Jump to content

Virat Kohli has been Team Captain for over 2 years yet not even one young batsman has flourished under him. Why?


Recommended Posts

16 hours ago, ShoonyaSifar said:

Like it or not, Dhoni’s presence in LOIs has hurt the development of this team. This is still not Kohli’s team unlike the Test unit. 

 

How can a captain, who looks far more assured in Tests (tougher format), look so woeful in LOIs. While Kohli should be blamed for prostration before Dhoni, what to say of Dhoni. In his own days as captain, that joker would not let a single senior player, each of them ATGs by then,  interfere with his decisions. Here he is, shamelessly hogging limelight (only when we win) while Kohli fields in the deep.

 

When Kohli does eventually get sacked as LOI captain after the WC, he would rue his decision of showing blind faith in Dhoni as the biggest mistake of his captaincy career.

Test team is even worse in terms of player development . Hes equally bad in Tests 

Link to comment
On 3/18/2019 at 12:42 PM, sandsaims said:

Lot of people talk about Sachin being a selfish batsman but dont see how selfish a cricketer Kohli is, he doesnt like any gun Batsmen coming up and likes being the only Star in the team.

Ya he is asking all the youngsters to get out. How did he allow rohit sharma ? Is it because bunty ? 

Link to comment

Just feel that they did not allow anybody an extended run lest we see how capable the younger batsman are when pitted against dhoni, Rohit and dhawan.

 

Mayank did extremely  well, vihari was good, Shankar was revelation in 2nd avatar, pant was phenomenal in tests .

 

Dhawan - downhill

Rahane - downhill

Dhoni- nadir

Rohit - so so

 

Link to comment

To bring newbies,drop oldies first.

Rohit,Dhawan & Dhoni have too much power & can't be dropped.

Rayudud has the backbone of MSK Prasad .

The bowling unit has transformed under Kohli. So,he does know what he is doing in that aspect.

The batting is in shambles due to petty politics of selectors & CSK Lobby.

 

 

 

Edited by diehardpacer
Link to comment
On 3/19/2019 at 4:21 PM, jusarrived said:

Test team is even worse in terms of player development . Hes equally bad in Tests 

Correct. The Australia series win happened despite, not because of Kohli's captaincy. The player who he nearly destroyed (Pujara) was the difference maker in the series. 

Link to comment
On 3/19/2019 at 10:32 PM, gattaca said:

Ya he is asking all the youngsters to get out. How did he allow rohit sharma ? Is it because bunty ? 

Rohit was given lifeline by Dhoni. Despite his inconsistency, Dhoni kept harping on how big a match winner he could be. Once he turned opener, Rohit's luck turned around. He was already a successful ODI player by the time Kohli took over as captain.

Link to comment

This isn't just a Kohli thing, he can be held responsible for the present but the rot started much earlier.

 

For limited overs: Rohit started playing long back & got umpteen chances to settle down. Dhawan made the opening slot his own. ICF's wonderboy Rahul got chances in all formats but was poor in middle order. Dhoni can't be budged. The remaining 1-2 slots weren't taken up with long term planning in mind. That has been true post Raina & Yuvi's end of form which have been years into the making but we never moved on.

 

This culture of carrying baggage needs to change and has to start with the washerman. I'm not a fan of Pant's keeping but there had to be alternatives tried 2 years back.

Edited by Clarke
Link to comment

There is only one slot available for a new batsman, the No.4 slot. Dhawan has been going through bad form but his track record in ICC tournaments is phenomenal and he is worth persisting with. KL Rahul was given chances at No.4 but he blew them. Rayudu has done well in that position whenever he got picked. Kedhar Jadhav has done a good job as a middle order hitter/finisher at 5 and also can chip in with some overs. Not many chances were given to others. 

Link to comment
On 3/18/2019 at 7:40 PM, mani sha said:

he is a bad captain

doeent know how to spot talent

feels everybody is like him

 

after we exit before the final four in wc , i hope odi and t20 captaincy taken away from him

 

Vijay Shankar looks captaincy material 

He is a bad captain ? :hysterical: Thanks for the laughs.

 

India won 75 % of ODI matches under him in 2018 including series in Australia and South Africa(5-1) where we used to get whitewashed repeatedly and ended as best team of the year. 

Edited by kubrickian
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...