How to fit Ishan Kishan in ODI XI without losing balance ?

[express bowling]

1 minute ago, rkt.india said:

Sky is yet to establish himself in ODIs. Hardik should bat at 5. Sky 6. While Pant too can be a match winner. 

 

Pant can easily come in at 5. It should depend on who performs better from now on. 

[rkt.india]

21 minutes ago, express bowling said:

 

Pant can easily come in at 5. It should depend on who performs better from now on. 

I want only batters who are match winners. Iyer has done well and is consistent but hasn't shown the ability to win matches. Had the chance in the second odi. WC in India is going to be high scoring so six hitters are required. 

[express bowling]

3 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

I want only batters who are match winners. Iyer has done well and is consistent but hasn't shown the ability to win matches. Had the chance in the second odi. WC in India is going to be high scoring so six hitters are required. 

 

I am all for Pant

[Need4Speed]

Rohit and Rahul to get injured..problem solved..hope Sundar stays fit..

Also..I seriously hope Mohsin Khan comes to full fitness and form and start batting too..will give much needed balance..so we can accomodate Ravi Bishnoi

 

1)Rohit/Gill(preferably Gill but we know Rohit will play)

2)Kishan(Dhawan shud be out now)

3)Kohli

4)Iyer/Samson

5)Pant/SKY/Rahul(want Rahul to be out though…SKY yet to convince me in ODIs as well)

6)Pandya

7)Jadeja/Sundar/Axar(prefer Sundar here)

8)Sundar/Ashwin/-Bishnoi(if Mohsin is ready)

9)Mohsin/Bumrah(if Mohsin plays Bumrah bats lower)
10)Siraj/Prasidh/Mohsin

11)Umran(seeing he is improving and only express pace option..want him certainly in team)

Mohsin will also be handy too if Pandya is injured he can bat after spinners

 

Injury/fitness concerns:

Rohit

Rahul

Pandya

Sundar

Bumrah

 

Assuming them in full fitness and form,,my bowlers:

Bumrah

Umran

Mohsin

Pandya

Sundar

Bishnoi

 

ye faad denge..can defend slightly beliw par score like Pak bowling..

so batting thodi upar neeche chal jaayegi..apne ko bowling aisi penetrative chahiye hogi

Edited December 10, 2022 by Need4Speed

[rkt.india]

1 hour ago, express bowling said:

 

I am all for Pant

it's right time now just to limit the pool to 20 players and let them play as a group as many matches as possible instead of new players in every series. 

[rkt.india]

9 minutes ago, Need4Speed said:

Rohit and Rahul to get injured..problem solved..hope Sundar stays fit..

Also..I seriously hope Mohsin Khan comes to full fitness and form and start batting too..will give much needed balance..so we can accomodate Ravi Bishnoi

 

1)Rohit/Gill(preferably Gill but we know Rohit will play)

2)Kishan(Dhawan shud be out now)

3)Kohli

4)Iyer/Samson

5)Pant/SKY/Rahul(want Rahul to be out though…SKY yet to convince me in ODIs as well)

6)Pandya

7)Jadeja/Sundar/Axar(prefer Sundar here)

8)Sundar/Ashwin/-Bishnoi(if Mohsin is ready)

9)Mohsin/Bumrah(if Mohsin plays Bumrah bats lower)
10)Siraj/Prasidh/Mohsin

11)Umran(seeing he is improving and only express pace option..want him certainly in team)

Mohsin will also be handy too if Pandya is injured he can bat after spinners

 

Injury/fitness concerns:

Rohit

Rahul

Pandya

Sundar

Bumrah

 

Assuming them in full fitness and form,,my bowlers:

Bumrah

Umran

Mohsin

Pandya

Sundar

Bishnoi

 

ye faad denge..can defend slightly beliw par score like Pak bowling..

so batting thodi upar neeche chal jaayegi..apne ko bowling aisi penetrative chahiye hogi

People should not put Mohsin as he is yet to play any international game. Bumrah, Siraj, Prasidh, Umran, Kuldeep sen are the options right now. 

[Need4Speed]

33 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

People should not put Mohsin as he is yet to play any international game. Bumrah, Siraj, Prasidh, Umran, Kuldeep sen are the options right now. 

I understand but I am kinda wishing he delivers on the promise he has shown as he will help us 3 fold:

Hit the deck bowler

Left Armer

Batting capability..as I doubt Pnadya to be a consistent AR esp in ODIs due to injury concerns

[Arvind32]

If there is no nepotism and politics , this can be the team 

Gill 

Sky 

Kohli 

Iyer ( Based on consistent performances otherwise other youngster) 

Sanju Samson 

Pandya 

Washington Sundar ( Better bowler than Jadeja  can be used at power play overs ) 

Bishnoi 

Bumrah 

Siraj 

Mohsin/Arshdeep/Umran ( perfer left hand bowler ) 

 

[putrevus]

Siraj should not be playing white ball cricket.They need to give more chances to Umran.

[Pollack]

Rohit (He will play no matter what)

Ishaan/Shaw

Kohli

SKY/Iyer

KLRahul (Dravid quota) / Samson

Pandya

Sundar

Kuldeep Yadav/Bishnoi

 

Remaining 3 positions can be filled with suitable combinations from below pool of pace bowlers subject to availability and form and fitness :

Bumrah, kuldeep, Umran, Siraj, Prasidh, Mohsin, Tyagi, Arshdeep,Thakur, Chahar, Shami

 

 

 

 

 

 

[BacktoCricaddict]

9 hours ago, express bowling said:

Make Hardik the captain.

 

Then

 

1. Gill

2. Kishan ( wk )

3. Kohli

4. Shreyas

5. SKY / Pant

6. Hardik ( c )

7. Jadeja

8. Washington

9. Bumrah

10. Umran / Sen / Kuldeep Y 

11. Siraj / Prasidh 

 

[BacktoCricaddict]

3 hours ago, putrevus said:

Siraj should not be playing white ball cricket.They need to give more chances to Umran.

 

While I agree in principle, would it be a monetary hit for Siraj?  He is a good white-ball bowler and might feel wronged. 

[QuarantineTormentino]

My post 2023 World Cup xi:

 

Kishan

Shaw

Gill 

Pant (wk)

Hardik (c)

Samson/Parag

Sundar

Bishnoi

Mohsin

Bumrah

Umran

 

 

 

 

[rkt.india]

7 hours ago, putrevus said:

Siraj should not be playing white ball cricket.They need to give more chances to Umran.

Siraj is attacking and a wicket taker. Must for ODIs.

[vvvslaxman]

This discussion is only applicable for fans. For selectors the discussion will be along the lines "How to exclude Isan Kishan from the set up"

[jf1gp_1]

Pant can easily do what Ishan did yesterday. One just needs to keep faith in him. I keep hearing Pant is not grabbing his chances, lets understand what we have done to him. First Ravi announced he is our all format keeper. In t20 wc 21 even in pakistan game he got some runs. After than its been Ishan, Dinesh and him. He has been travelling with team for past 6 months. Give the guy a break and a long consistent run he will come good.  

[jf1gp_1]

12 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

This discussion is only applicable for fans. For selectors the discussion will be along the lines "How to exclude Isan Kishan from the set up"

and umran malik for Bhuvi

[deepdynamo]

People are bringing in even Shaw and he is not even in Top 10 for the five top order slots right now.

 

Frankly, we have no idea who will be the top 5. Maybe it will be more clear near to WC.





 

[nevada]

Karun Nair ODI version will be the most likely outcome. 

[Bigg Brother]

There is no need to fit him. He should be sure starter. Nobody in last decade has pummeled Bangladesh like this. DK was the one but it was T20. It was Shewagsque dhulai. A lefty opener who can keep wickets also, good fielder,too. Only stupid TM like of Indian team can bench him otherwise he should be in XI for next few series. Dhawan is done and dusted. Also Rohit too. Kishan-Gill/Shaw is the way to go.