7_FYfVDDgiJyOKojLPPIkMQlCj46vc0Qaje0nlSH8hc_QsNiY4hzJdneVi4mOMVGlPd-2ngAYNL2XPzd6KEc82o0y8NqryEXawi

 

 

 

These bcci personal are real clown . Now they are not happy of Gambhir's criticism of Senior player.

 

Vijy Grand Master

Vijy

Posted
Posted
22 minutes ago, raki05 said:

https://lm.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fin.mashable.com%2Fculture%2F44620%2Fbcci-former-cricketers-upset-with-loud-mouth-gautam-gambhir-after-he-criticised-team-india-heres-wha&h=AT2ZgmGJS7Zgi-GpvCUA_1mFa3saVfFdd7_FYfVDDgiJyOKojLPPIkMQlCj46vc0Qaje0nlSH8hc_QsNiY4hzJdneVi4mOMVGlPd-2ngAYNL2XPzd6KEc82o0y8NqryEXawi

 

 

 

These bcci personal are real clown . Now they are not happy of Gambhir's criticism of Senior player.

 

they should go into a circus

zen Grand Master

zen

Posted
Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, nevada said:

So a double century is no good apparently. Kishan should have tried for triple century. He had the chance and blew it. 

 

If Kishan had hit a triple, he would probably not even be in the squad (Karun Nair for e.g.) :phehe:

Edited by zen

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...