Indian players whose careers are at stake this England tour

[Ankit_sharma03]

Note: This isnt my choice, this is how i see Indian cricket working

 

Will start with Careers that are over and ill be highly shocked if they comeback now

 

 

1. Raina- Said during IPL the way he was handling fast bowling he shud not play for India anymore , but i thought ENG -IReland doesnt have bowlers to trouble to my surprise IReland bounced him out n england spun him out. To comeback for any player its important how he does in domestic n most importantly how badly others fails to. Raina might do well in domestic but their is enough talent now to keep him away

 

2. Parthiv - When u drop someone its important to check has he improved n then pick him n with parthiv n even Raina selectors shud realise they didnt so what did they check??? Parthiv in SA showed that he still was an Awfull keeper. 

With karthik, Saha , pant, kishen, samson....... we dnt have to see him Again 

 

Now the careers who are on thin ice

• For them what matters if they perform they keep their place, if they dnt they are on thin ICE and if others perform aiming for same role.....they can be shown the door 

 

1. Dhoni- Many may think he will never be dropped but no one is indispensable . The more ur perfomance goes down the more nearer u get towards getting dropped. Some one will get extra rope and some wont but that rope will end one day. Dhoni batting isnt helping him but his contribution to captaincy, fitness, wicket keeping n helping younger players is saving him. 

He is a large figure in Indian cricket so for him to be dropped now Karthik n pant has to perform. If karthik has a gr8 england tour ....dhoni place will be in bother and then possible he might be a series away from being dropped. Same is with Pant he has to perform whenever he gets a chance and he is an impact player.....but for him to secure that place he has to show gr8 consistency. So as of now m expecting karthik to be more of problem for dhoni then Pant. 

 

2. Murali Vijay- I have no doubt in my mind if vijay fails england tour .....we ll see the last of him. He hasnt had gr8 last 1-2 yrs and his age wnt help him either. With the emergance of Shaw n mayank .....i doubt selectors will back him if he fails in England . 

 

3. Dinesh Karthik- A bad series in england n it can be curtains for him. DK for all his inconsistency will always be under microscope. A failure with gloves will keep him on benches as then he ll have to compete with other batsman for the role of only batsman. If he fails with both bat n gloves .....we might not see him again for which also Pant has to perform. If pant doesnt perform n so does DK fail, DK might still live on for a series or two. 

 

Now the career which still has oxygen left in them and wud only be under threat if they do badly in england but just under threat 

 

1. Dhawan the test cricketer- he aint going anywere 

2. Ishant sharma- All he has to do is bowl that one gr8 spell n he ll be their to play his 100 test, leave ur hopes he aint going anywhere till aussie tour ends. Yes a failure on both tour will lead him to be dropped . 

3. Pujara- A failure in england wud only mean he might be only seen in subcontinent where his place cnt be questioned but cnt say with kohli. 

4. Shami- Same as Ishant sharma. Need atleast 2 bad tours 

5. Ashwin- Will have the same fate as pujara if he fails actually a lil better as his batting might come to rescue him.

6. Jadeja- If kuldeep does well he might have to compete with ashwin in future for 2nd spinner spot overseas. At home his place cnt be questioned. 

 

Edited July 25, 2018 by Ankit_sharma03

[Rasgulla]

Dhoni out of that list. How can anyone remove on field captain  until Shastri and his chamcha Kohli is there he is good. 

[vvvslaxman]

KL Rahul lol

[Rasgulla]

1 minute ago, vvvslaxman said:

KL Rahul lol

How could u remove self proclaimed king ? He is doing well in his photoshoots

 

 

 

[Switchblade]

With Saha being injured I don’t see DK getting dropped as he is an experienced wk batsman and whatever I have seen of Virat he prefers experienced players so I see Dk at least getting a run of an year at least.

Dhoni will be there till 2019 WC for sure.

[GolGappe]

You just never know with this team management and current batch of selectors as they apply different standards for different players.

 

One would think Dhoni would be history by now after being a complete turd as batsman but he is as safe as ever.

 

[mancalledsting]

Tests 

Ashwin (overseas test career)

Pujara 

Dhawan 

DK (although is career been on the line ever since he debuted)

[Rasgulla]

2 hours ago, UnknownGenius said:

 

Ashwin - Indias greatest ever test cricketer

Agreed with rest of them but Greatest ever ? Kya bol raha hai bhai

2 hours ago, UnknownGenius said:

Raina - India's greatest ever IPL pproduct and a key cog in winning the 2011 world cup 

He is gone now i ll say.. Yuvi and Raina can have parties together 

Edited July 26, 2018 by Rasgulla

[SK_IH]

@Ankit_sharma03  msd's thin ice has melted long back, if his place in the side is due to intangibles like fitness and  helping younger players , then god save us 

also for either pant or dk to get in his place, msd's lack of performance should also be criterion

thirdly for DK and Pant to peform, they need to get matches as well which they dont and dont be so ignorant that dk's performance in test will help displace dhoni from loi teams

i am also one of big fans of dhoni like you but one has to concede he has no place in either side now,consistency will not be a problem with him even now but we have seen runs from him are not threat for opposition anymore

 

Quote

Dhawan the test cricketer

2. Ishant sharma

3. Pujara

4. Shami

5. Ashwin.

6. Jadeja

Another ignorant post considering the current regime, all the above mentioned players are not going anywhere

[Stan AF]

ODIs:

 

Dhoni/Raina (Much like Ashwin/jadeja odi drop last year)

 

Tests:

Pujara (Getting to the point of ridiculous is his slow approach)

Vijay

[Ashwin/Jadeja's] overseas career. With kuldeeps intro their indian sojourn as well.

Dinesh Karthik (Unfortunately, rishabh pant is also breathing down his neck). But im picking him to do well.

Umesh needs to pull up his socks and deliver.

 

[Ankit_sharma03]

1 hour ago, SK_IH said:

@Ankit_sharma03  msd's thin ice has melted long back, if his place in the side is due to intangibles like fitness and  helping younger players , then god save us 

As i said in the 1st line of the post - its not how i think its how team thinks n sooner or later if he goes like this it ll end . It happened with rohit the test cricketer to 

1 hour ago, SK_IH said:

also for either pant or dk to get in his place, msd's lack of performance should also be criterion

N for that Pant n DK has to perform also, it works 2 ways 

1 hour ago, SK_IH said:

thirdly for DK and Pant to peform, they need to get matches as well which they dont and dont be so ignorant that dk's performance in test will help displace dhoni from loi teams

Dk has eng tour now 

Pant will also get his chances sooner or later 

1 hour ago, SK_IH said:

i am also one of big fans of dhoni like you but one has to concede he has no place in either side now,consistency will not be a problem with him even now but we have seen runs from him are not threat for opposition anymore

 

Another ignorant post considering the current regime, all the above mentioned players are not going anywhere

Bhai maine likha hai to hai ki even failure wnt cost them their place as of now .......dhyaan se dekh

10 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

 

Now the career which still has oxygen left in them and wud only be under threat if they do badly in england but just under threat 

 

1. Dhawan the test cricketer- he aint going anywere 

2. Ishant sharma- All he has to do is bowl that one gr8 spell n he ll be their to play his 100 test, leave ur hopes he aint going anywhere till aussie tour ends. Yes a failure on both tour will lead him to be dropped . 

3. Pujara- A failure in england wud only mean he might be only seen in subcontinent where his place cnt be questioned but cnt say with kohli. 

4. Shami- Same as Ishant sharma. Need atleast 2 bad tours 

5. Ashwin- Will have the same fate as pujara if he fails actually a lil better as his batting might come to rescue him.

6. Jadeja- If kuldeep does well he might have to compete with ashwin in future for 2nd spinner spot overseas. At home his place cnt be questioned. 

 

 

[SK_IH]

41 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

As i said in the 1st line of the post - its not how i think its how team thinks n sooner or later if he goes like this it ll end . It happened with rohit the test cricketer to 

N for that Pant n DK has to perform also, it works 2 ways 

Dk has eng tour now 

Pant will also get his chances sooner or later 

Bhai maine likha hai to hai ki even failure wnt cost them their place as of now .......dhyaan se dekh

 

regarding dhoni you have skirted the fact that Dhoni is getting consistent chances and others are not getting enough chnaces consistently to fail or succeed

[Ankit_sharma03]

23 minutes ago, SK_IH said:

regarding dhoni you have skirted the fact that Dhoni is getting consistent chances and others are not getting enough chnaces consistently to fail or succeed

so it will end soon if it continues

[SK_IH]

17 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

so it will end soon if it continues

ok i dont think so, because it has already continued for too long 

[Switchblade]

5 hours ago, Rasgulla said:

Agreed with rest of them but Greatest ever ? Kya bol raha hai bhai

He is gone now i ll say.. Yuvi and Raina can have parties together 

Uski dunia Ipl aur Csk tak limited hai.

[Switchblade]

@Ankit_sharma03 Dhoni won’t be going he will be there till the next WC no way this management is dropping him.

[sourab10forever]

Rahul-Forever on thin Ice.

[speedheat]

6 hours ago, Rasgulla said:

Agreed with rest of them but Greatest ever ? Kya bol raha hai bhai

He is gone now i ll say.. Yuvi and Raina can have parties together 

While dhoni can carry drinks for them in those parties .......... BOT

[Oldhere]

I just dont know, why suddenly whole of ICF has gotten Pujara as part of the gang.

 

Till last year, whole of ICF was after KOhli as for him Pujara was never a certainty andKohli even dropped him becoz of his strike rate.

 

But at that most of the ICFers supported Pujara as from media it seemed like Kohli's decision and Kumble was supporting Pujara.

 

But now, just becoz Kohli's strike rate comment is looking true day by day. Whole of ICF has decided that Pujara is in team because he is part of the gang.

 

Bhai, aakhir itni jaldi kaise sab badal sakta hai.

[R!TTER]

No one's going anywhere, god save Kuldeep and KL